Playmaker's Best Premier League Team - CM - VOTE

Dean wrote:Well crump? Explain yourself? I'd love to here what you've got to say?

Why does he need to explain himself to you?

kyro7 wrote:

SBSP wrote:DM - Vieira
AM - Scholes

Why are you putting AM and DM, just put them as both Central Midfielders.

Because I chose one defensive and one attacking out of the ones given.

I think a lot of you have taken the positions of the players a little to seriously. Are we doing this on what would be the most realistic and challenge for trophies team, or just a dream team?

Dean wrote:Well crump? Explain yourself? I'd love to here what you've got to say?

Centre Foward.

ZlatanFabregas wrote:I think a lot of you have taken the positions of the players a little to seriously. Are we doing this on what would be the most realistic and challenge for trophies team, or just a dream team?

Dream team.

crump wrote:

Dean wrote:Well crump? Explain yourself? I'd love to here what you've got to say?

Centre Foward.

How is Gerrard a CF?

ZlatanFabregas wrote:I think a lot of you have taken the positions of the players a little to seriously. Are we doing this on what would be the most realistic and challenge for trophies team, or just a dream team?

Dream team obviously. Challenge for trophies would be ManUtd teams over the years

crump wrote:

Dean wrote:Well crump? Explain yourself? I'd love to here what you've got to say?

Centre Foward.

You do have to admit, that is very idiotic. When has Gerrard ever played CF, ever?

SBSP wrote:DM - Vieira
AM - Scholes

If i'm going to be picky, Vieira was a box-to-box midfielder while Scholes was a deep-lying central midfielder.

SBSP wrote:

ZlatanFabregas wrote:I think a lot of you have taken the positions of the players a little to seriously. Are we doing this on what would be the most realistic and challenge for trophies team, or just a dream team?

Dream team.

So why are people being little bitches about what position so and so plays?

I think I have found a way to solve all of this

Call the poll to decide strikers Central Attackers, no-one can argue with this. We have established that Gerrard is at his best when he is the centre, and when he is playing in the centre, he is certainly best when he is used as an attacking player. Therefore he is a central attacker. Strikers are also Central Attackers, so it is normal to have them in the same poll.

SBSP wrote:

crump wrote:

Dean wrote:Well crump? Explain yourself? I'd love to here what you've got to say?

Centre Foward.

You do have to admit, that is very idiotic. When has Gerrard ever played CF, ever?

2006/07, 2007/08, 2008/09

ResurrectionRooney wrote:

SBSP wrote:

crump wrote:

Dean wrote:Well crump? Explain yourself? I'd love to here what you've got to say?

Centre Foward.

You do have to admit, that is very idiotic. When has Gerrard ever played CF, ever?

2006/07, 2007/08, 2008/09

He play as AM

fool.

crump wrote:

Scott wrote:You're shit at this btw, RR had the right idea of how to do this. Make 1 poll with all the names. Whoever wins that is the first of the pair. Re-do the poll afterwards with the winner of the last poll removed, and whoever wins the new poll is the second of the pair. Not hard you fucking retard.

Yo yo yo yo
My name is Scott, I reckon I'm cool, I think I'm the one who's walking tall
But really your just a silly little fool who supprorts Liverpool
Haha, 16 bars you said in the Playmaker Battles, the only bars you'll be spitting are the ones made my Mars
Your getting butthurt over a Playmaker Poll, reckons CM is how Gerrard rolls
Calling me a retard but your just a big lump of lard who reckons he's hard
So instead of getting butt hurt because of a poll why not just chill out and have a lol.

What the fuck.



Viera and scholes

I think people are getting mixed up between the terms center forward and a second striker/attacking midfielder. Some people use the term center forward to describe tall, strong advanced strikers such as Shearer, while others use the term center forward and second striker as the same meaning.

ResurrectionRooney wrote:

Zzonked wrote:

arsenalap11 wrote:

Zzonked wrote:So basically, Gerrard isn't going to be any of the polls?

End of the day, the position in a 4-4-2 that suits him post is CM.

No, he'll be in the secondary striker poll.

So we're doing that to accommodate basically him and Bergkamp?

I'd rather just have a 2 striker poll so people like RVN and Shearer can compete against Henry.

I expect that will be what will happen, the vote for strikers will be done similarly to this poll, people will have the option of selecting two out and out strikers, an out and out striker and a SS, or even two SSs, might get the best out of Ronaldo.

In that case shouldn't Gerrard be in the CM poll so he can actually be in one of the polls?

ResurrectionRooney wrote:

SBSP wrote:

crump wrote:

Dean wrote:Well crump? Explain yourself? I'd love to here what you've got to say?

Centre Foward.

You do have to admit, that is very idiotic. When has Gerrard ever played CF, ever?

2006/07, 2007/08, 2008/09

That's ot really CF.That's still CAM. The position he's played for the majority of his career is CM.

NZG wrote:

ResurrectionRooney wrote:

SBSP wrote:

crump wrote:

Dean wrote:Well crump? Explain yourself? I'd love to here what you've got to say?

Centre Foward.

You do have to admit, that is very idiotic. When has Gerrard ever played CF, ever?

2006/07, 2007/08, 2008/09

He play as AM

fool.

Can you explain to me what the difference is between those two roles?

Steadman wrote:I think people are getting mixed up between the terms center forward and a second striker/attacking midfielder. Some people use the term center forward to describe tall, strong advanced strikers such as Shearer, while others use the term center forward and second striker as the same meaning.

I think some people don't understand that a centre forward is in fact a classic 9 There's no mixup, people just have it wrong. I don't think he's a second striker either though.

ResurrectionRooney wrote:

NZG wrote:

ResurrectionRooney wrote:

SBSP wrote:

crump wrote:

Centre Foward.

You do have to admit, that is very idiotic. When has Gerrard ever played CF, ever?

2006/07, 2007/08, 2008/09

He play as AM

fool.

Can you explain to me what the difference is between those two roles?

that man utd just said what a cf was
(the other thread about useless shit)

Laurencio wrote:

Steadman wrote:I think people are getting mixed up between the terms center forward and a second striker/attacking midfielder. Some people use the term center forward to describe tall, strong advanced strikers such as Shearer, while others use the term center forward and second striker as the same meaning.

I think some people don't understand that a centre forward is in fact a classic 9 There's no mixup, people just have it wrong. I don't think he's a second striker either though.

Some people have different terminology for these sorts of things, that's why this discussion keeps going around in circles.

You're fucking thick crump. Gerrard's never played as a centre forward. Gerrard was deployed in a specific role under Benitez, in front of 2 stationary central midfielder's, basically a free role- That enabled him on attacks, to get forward on counter attacks and support the striker, help the 2 central midfielder's when defending and was an extra body in the centre of pitch when in possession. So how the fuck that classes his as a centre forward I'll never know.

I've watched Gerrard week in week out for the last 8 years of my life so I don't need to some fucking kid Arsenal fan telling me where his 'best' position is or where he played etc... if there's anyone person on this forum who knows the ins and outs of Steven Gerrard it's me. (I'm not being arrogant here, but it's the truth).

Steadman wrote:

Laurencio wrote:

Steadman wrote:I think people are getting mixed up between the terms center forward and a second striker/attacking midfielder. Some people use the term center forward to describe tall, strong advanced strikers such as Shearer, while others use the term center forward and second striker as the same meaning.

I think some people don't understand that a centre forward is in fact a classic 9 There's no mixup, people just have it wrong. I don't think he's a second striker either though.

Some people have different terminology for these sorts of things, that's why this discussion keeps going around in circles.

Well they can stop being silly. Centre forwards are not Second Strikers, just as much as Second Strikers are not attacking midfielders. Next people will be saying Sweepers are advanced goalkeepers and defensive midfielders are really just centrebacks

blackskar wrote:

Dean wrote:Well crump? Explain yourself? I'd love to here what you've got to say?

Why does he need to explain himself to you?

What? Well he's making silly errors, so I want an explanation on it. You know, being a football discussion board and all that...

Dean wrote:

blackskar wrote:

Dean wrote:Well crump? Explain yourself? I'd love to here what you've got to say?

Why does he need to explain himself to you?

What? Well he's making silly errors, so I want an explanation on it. You know, being a football discussion board and all that...

Shut up.

Dean wrote:You're fucking thick crump. Gerrard's never played as a centre forward. Gerrard was deployed in a specific role under Benitez, in front of 2 stationary central midfielder's, basically a free role- That enabled him on attacks, to get forward on counter attacks and support the striker, help the 2 central midfielder's when defending and was an extra body in the centre of pitch when in possession. So how the fuck that classes his as a centre forward I'll never know.

I've watched Gerrard week in week out for the last 8 years of my life so I don't need to some fucking kid Arsenal fan telling me where his 'best' position is or where he played etc... if there's anyone person on this forum who knows the ins and outs of Steven Gerrard it's me. (I'm not being arrogant here, but it's the truth).

Why get so mad over it? Why not just vote for him as a second striker? It's pretty obvious where he would play if it came out like, for example

----Schmeichel

Neville Vidic Adams Cole

Ronaldo Scholes Vieira Giggs

Gerrard Henry

No-one is going to get confused and think Gerrard is playing as a central striker, he'd obviously be in a free role. I think you're just angry because you don't think he's good enough to get in as a SS.

ResurrectionRooney wrote:

Dean wrote:You're fucking thick crump. Gerrard's never played as a centre forward. Gerrard was deployed in a specific role under Benitez, in front of 2 stationary central midfielder's, basically a free role- That enabled him on attacks, to get forward on counter attacks and support the striker, help the 2 central midfielder's when defending and was an extra body in the centre of pitch when in possession. So how the fuck that classes his as a centre forward I'll never know.

I've watched Gerrard week in week out for the last 8 years of my life so I don't need to some fucking kid Arsenal fan telling me where his 'best' position is or where he played etc... if there's anyone person on this forum who knows the ins and outs of Steven Gerrard it's me. (I'm not being arrogant here, but it's the truth).

Why get so mad over it? Why not just vote for him as a second striker? It's pretty obvious where he would play if it came out like, for example

----Schmeichel

Neville Vidic Adams Cole

Ronaldo Scholes Vieira Giggs

Gerrard Henry

No-one is going to get confused and think Gerrard is playing as a central striker, he'd obviously be in a free role. I think you're just angry because you don't think he's good enough to get in as a SS.

Guess whos just hit the nail on the fucking head.

crump wrote:

ResurrectionRooney wrote:

Dean wrote:You're fucking thick crump. Gerrard's never played as a centre forward. Gerrard was deployed in a specific role under Benitez, in front of 2 stationary central midfielder's, basically a free role- That enabled him on attacks, to get forward on counter attacks and support the striker, help the 2 central midfielder's when defending and was an extra body in the centre of pitch when in possession. So how the fuck that classes his as a centre forward I'll never know.

I've watched Gerrard week in week out for the last 8 years of my life so I don't need to some fucking kid Arsenal fan telling me where his 'best' position is or where he played etc... if there's anyone person on this forum who knows the ins and outs of Steven Gerrard it's me. (I'm not being arrogant here, but it's the truth).

Why get so mad over it? Why not just vote for him as a second striker? It's pretty obvious where he would play if it came out like, for example

----Schmeichel

Neville Vidic Adams Cole

Ronaldo Scholes Vieira Giggs

Gerrard Henry

No-one is going to get confused and think Gerrard is playing as a central striker, he'd obviously be in a free role. I think you're just angry because you don't think he's good enough to get in as a SS.

Guess whos just hit the nail on the fucking head.

Hmmm, this is a hard one, RR?

As usual.

Dean wrote:

blackskar wrote:

Dean wrote:Well crump? Explain yourself? I'd love to here what you've got to say?

Why does he need to explain himself to you?

What? Well he's making silly errors, so I want an explanation on it. You know, being a football discussion board and all that...

Eh I wouldn't blame him, it's not like Liverpool fans have been particulary cooperative with these polls. With voting for Konchesky, Riise and Johnson being some of the wonderful highlights.

No-one is going to get confused and think Gerrard is playing as a central striker, he'd obviously be in a free role. I think you're just angry because you don't think he's good enough to get in as a SS.

Personally I don't think he would make it for Central Midfield even, but I still disagree with him being classified as a second striker. How is he a Totti, Del Piero, Diego Maradona, Messi type of player?