I was recently having a debate with a friend over whether Scholes or Gerrard was better. I chose Scholes and started thinking was he the greatest English player ever. Scholes has been consistently great throughout his career. I know I 'm biased but I'd like to see if you agree and if you don't who do you think is the greatest English player ever?
+20
luke.
dena
El Jefe
Jordi
Carlos Jenkinson
samiz
Harrold
GK01
moscowmadeit3
ResurrectionRooney
chiboygeorge
Mouse
Zzonked
Kuled
Steadman
Demba Ba
Jord
Theo Filippo
Scouser_Dave
RoryOB94
24 posters
Scholes?
Poll
Is Scholes the greatest English player ever?
- [ 8 ]
[30%]
- [ 19 ]
- [70%]
Total Votes: 27
Poll closed
Poll closed
RoryOB94-
- Posts : 310
Age : 30
Supports : Manchester United
Theo Filippo-
- Formerly known as : Filippo Inzaghi
Posts : 21636
Age : 30
Hes far superior to Gerrard that is for sure.
Jord-
- Formerly known as : SUPAH BURNLEY!
Posts : 33665
Location : Equestria
Supports : Liverpool FC
Come now.. There are a few English players better than Scholes.
Demba Ba-
- Formerly known as : cheesy
Posts : 4142
Location : Scotland
He's arguably the greatest English player of his generation, but there have been greater players in the past such as Charlton and Moore.
No doubt that he's the best midfielder England have had though, as he was streaks ahead of Lampard and Gerrard when in his prime.
No doubt that he's the best midfielder England have had though, as he was streaks ahead of Lampard and Gerrard when in his prime.
RoryOB94-
- Posts : 310
Age : 30
Supports : Manchester United
Who do you think is then?Scouser_Dave wrote:No.
Scouser_Dave-
- Posts : 7498
Filippo Inzaghi wrote:Hes far superior to Gerrard that is for sure.
Didn't expect that one from you. Shocked
Steadman-
- Posts : 6134
Age : 32
Location : London
Supports : I have humor, yes.
I agree, the greatest. 
Scouser_Dave-
- Posts : 7498
RoryOB94 wrote:Who do you think is then?Scouser_Dave wrote:No.
Gerrard, with Lampard not far behind him.
Theo Filippo-
- Formerly known as : Filippo Inzaghi
Posts : 21636
Age : 30
Its not even debatableScouser_Dave wrote:Filippo Inzaghi wrote:Hes far superior to Gerrard that is for sure.
Didn't expect that one from you. Shocked
Theo Filippo-
- Formerly known as : Filippo Inzaghi
Posts : 21636
Age : 30
Scouser_Dave wrote:RoryOB94 wrote:Who do you think is then?Scouser_Dave wrote:No.
Gerrard, with Lampard not far behind him.
Demba Ba-
- Formerly known as : cheesy
Posts : 4142
Location : Scotland
Scouser_Dave wrote:RoryOB94 wrote:Who do you think is then?Scouser_Dave wrote:No.
Gerrard, with Lampard not far behind him.
Are you trying to argue that Gerrard and Lampard are both better than Scholes at his best?
Kuled-
- Posts : 55235
Age : 28
LOLScouser_Dave wrote:RoryOB94 wrote:Who do you think is then?Scouser_Dave wrote:No.
Gerrard, with Lampard not far behind him.
RoryOB94-
- Posts : 310
Age : 30
Supports : Manchester United
Seriously? I could understand if you said someone like Charlton etc. but Gerrard and Lampard?Scouser_Dave wrote:RoryOB94 wrote:Who do you think is then?Scouser_Dave wrote:No.
Gerrard, with Lampard not far behind him.
Scouser_Dave-
- Posts : 7498
RoryOB94 wrote:Seriously? I could understand if you said someone like Charlton etc. but Gerrard and Lampard?Scouser_Dave wrote:RoryOB94 wrote:Who do you think is then?Scouser_Dave wrote:No.
Gerrard, with Lampard not far behind him.
Thought you were talking about English midfielder's. If you think Scholes is the greatest English player of all time then
Zzonked-
- Posts : 24290
Age : 32
cheesy wrote:He's arguably the greatest English player of his generation, but there have been greater players in the past such as Charlton and Moore.
No doubt that he's the best midfielder England have had though, as he was streaks ahead of Lampard and Gerrard when in his prime.
I would say there is plenty of doubt tbh.
Demba Ba-
- Formerly known as : cheesy
Posts : 4142
Location : Scotland
Scouser_Dave wrote:RoryOB94 wrote:Seriously? I could understand if you said someone like Charlton etc. but Gerrard and Lampard?Scouser_Dave wrote:RoryOB94 wrote:Who do you think is then?Scouser_Dave wrote:No.
Gerrard, with Lampard not far behind him.
Thought you were talking about English midfielder's. If you think Scholes is the greatest English player of all time then
You can't laugh at him if you honestly think Gerrard and Lampard are two of the greatest ever English midfielders either.
Mouse-
- Posts : 17009
Age : 28
Location : Cymru
Supports : Sweden Women's National Handball Team
Charlton...Moore.....John Barnes 
Scouser_Dave-
- Posts : 7498
cheesy wrote:Scouser_Dave wrote:RoryOB94 wrote:Seriously? I could understand if you said someone like Charlton etc. but Gerrard and Lampard?Scouser_Dave wrote:RoryOB94 wrote:Who do you think is then?
Gerrard, with Lampard not far behind him.
Thought you were talking about English midfielder's. If you think Scholes is the greatest English player of all time then
You can't laugh at him if you honestly think Gerrard and Lampard are two of the greatest ever English midfielders either.
Mine isn't anywhere near as laughable as thinking Scholes is the greatest English player of all time
RoryOB94-
- Posts : 310
Age : 30
Supports : Manchester United
John Barnes is a fake EnglishmanMc Babel wrote:Charlton...Moore.....John Barnes
chiboygeorge-
- Posts : 3517
I don't really think any English midfielder has a career as great as Scholes.. 
chiboygeorge-
- Posts : 3517
So who is then? Gerrard?Scouser_Dave wrote:cheesy wrote:Scouser_Dave wrote:RoryOB94 wrote:Seriously? I could understand if you said someone like Charlton etc. but Gerrard and Lampard?Scouser_Dave wrote:
Gerrard, with Lampard not far behind him.
Thought you were talking about English midfielder's. If you think Scholes is the greatest English player of all time then
You can't laugh at him if you honestly think Gerrard and Lampard are two of the greatest ever English midfielders either.
Mine isn't anywhere near as laughable as thinking Scholes is the greatest English player of all time
ResurrectionRooney-
- Posts : 17681
Supports : United
Comparing him to Gerrard is just an insult.
Scouser_Dave-
- Posts : 7498
chiboygeorge wrote:I don't really think any English midfielder has a career as great as Scholes..
That's only because of the players around him. Stick Gerrard at United and Scholes at Liverpool and people would have a different opinion.
Scouser_Dave-
- Posts : 7498
ResurrectionRooney wrote:Comparing him to Gerrard is just an insult.
Yeah because Gerrard is a much better footballer. Glad you can see that.
Scouser_Dave-
- Posts : 7498
chiboygeorge wrote:So who is then? Gerrard?Scouser_Dave wrote:cheesy wrote:Scouser_Dave wrote:RoryOB94 wrote:Seriously? I could understand if you said someone like Charlton etc. but Gerrard and Lampard?
Thought you were talking about English midfielder's. If you think Scholes is the greatest English player of all time then
You can't laugh at him if you honestly think Gerrard and Lampard are two of the greatest ever English midfielders either.
Mine isn't anywhere near as laughable as thinking Scholes is the greatest English player of all time
No, probably Bobby Moore.
ResurrectionRooney-
- Posts : 17681
Supports : United
I'm not even going to argue this, saying Gerrard is better than Scholes is like saying Joe Cole is better than Lionel Messi. Are scousers born like that or something?
Guest- Guest
Prime Gerrard > Prime Scholes imo
Guest- Guest
I think Paul Scholes was an absolute class footballer, and his passing and vision and the way he found space on the pitch was amazing. He also played more as an attacking midfielder when he was younger, but when he got older he sat back in the midfield and could run a game from the middle of the pitch. Dont know if he is the greatest but i would put him up there as one of the greatest.
Similar topics
