yeah hes probably the best
+27
RoryOB94
dena
Zzonked
Muhkoo
Sean
Childish Logic
El Jefe
Jordi
Grenade
Bye_Ya
BMxJoga
Cadbury
Dr. Ján Ĩtor
AriseForLife
Theo Filippo
Ben 10
fluffy_kittens
Fanatic
The Zlatan
Lux
Tio Nicci
Jamie
chiboygeorge
Marvin
VivaRonaldoLAD
SBSP
Carlos Jenkinson
31 posters
Is Silva the best midfielder in the league?
Poll
Vote
- [ 14 ]
[54%]
- [ 12 ]
- [46%]
Total Votes: 26
Guest- Guest
Carlos Jenkinson-
- Posts : 10964
- Post n°32
Re: Is Silva the best midfielder in the league?
by Carlos Jenkinson Fri Aug 19, 2011 11:31 am
VivaRonaldo wrote:Fonseca wrote:VivaRonaldo wrote:Fonseca wrote:VivaRonaldo wrote:
Its not logical comparing David Silva to the likes of Fabrice fuckin Muamba.
Jela 2.0?
No, I just have common sense.
Well there's no hope in trying with you if you can't see the difference in quality between Muamba
Its more to do with their difference in positionsProving you cant simply compare "midfielders" as they are different types of player.
The difference in class distinguishes it, a person with half a brain could acknowledge Cesc was the best with the likes of Toure etc
VivaRonaldoLAD-
- Posts : 14745
Location : United Road.
Supports : Giggsy 12-0 Gerrard
- Post n°33
Re: Is Silva the best midfielder in the league?
by VivaRonaldoLAD Fri Aug 19, 2011 11:32 am
Fonseca wrote:VivaRonaldo wrote:Fonseca wrote:VivaRonaldo wrote:Fonseca wrote:
Jela 2.0?
No, I just have common sense.
Well there's no hope in trying with you if you can't see the difference in quality between Muamba
Its more to do with their difference in positions
The difference in class distinguishes it, a person with half a brain could acknowledge Cesc was the best with the likes of Toure etc
Silva and DeJong two of the best midfielders in their respective positions, how do you choose who is best?
Dr. Ján Ĩtor-
- Formerly known as : XxBradKennedyxX
Posts : 2983
Age : 30
Probably, but its hard comparing players when theyre so different, Nani, Silva, Modders and De Jong are probably the best in there respective roles/styles, so how do you choose which is best?
VivaRonaldoLAD-
- Posts : 14745
Location : United Road.
Supports : Giggsy 12-0 Gerrard
- Post n°35
Re: Is Silva the best midfielder in the league?
by VivaRonaldoLAD Fri Aug 19, 2011 11:47 am
XxBradKennedyxX wrote:Probably, but its hard comparing players when theyre so different, Nani, Silva, Modders and De Jong are probably the best in there respective roles/styles, so how do you choose which is best?
My point exactly..........
SBSP-
- Posts : 50010
Where does Muamba come on though?
VivaRonaldoLAD-
- Posts : 14745
Location : United Road.
Supports : Giggsy 12-0 Gerrard
- Post n°37
Re: Is Silva the best midfielder in the league?
by VivaRonaldoLAD Fri Aug 19, 2011 11:55 am
SBSP wrote:Where does Muamba come on though?
He was the first midfielder that popped into my head.
SBSP-
- Posts : 50010
That doesn't make any sense though. Even though they play different positions, Silva is easily better in his than Muamba.
Cadbury-
- Posts : 23487
Age : 31
Location : Blackpool
Supports : Not Kenny.
Can I just nominate El Zhar? He's leaving, but until then, he's in with a shout.
Guest- Guest
Bit ironic seeing you were moaning about Adam's workrate the other day and deem a player like Arshavin as shit.Jamie wrote:Chris wrote:In England it seems people prefer workrate to flair, which is why it's going downhill.
I've got you pegged as one of those people.
VivaRonaldoLAD-
- Posts : 14745
Location : United Road.
Supports : Giggsy 12-0 Gerrard
- Post n°41
Re: Is Silva the best midfielder in the league?
by VivaRonaldoLAD Fri Aug 19, 2011 11:57 am
SBSP wrote:That doesn't make any sense though. Even though they play different positions, Silva is easily better in his than Muamba.
My point was that Silva and Muamba cant be compared as midfielders, we know Silva is the better player.
SBSP-
- Posts : 50010
They can be compared as midfielders because they both are. You can compare any players you want. It's just difficult when they're close in quality and play different roles. Silva and Muamba, though, are not close in quality.
You can compare any players you want. It's just difficult when they're close in quality and play different roles. Silva and Muamba, though, are not close in quality.
VivaRonaldoLAD-
- Posts : 14745
Location : United Road.
Supports : Giggsy 12-0 Gerrard
- Post n°43
Re: Is Silva the best midfielder in the league?
by VivaRonaldoLAD Fri Aug 19, 2011 12:01 pm
SBSP wrote:They can be compared as midfielders because they both are.
They both play completely different roles. How would you judge whos better between De Jong and Silva, I know Muamba was pushing it but I had to prove my point.
Marvin- .
- Posts : 13039
Age : 34
Location : Hollyoaks
Supports : Hollyoaks
I would like to see Silva protecting the back 4 and breaking up play.SBSP wrote:They can be compared as midfielders because they both are.
VivaRonaldoLAD-
- Posts : 14745
Location : United Road.
Supports : Giggsy 12-0 Gerrard
- Post n°45
Re: Is Silva the best midfielder in the league?
by VivaRonaldoLAD Fri Aug 19, 2011 12:04 pm
Marvin wrote:I would like to see Silva protecting the back 4 and breaking up play.SBSP wrote:They can be compared as midfielders because they both are.
SBSP-
- Posts : 50010
You know what I meant. 
VivaRonaldoLAD-
- Posts : 14745
Location : United Road.
Supports : Giggsy 12-0 Gerrard
- Post n°47
Re: Is Silva the best midfielder in the league?
by VivaRonaldoLAD Fri Aug 19, 2011 12:10 pm
SBSP wrote:You know what I meant.
Hes showing my point though, Silva cant break up play like DeJong, whereas De Jong cant attack as good as Silva, you can say Silva is a better player, but not a better midfielder.
Jamie-
- Posts : 24047
Age : 63
Location : Thiago
Supports : That Catalan club
Chris wrote:Bit ironic seeing you were moaning about Adam's workrate the other day and deem a player like Arshavin as shit.Jamie wrote:Chris wrote:In England it seems people prefer workrate to flair, which is why it's going downhill.
I've got you pegged as one of those people.
Arshavin is shit because he disappears, not because he doesn't work hard.
Adam doesn't really have flair.
Guest- Guest
Muamba is quite good on FIFA, he develops into a beautiful footballer and wfor
Guest- Guest
i dont like arshavin either
he has all facets to be one of best player around. good tecnical. good speed. intelligence etc etc. but his influence is so littleeee
why is so many games he doesnt involve himself in play much. surely he is what they call a "motd player". like he is shy. but simply doesnt insert influence over a game
he has all facets to be one of best player around. good tecnical. good speed. intelligence etc etc. but his influence is so littleeee
why is so many games he doesnt involve himself in play much. surely he is what they call a "motd player". like he is shy. but simply doesnt insert influence over a game
BMxJoga-
- Posts : 399
I'd rather have Nasri if I am honest.
Bye_Ya-
- Posts : 2688
Silva 
Guest- Guest
Silva is brilliant, him and Modric are the two midfielders I like best in the league, we'll see how Gerrard comes back but it's not looking good.
Grenade-
- Formerly known as : grenade187
Posts : 9113
Age : 43
mauro=beast wrote:i dont like arshavin either
he has all facets to be one of best player around. good tecnical. good speed. intelligence etc etc. but his influence is so littleeee
why is so many games he doesnt involve himself in play much. surely he is what they call a "motd player". like he is shy. but simply doesnt insert influence over a game
He's a good player but he plays best centrally and to be honest he doesn't really fit into the Arsenal team well. I guess you can say he's wasting his career at Arsenal. Not winning trophy's and not playing well.
Anyway I would say Silva is probably one of the best midfielders in the league with the likes of Nasri, Modric, Essien (when on form), Nani and Yaya toure. I'm not directly comparing these players but they are amongst the elite of the premier league. When City sign Nasri they will fucking shit on everyone !
Guest- Guest
Now that Cesc has gone I would say Silva is the best.
Guest- Guest
its crazy, before he came i bet 90% of the people said he wouldnt be able to handle the premier league
Lux-
- Posts : 9892
Age : 32
Location : North West London
Supports : Watford FC
VivaRonaldo wrote:SBSP wrote:They can be compared as midfielders because they both are.
They both play completely different roles. How would you judge whos better between De Jong and Silva, I know Muamba was pushing it but I had to prove my point.
The whole point of comparing is that it's supposed to be different things.
Messi is better than Carson, Ben and Jerry's ice cream is better than Tesco Value cornflakes.
Jordi- .
- Posts : 36039
Age : 29
Supports : Saints
Strongly disagree.Lux wrote:VivaRonaldo wrote:SBSP wrote:They can be compared as midfielders because they both are.
They both play completely different roles. How would you judge whos better between De Jong and Silva, I know Muamba was pushing it but I had to prove my point.
The whole point of comparing is that it's supposed to be different things.
Messi is better than Carson, Ben and Jerry's ice cream is better than Tesco Value cornflakes.
Guest- Guest
Yeah probably. There's definitely a shortage of quality midfielders in the Premier League which has lead players like Luka "flavour of the month" Modric to all of a sudden be considered world class.
Lux-
- Posts : 9892
Age : 32
Location : North West London
Supports : Watford FC
Jordi wrote:Strongly disagree.
