With the departure of Cesc and underperforming stars such as Lampard, Essien, Nasri and Malouda... Is it fair to say Silva is the best midfielder in the league?
+27
RoryOB94
dena
Zzonked
Muhkoo
Sean
Childish Logic
El Jefe
Jordi
Grenade
Bye_Ya
BMxJoga
Cadbury
Dr. Ján Ĩtor
AriseForLife
Theo Filippo
Ben 10
fluffy_kittens
Fanatic
The Zlatan
Lux
Tio Nicci
Jamie
chiboygeorge
Marvin
VivaRonaldoLAD
SBSP
Carlos Jenkinson
31 posters
Is Silva the best midfielder in the league?
Poll
Vote
- [ 14 ]
[54%]
- [ 12 ]
- [46%]
Total Votes: 26
Carlos Jenkinson-
- Posts : 10964
SBSP-
- Posts : 50010
Malouda underpeforming? He was overperforming before. 
It's possible that Silva is.
It's possible that Silva is.
VivaRonaldoLAD-
- Posts : 14745
Location : United Road.
Supports : Giggsy 12-0 Gerrard
- Post n°3
Re: Is Silva the best midfielder in the league?
by VivaRonaldoLAD Fri Aug 19, 2011 10:39 am
So many different types of midfielders, we cant compare him to all them.
Marvin- .
- Posts : 13039
Age : 34
Location : Hollyoaks
Supports : Hollyoaks
Too soon to say.
Guest- Guest
Wilshere > all.
chiboygeorge-
- Posts : 3517
I think he's the most creative midfielder that's for sure.
I rank him and Nani at least top three midfielders in the PL.
I rank him and Nani at least top three midfielders in the PL.
Jamie-
- Posts : 24047
Age : 63
Location : Thiago
Supports : That Catalan club
I can't think of any better...
VivaRonaldoLAD-
- Posts : 14745
Location : United Road.
Supports : Giggsy 12-0 Gerrard
- Post n°8
Re: Is Silva the best midfielder in the league?
by VivaRonaldoLAD Fri Aug 19, 2011 10:46 am
Jamie wrote:I can't think of any better...
Nigel de Jong.
Guest- Guest
Fabregas > BPL Midfielders 
chiboygeorge-
- Posts : 3517
Premier League is really lagging behind in terms of World Class talents, after Silva, you don't see many World Class midfielders in PL though.
VivaRonaldoLAD-
- Posts : 14745
Location : United Road.
Supports : Giggsy 12-0 Gerrard
- Post n°11
Re: Is Silva the best midfielder in the league?
by VivaRonaldoLAD Fri Aug 19, 2011 10:52 am
Btw the De Jong comment was sarcasm for anyone who thought I was serious ... just showing how pointless this thread is 
Carlos Jenkinson-
- Posts : 10964
- Post n°12
Re: Is Silva the best midfielder in the league?
by Carlos Jenkinson Fri Aug 19, 2011 10:59 am
VivaRonaldo wrote:Btw the De Jong comment was sarcasm for anyone who thought I was serious ... just showing how pointless this thread is
Maybe because it's a logical question with people giving logical answers and simpletons like yourself try to make it difficult
VivaRonaldoLAD-
- Posts : 14745
Location : United Road.
Supports : Giggsy 12-0 Gerrard
- Post n°13
Re: Is Silva the best midfielder in the league?
by VivaRonaldoLAD Fri Aug 19, 2011 11:01 am
Fonseca wrote:VivaRonaldo wrote:Btw the De Jong comment was sarcasm for anyone who thought I was serious ... just showing how pointless this thread is
Maybe because it's a logical question with people giving logical answers and simpletons like yourself try to make it difficult
Its not logical comparing David Silva to the likes of Fabrice fuckin Muamba.
Tio Nicci-
- Posts : 557
Age : 35
Location : Houston
Supports : Colombian National Team, Deportivo Cali, and USMNT
chiboygeorge wrote:Premier League is really lagging behind in terms of World Class talents, after Silva, you don't see many World Class midfielders in PL though.
It's also because PL they don't use much creative midfielders, they use more traditional midfielders with the newly implemented wingers.
Lux-
- Posts : 9892
Age : 32
Location : North West London
Supports : Watford FC
chiboygeorge wrote:Premier League is really lagging behind in terms of World Class talents, after Silva, you don't see many World Class midfielders in PL though.
Anderson is da best cuz he's from Brazil
Tio Nicci-
- Posts : 557
Age : 35
Location : Houston
Supports : Colombian National Team, Deportivo Cali, and USMNT
Lux wrote:chiboygeorge wrote:Premier League is really lagging behind in terms of World Class talents, after Silva, you don't see many World Class midfielders in PL though.
Anderson is da best cuz he's from Brazil
Sike...
Carlos Jenkinson-
- Posts : 10964
- Post n°17
Re: Is Silva the best midfielder in the league?
by Carlos Jenkinson Fri Aug 19, 2011 11:04 am
VivaRonaldo wrote:Fonseca wrote:VivaRonaldo wrote:Btw the De Jong comment was sarcasm for anyone who thought I was serious ... just showing how pointless this thread is
Maybe because it's a logical question with people giving logical answers and simpletons like yourself try to make it difficult
Its not logical comparing David Silva to the likes of Fabrice fuckin Muamba.
Jela 2.0?
VivaRonaldoLAD-
- Posts : 14745
Location : United Road.
Supports : Giggsy 12-0 Gerrard
- Post n°18
Re: Is Silva the best midfielder in the league?
by VivaRonaldoLAD Fri Aug 19, 2011 11:07 am
Fonseca wrote:VivaRonaldo wrote:Fonseca wrote:VivaRonaldo wrote:Btw the De Jong comment was sarcasm for anyone who thought I was serious ... just showing how pointless this thread is
Maybe because it's a logical question with people giving logical answers and simpletons like yourself try to make it difficult
Its not logical comparing David Silva to the likes of Fabrice fuckin Muamba.
Jela 2.0?
No, I just have common sense.
The Zlatan-
- Posts : 10347
Close between him and Nasri
Fanatic-
- Posts : 4855
Between him and Modric for me.
I'd say Silva atm.
I'd say Silva atm.
fluffy_kittens-
- Posts : 3190
Location : New Jersey, USA
- Post n°21
Re: Is Silva the best midfielder in the league?
by fluffy_kittens Fri Aug 19, 2011 11:08 am
Luke Uh Mode Rick
nuff said.
nuff said.
Carlos Jenkinson-
- Posts : 10964
- Post n°22
Re: Is Silva the best midfielder in the league?
by Carlos Jenkinson Fri Aug 19, 2011 11:08 am
VivaRonaldo wrote:Fonseca wrote:VivaRonaldo wrote:Fonseca wrote:VivaRonaldo wrote:Btw the De Jong comment was sarcasm for anyone who thought I was serious ... just showing how pointless this thread is
Maybe because it's a logical question with people giving logical answers and simpletons like yourself try to make it difficult
Its not logical comparing David Silva to the likes of Fabrice fuckin Muamba.
Jela 2.0?
No, I just have common sense.
Well there's no hope in trying with you if you can't see the difference in quality between Muamba
Ben 10-
- Posts : 10205
Age : 28
Location : Preston
Supports : Preston North End F.C.
"No, I just have common sense."
I beg to differ.
I beg to differ.
Theo Filippo-
- Formerly known as : Filippo Inzaghi
Posts : 21636
Age : 30
Preston is a shit holeBen 10 wrote:"No, I just have common sense."
I beg to differ.
I bet you beg to differ.
VivaRonaldoLAD-
- Posts : 14745
Location : United Road.
Supports : Giggsy 12-0 Gerrard
- Post n°25
Re: Is Silva the best midfielder in the league?
by VivaRonaldoLAD Fri Aug 19, 2011 11:10 am
Fonseca wrote:VivaRonaldo wrote:Fonseca wrote:VivaRonaldo wrote:Fonseca wrote:
Maybe because it's a logical question with people giving logical answers and simpletons like yourself try to make it difficult
Its not logical comparing David Silva to the likes of Fabrice fuckin Muamba.
Jela 2.0?
No, I just have common sense.
Well there's no hope in trying with you if you can't see the difference in quality between Muamba
Its more to do with their difference in positions
Proving you cant simply compare "midfielders" as they are different types of player.Last edited by VivaRonaldo on Fri Aug 19, 2011 11:11 am; edited 1 time in total
Guest- Guest
In England it seems people prefer workrate to flair, which is why it's going downhill.
Ben 10-
- Posts : 10205
Age : 28
Location : Preston
Supports : Preston North End F.C.
Filippo Inzaghi wrote:Preston is a shit holeBen 10 wrote:"No, I just have common sense."
I beg to differ.
I bet you beg to differ.
It's not even that bad.Just wondering, how many times have you visited Preston?
Jamie-
- Posts : 24047
Age : 63
Location : Thiago
Supports : That Catalan club
Chris wrote:In England it seems people prefer workrate to flair, which is why it's going downhill.
I've got you pegged as one of those people.
Guest- Guest
Chris wrote:In England it seems people prefer workrate to flair, which is why it's going downhill.
Kuyt
AriseForLife-
- Posts : 2473
Excellent midfielder, but not sure I would say he is the best. He's definitely class though.
