+21
MCFCSilva10
Danny
El_indian
AriseForLife
El Jefe
luke.
The Zlatan
Dean
Mal
ResurrectionRooney
Coatsy
Lux
wellz
Jordi
blackskar
Ricardo
Jord
Kuled
LFC_Grunners
Jamie
CollieBuddz
25 posters
Scholes vs Fabregas
Poll
Who?
- [ 20 ]
- [44%]
- [ 25 ]
- [56%]
Total Votes: 45
CollieBuddz-
- Posts : 3473
Age : 34
- Post n°1
Scholes vs Fabregas
When both players are ON TOP OF THEIR GAME, which one is better?
Jamie-
- Posts : 24047
Age : 63
Location : Thiago
Supports : That Catalan club
- Post n°3
Re: Scholes vs Fabregas
Cesc.
Guest- Guest
- Post n°6
Re: Scholes vs Fabregas
You would have chose different if he was called Paulesc Scholesaxiesta and he played for Barca.Fine Shagger wrote:Cesc.
Jord-
- Formerly known as : SUPAH BURNLEY!
Posts : 33665
Location : Equestria
Supports : Liverpool FC
- Post n°7
Re: Scholes vs Fabregas
On the top of his game, Fabregas has to have everything Scholes has and more.
Jamie-
- Posts : 24047
Age : 63
Location : Thiago
Supports : That Catalan club
- Post n°8
Re: Scholes vs Fabregas
kyro7 wrote:You would have chose different if he was called Paulesc Scholesaxiesta and he played for Barca.Fine Shagger wrote:Cesc.
Depends if he was a complete and utter cunt who tried to end peoples careers every week or not I suppose.
Guest- Guest
- Post n°9
Re: Scholes vs Fabregas
Fine Shagger wrote:kyro7 wrote:You would have chose different if he was called Paulesc Scholesaxiesta and he played for Barca.Fine Shagger wrote:Cesc.
Depends if he was a complete and utter cunt who tried to end peoples careers every week or not I suppose.
Ricardo-
- Posts : 4561
Age : 30
Location : London
- Post n°10
Re: Scholes vs Fabregas
Fàbregas is better at just about everything except shooting.
wellz-
- Posts : 1073
Age : 35
Location : Washington D.C.
Supports : The Troops
- Post n°13
Re: Scholes vs Fabregas
You are comparing two players with over a decade in age difference...why?
Anyhow I pick Scholes
Anyhow I pick Scholes
CollieBuddz-
- Posts : 3473
Age : 34
- Post n°14
Re: Scholes vs Fabregas
wellz wrote:You are comparing two players with over a decade in age difference...why?
Anyhow I pick Scholes
Age is irrelevant in this comparison.
Lux-
- Posts : 9892
Age : 32
Location : North West London
Supports : Watford FC
- Post n°15
Re: Scholes vs Fabregas
CollieBuddz wrote:wellz wrote:You are comparing two players with over a decade in age difference...why?
Anyhow I pick Scholes
Age is irrelevant in this comparison.
It is, because you said "At the top of their game". Not "at their prime".
It's more like you're asking "who's better when on form right now?". Scholes is old right now, and Fabregas on form would hit a much bigger high.
ResurrectionRooney-
- Posts : 17681
Supports : United
- Post n°17
Re: Scholes vs Fabregas
Scholes 4 or 5 years ago but Fabregas now.
Mal-
- Posts : 31043
Age : 34
- Post n°18
Re: Scholes vs Fabregas
ResurrectionRooney wrote:Scholes 4 or 5 years ago but Fabregas now.
This.
CollieBuddz-
- Posts : 3473
Age : 34
- Post n°19
Re: Scholes vs Fabregas
Lux wrote:CollieBuddz wrote:wellz wrote:You are comparing two players with over a decade in age difference...why?
Anyhow I pick Scholes
Age is irrelevant in this comparison.
It is, because you said "At the top of their game". Not "at their prime".
It's more like you're asking "who's better when on form right now?". Scholes is old right now, and Fabregas on form would hit a much bigger high.
It isn't, stop trying to be smart. We just have different definitions for those terms. For me, in their prime means in their best years. But even a player in their best years can go through a bad patch.
In my mind, if you're on top of your game, it's the best you possibly can be, doesn't matter how old you are, it's THEIR game(career in other words) and if you're on top of it then it's the best you've been. That's what I'm comparing.
CollieBuddz-
- Posts : 3473
Age : 34
- Post n°20
Re: Scholes vs Fabregas
ResurrectionRooney wrote:Scholes 4 or 5 years ago but Fabregas now.
Avoiding the question.
I want you to say who is better.
In your words, the Scholes of 5 years ago, or the Fabregas of now.
ResurrectionRooney-
- Posts : 17681
Supports : United
- Post n°21
Re: Scholes vs Fabregas
CollieBuddz wrote:ResurrectionRooney wrote:Scholes 4 or 5 years ago but Fabregas now.
Avoiding the question.
I want you to say who is better.
In your words, the Scholes of 5 years ago, or the Fabregas of now.
Scholes then.
Guest- Guest
- Post n°24
Re: Scholes vs Fabregas
i think anyone who has watched the premier league over the last 15 will say scholes
but fabregas can still improve
but fabregas can still improve
CollieBuddz-
- Posts : 3473
Age : 34
- Post n°25
Re: Scholes vs Fabregas
ViVaRooney wrote:i think anyone who has watched the premier league over the last 15 will say scholes
but fabregas can still improve
Bias.
Guest- Guest
- Post n°26
Re: Scholes vs Fabregas
CollieBuddz wrote:ViVaRooney wrote:i think anyone who has watched the premier league over the last 15 will say scholes
but fabregas can still improve
Bias.
luke.-
- Posts : 32310
Age : 30
Location : Belfast
- Post n°29
Re: Scholes vs Fabregas
Scholes. But Fabregas hasn't even reached his peak yet.
Guest- Guest
- Post n°30
Re: Scholes vs Fabregas
Biased because Scholes is ginger.luke. wrote:Scholes. But Fabregas hasn't even reached his peak yet.