You're a 23 year old English striker playing for Celtic...

The Maestro wrote:

Alan wrote:I think Jelavic and maybe one or two others from the SPL could make it in the premiership, and they could possible be succesful.

I'd like to hear what you think on the question being asked, ignoring James biased post which basically ensures the votes go his way.

Celtic

- play in a slightly poorer league
- play in front of 60k of the best supporters in the country
- play in champions league next season
- winners medals and trophies

Southampton

- play in a slightly better league
- play in front of 20k fans
- chance of premier league promotion
- then immediate relegation

The Maestro wrote:

Alan wrote:I think Jelavic and maybe one or two others from the SPL could make it in the premiership, and they could possible be succesful.

I'd like to hear what you think on the question being asked, ignoring James biased post which basically ensures the votes go his way.

Celtic

- play in front of 60k of the best supporters in the country
- play in champions league next season
- winners medals and trophies

Southampton

- play in front of 20k fans
- chance of premier league promotion
- then immediate relegation

i have no included the standard of football, because quite simply, some of the football in the Championship is DIRE, as is some of the football in Scotland.

To say the football up there is better is pushing it.

Big_Lad_Pardew wrote:

Jelavic9|RFC wrote:

About 5 of them would.

Who?
This should be good...

Jelavic9|RFC wrote:

Big_Lad_Pardew wrote:
Who?
This should be good...

McGregor > Krul > Harper > Elliot
Naismith > Obertan > Marveaux > Vuckic
Davis > Guthrie > Smith, Abied, Gosling
Edu > Guthrie > Smith, Abied, Gosling
Jelavic > Best > Lovenkrands > Ameobi > Ameobi
Wallace > Simpson, Williamson, Perch, Ferguson
Papac > Simpson, Williamson, Perch, Ferguson
McCulloch > Guthrie > Smith, Abied, Gosling
Bocanegra > Simpson, Williamson, Perch, Ferguson
Goian > Simpson, Williamson, Perch, Ferguson

ResurrectionRaddy wrote:Nottingham Forest; a Championship club, have more European Cups than every single club in Scotland put together.

Big_Lad_Pardew wrote:

Jelavic9|RFC wrote:

McGregor > Krul > Harper > Elliot
Naismith > Obertan > Marveaux > Vuckic
Davis > Guthrie > Smith, Abied, Gosling
Edu > Guthrie > Smith, Abied, Gosling
Jelavic > Best > Lovenkrands > Ameobi > Ameobi
Wallace > Simpson, Williamson, Perch, Ferguson
Papac > Simpson, Williamson, Perch, Ferguson
McCulloch > Guthrie > Smith, Abied, Gosling
Bocanegra > Simpson, Williamson, Perch, Ferguson
Goian > Simpson, Williamson, Perch, Ferguson

Are you on crack? Even then you have chosen played who dont even get in our matchday squad to compare

ahlycotc wrote:Most likely Celtic. It mostly depends on my wage and playing time. Celtic is a bigger club and I have a better chance of going to an even bigger club if I perform well.

ahlycotc wrote:Most likely Celtic. It mostly depends on my wage and playing time. Celtic is a bigger club and I have a better chance of going to an even bigger club if I perform well.

The Maestro wrote:

Alan wrote:I think Jelavic and maybe one or two others from the SPL could make it in the premiership, and they could possible be succesful.

I'd like to hear what you think on the question being asked, ignoring James biased post which basically ensures the votes go his way.

Celtic

- play in front of 60k of the best supporters in the country
- play in champions league next season
- winners medals and trophies

Southampton

- play in front of 20k fans
- chance of premier league promotion
- then immediate relegation

i have no included the standard of football, because quite simply, some of the football in the Championship is DIRE, as is some of the football in Scotland.

To say the football up there is better is pushing it.

The Maestro wrote:

ahlycotc wrote:Most likely Celtic. It mostly depends on my wage and playing time. Celtic is a bigger club and I have a better chance of going to an even bigger club if I perform well.

Not surprised at this, the arrogance is usually only confined to England.

Jelavic9|RFC wrote:

Big_Lad_Pardew wrote:
Are you on crack? Even then you have chosen played who dont even get in our matchday squad to compare

Included all the players who can play in that position, hard to remember so much shite.

Big_Lad_Pardew wrote:Williamson would be your best player, likewise with guthrie who is badly underrated.
McGergor over krul
Ferguson would be like messi in the SPL
Abeid and vuckic again would be your best players. Maybe even smith, who knows....

The Maestro wrote:

Alan wrote:I think Jelavic and maybe one or two others from the SPL could make it in the premiership, and they could possible be succesful.

I'd like to hear what you think on the question being asked, ignoring James biased post which basically ensures the votes go his way.

Celtic

- play in front of 60k of the best supporters in the country
- play in champions league next season
- winners medals and trophies

Southampton

- play in front of 20k fans
- chance of premier league promotion
- then immediate relegation

i have no included the standard of football, because quite simply, some of the football in the Championship is DIRE, as is some of the football in Scotland.

To say the football up there is better is pushing it.

Jelavic9|RFC wrote:

Big_Lad_Pardew wrote:Williamson would be your best player, likewise with guthrie who is badly underrated.
McGergor over krul
Ferguson would be like messi in the SPL
Abeid and vuckic again would be your best players. Maybe even smith, who knows....

Yes, those players are better than Naismith, Davis, Jelavic etc.

Who the fuck are those people anyway?

Big_Lad_Pardew wrote:Here is a mixed NUFC rangers side.

Krul
Raylor Taylor Coloccini Santon
Marveaux Cabaye Tiote Guttirez
Ben Arfa
Ba

Big_Lad_Pardew wrote:

Jelavic9|RFC wrote:

Included all the players who can play in that position, hard to remember so much shite.

You have chosen to disclude our best players. Basically most of our squad.

James wrote:He keeps mentioning this 60k attendance, which happens like 5 times a season. Average is 49k for home games.

Half of the season they in front of an average crowd 4x smaller than that.

Jelavic9|RFC wrote:

Big_Lad_Pardew wrote:
You have chosen to disclude our best players. Basically most of our squad.

Around 5 players yes, because they are better. i.e. Tiote, Cabaye, S Taylor, Ba (Arguably, horrible health record), Ben Arfa

ResurrectionRaddy wrote:

ahlycotc wrote:Most likely Celtic. It mostly depends on my wage and playing time. Celtic is a bigger club and I have a better chance of going to an even bigger club if I perform well.

Do you really though? Name a player than has gone on to bigger, better clubs from an SPL side.


The list is endless from Championship clubs, and even League 1.

Gareth Bale
Theo Walcott
Aaron Lennon
Adam Johnson
Alex Chamberlain
etc etc

James wrote:He keeps mentioning this 60k attendance, which happens like 5 times a season. Average is 49k for home games.

Half of the season they in front of an average crowd 4x smaller than that.

Big_Lad_Pardew wrote:Here is a mixed NUFC rangers side.

Krul
Raylor Taylor Coloccini Santon
Marveaux Cabaye Tiote Guttirez
Ben Arfa
Ba

ahlycotc wrote:

The Maestro wrote:

Not surprised at this, the arrogance is usually only confined to England.

Not sure if that's an agreement with my views or a sarcastic attack.