Saw this topic on the fifa forums about what Gerrard's rating should be in fifa 12, the topic strayed off a bit and people began to debate who was the better player. I for one feel Ballack's the better player, i'm sure many will diasgree but hey 
+21
Ricardo
fluffy_kittens
Mustangt125
Danny
Carlos Jenkinson
GCU
Cadbury
Theo Filippo
Fanatic
dena
Cornholio
Marvin
Trig
Scuba Steve
Zzonked
Jamie
Barton
Dean
luke.
Cameron.
Sean
25 posters
Ballack vs Gerrard
Poll
The better individual?
- [ 11 ]
[28%]
- [ 26 ]
- [65%]
- [ 3 ]
- [7%]
Total Votes: 40
Sean-
- Posts : 33857
Age : 30
Why is Ballack better?
Cameron.-
- Posts : 10955
Age : 30
Supports : Manchester United.
Guest- Guest
Overall in their career.kyro7 wrote:Right now?
luke.-
- Posts : 32310
Age : 30
Location : Belfast
Gerrard will win due to all the Liverpool fans on here. That's a guarantee.
Not taking a dig or nothing.
#justsaying
Not taking a dig or nothing.
#justsaying
Guest- Guest
Well, to me Gerrard is one of the best midfielders I've ever seen.19Jones19v wrote:Overall in their career.kyro7 wrote:Right now?
Both have had great careers but I'd pick Gerrard personally.
Guest- Guest
luke. wrote:Gerrard will win due to all the Liverpool fans on here. That's a guarantee.
Not taking a dig or nothing.
#justsaying
It's not twitter ffs.
Guest- Guest
luke. wrote:Gerrard will win due to all the Liverpool fans on here. That's a guarantee.
Not taking a dig or nothing.
#justsaying
ANd you're going to vote for Ballack cuz he played for Chelsea
#justsaying
Guest- Guest
Cunt.luke. wrote:Gerrard will win due to all the Liverpool fans on here. That's a guarantee.
Not taking a dig or nothing.
#justsaying
#justsaying
luke.-
- Posts : 32310
Age : 30
Location : Belfast
Bogdan wrote:luke. wrote:Gerrard will win due to all the Liverpool fans on here. That's a guarantee.
Not taking a dig or nothing.
#justsaying
ANd you're going to vote for Ballack cuz he played for Chelsea
#justsaying
I haven't voted yet, I'm mulling over it.
Guest- Guest
luke. wrote:Gerrard will win due to all the Liverpool fans on here. That's a guarantee.
Not taking a dig or nothing.
#justsaying
This isn't twitter you utter pleb.
luke.-
- Posts : 32310
Age : 30
Location : Belfast
Scott wrote:luke. wrote:Gerrard will win due to all the Liverpool fans on here. That's a guarantee.
Not taking a dig or nothing.
#justsaying
This isn't twitter you utter pleb.
Oh sorry, I didn't realise that at all. I mean, I didn't enter www.the-playmaker.com into my browser, and came into this thread.
Or did I?
Dean-
- Posts : 9761
Ballack better than Gerrard on pure ability alone? Come off it. Fucking no chance.
Barton-
- Formerly known as : JMB_94
Posts : 10066
Age : 30
Scott wrote:luke. wrote:Gerrard will win due to all the Liverpool fans on here. That's a guarantee.
Not taking a dig or nothing.
#justsaying
This isn't twitter you utter pleb.
What i was thinking.
#justsaying
Guest- Guest
Hey hey hey stop taking digs at Luke here and I do realise the biasness cos of the majority of Liverpool fans, but yeah thought I'd put it up anyway.
stop taking digs at Luke here and I do realise the biasness cos of the majority of Liverpool fans, but yeah thought I'd put it up anyway.
Dean-
- Posts : 9761
luke. wrote:Gerrard will win due to all the Liverpool fans on here. That's a guarantee.
Not taking a dig or nothing.
#justsaying
And Gerrard should win, due to actually being 'better'. I'm a Liverpool fan and I'm not voting Gerrard because he's a Liverpool player, I'm voting him because he's better.
Jamie-
- Posts : 24047
Age : 63
Location : Thiago
Supports : That Catalan club
Ballack is very underrated career wise imo. Not sure if it his peak he's as good as Gerrard but if not he's close. Both were absolutely superb.
luke.-
- Posts : 32310
Age : 30
Location : Belfast
Decided to go for Can't decide out of slight bias.
Love Ballack, shouldn't have been axed, wish we renewed his contract
Love Ballack, shouldn't have been axed, wish we renewed his contract
luke.-
- Posts : 32310
Age : 30
Location : Belfast
Dean wrote:luke. wrote:Gerrard will win due to all the Liverpool fans on here. That's a guarantee.
Not taking a dig or nothing.
#justsaying
And Gerrard should win, due to actually being 'better'. I'm a Liverpool fan and I'm not voting Gerrard because he's a Liverpool player, I'm voting him because he's better.
I never said Ballack was better though, just stating that because we have a majority of LFC fans here, Gerrard will win, just like in most (if not all) of all the other LFC player vs other player comparison threads we get.
Guest- Guest
luke. wrote:Scott wrote:luke. wrote:Gerrard will win due to all the Liverpool fans on here. That's a guarantee.
Not taking a dig or nothing.
#justsaying
This isn't twitter you utter pleb.
Oh sorry, I didn't realise that at all. I mean, I didn't enter www.the-playmaker.com into my browser, and came into this thread.
Or did I?
Guest- Guest
Surely, because Kyro is a man utd fan, he hates liverpool so must vote for Ballack?
Barton-
- Formerly known as : JMB_94
Posts : 10066
Age : 30
I've only ever seen Ballack play for Chelsea, and Germany acouple of times. Can someone tell me if he was at his peak with Chelsea?
Guest- Guest
I'm not biased.Cam wrote:Surely, because Kyro is a man utd fan, he hates liverpool so must vote for Ballack?
It's not a massive difference in their career's but I respect Gerrard for what an amazing player he's been, he gets my vote.
Guest- Guest
JMB_94 wrote:I've only ever seen Ballack play for Chelsea, and Germany acouple of times. Can someone tell me if he was at his peak with Chelsea?
Nah, Bayern Munich.
Guest- Guest
He was pretty darn good with Leverkusen as well.
Guest- Guest
kyro7 wrote:I'm not biased.Cam wrote:Surely, because Kyro is a man utd fan, he hates liverpool so must vote for Ballack?
It's not a massive difference in their career's but I respect Gerrard for what an amazing player he's been, he gets my vote.
I know
Just an example
Dean-
- Posts : 9761
I can't think of any single midfielder better than Gerrard in the last 20 years. Zidane is probably the only one in my book.
Jamie-
- Posts : 24047
Age : 63
Location : Thiago
Supports : That Catalan club
JMB_94 wrote:I've only ever seen Ballack play for Chelsea, and Germany acouple of times. Can someone tell me if he was at his peak with Chelsea?
Nah he was a shadow of the player at Chelsea.
Zzonked-
- Posts : 24290
Age : 32
Can't decide off the top of my head, don't really care enough to think about it any more.
