[65%] [35%] 
Jord wrote:No he's not. That's Kyro's lingering spirit. He lives on in us all.polska. wrote:Kyro, your alive.kyro7 wrote:Adam would be the better player for a lower team, like lets say if you put Carrick in Blackpool he'd not be nearly as effective as Adam, but Carrick is the better player at getting a team ticking and the better for a bigger team.
Charlie Adam could be pretty good at Liverpool though, if he makes his passing game more simple.
Oh.. Like a ghost?Jord wrote:No he's not. That's Kyro's lingering spirit. He lives on in us all.polska. wrote:Kyro, your alive.kyro7 wrote:Adam would be the better player for a lower team, like lets say if you put Carrick in Blackpool he'd not be nearly as effective as Adam, but Carrick is the better player at getting a team ticking and the better for a bigger team.
Charlie Adam could be pretty good at Liverpool though, if he makes his passing game more simple.
Like Mufasa.polska. wrote:Oh.. Like a ghost?Jord wrote:No he's not. That's Kyro's lingering spirit. He lives on in us all.polska. wrote:Kyro, your alive.kyro7 wrote:Adam would be the better player for a lower team, like lets say if you put Carrick in Blackpool he'd not be nearly as effective as Adam, but Carrick is the better player at getting a team ticking and the better for a bigger team.
Charlie Adam could be pretty good at Liverpool though, if he makes his passing game more simple.
Filippo Inzaghi wrote:Let the debate begin...
Carrick has played in multiple champions league finals, countless premier league games against the top four sides and many other high profile games in Europe and at Wembley.
Adam on the other hand has a play-off final to his name.
You would think it is clear who the superior player is. I must warn some of you before voting you will be called a troll by a particular member if you vote a certain optionnone the less...
Who is better
Please stay on topic.Liverpool fc 4 ever wrote:Filippo Inzaghi wrote:Let the debate begin...
Carrick has played in multiple champions league finals, countless premier league games against the top four sides and many other high profile games in Europe and at Wembley.
Adam on the other hand has a play-off final to his name.
You would think it is clear who the superior player is. I must warn some of you before voting you will be called a troll by a particular member if you vote a certain option
Who is better
Fuck me its Theo, here we go again
So Carrick is betterSBSP wrote:Different types of players. Carrick wouldn't be as effective in Blackpool as Adam, and Adam wouldn't be as effective in Man Utd.
kyro7 wrote:Adam would be the better player for a lower team, like lets say if you put Carrick in Blackpool he'd not be nearly as effective as Adam, but Carrick is the better player at getting a team ticking and the better for a bigger team.
Charlie Adam could be pretty good at Liverpool though, if he makes his passing game more simple.
He has to be the worst midfielder I've seen playing football. How he's still at United is a fucking mystery.
You are exaggerating it. Carrick is a decent player, I don't see what Adam has done to be better than Carrick.Scouser_Dave wrote:Carrick winning the poll
chiboygeorge wrote:You are exaggerating it. Carrick is a decent player, I don't see what Adam has done to be better than Carrick.Scouser_Dave wrote:Carrick winning the poll
Yes Carrick can't play football?Scouser_Dave wrote:chiboygeorge wrote:You are exaggerating it. Carrick is a decent player, I don't see what Adam has done to be better than Carrick.Scouser_Dave wrote:Carrick winning the poll
Adam can play football, that's what makes him a better footballer.
Scouser_Dave wrote:chiboygeorge wrote:You are exaggerating it. Carrick is a decent player, I don't see what Adam has done to be better than Carrick.Scouser_Dave wrote:Carrick winning the poll
Adam can play football, that's what makes him a better footballer.
chiboygeorge wrote:Yes Carrick can't play football?Scouser_Dave wrote:chiboygeorge wrote:You are exaggerating it. Carrick is a decent player, I don't see what Adam has done to be better than Carrick.Scouser_Dave wrote:Carrick winning the poll
Adam can play football, that's what makes him a better footballer.
One of the best midfielders in England in 2006-2008. Adam has never done anything compared to what Carrick did in those two seasons.
James wrote:Scouser_Dave wrote:chiboygeorge wrote:You are exaggerating it. Carrick is a decent player, I don't see what Adam has done to be better than Carrick.Scouser_Dave wrote:Carrick winning the poll
Adam can play football, that's what makes him a better footballer.
Carrick can play too.
Carrick can actually run faster than a tortoise as well.
He's quality because he's signed for Liverpool.moscowmadeit3 wrote:What's so good about Adam then?
Encourages hoofball perfect for Carroll.moscowmadeit3 wrote:What's so good about Adam then?
moscowmadeit3 wrote:What's so good about Adam then?
El_indian wrote:I haven't seen enough of either to vote TBH, but I always thought Utd fans didn't rate Carrick, or did he just have a poor last season?
Shame on us for slating Carrick? He has been useless all season. he did alot last season? u mean he got us knocked out of the champions leauge and seems to go invisible in any big matches we have played. Yesterday his performance was disgraceful see him trying to tackle suarez? He doesnt seem to care lacks heart,passion and the fight that the likes of keano had. All our problems our coming from midfield people say carrick was good i never rem him being good. . He was carried by ronaldo tevez rooney giggs and scholes. Only for rooney last year our season would have been more average than it was. It hurts me to watch him play for this club that i love how has he not been dropped for being poor? BE HONEST WITH YOURSELVES WOULD HE GET ON ANY OTHER TOP TEAM? I Know some die hard fans should say we shouldn criticise our own players i find that stupid we can voice our opinions we need to revamp our squad and if we dont i can even see us making the top four next season. Look at the difference in Liverpool since they spend some money they destroyed us yesterday. I am worried for our future we are in serious trouble if we dont spend money on midfielders this summer. i am sorry for criticizing the player he is a model professional and always gives a 100% but he is just not good enough. I love manchester united but now i find myself worrying about big away games and having no confidence in the team which never happened me before, I am really worried with the direction our club is going.
Scouser_Dave wrote:Carrick winning the poll
He had a poor first half to last season, although that was mainly due to Fletcher dragging him down, 2nd half of the season he was much better.El_indian wrote:I haven't seen enough of either to vote TBH, but I always thought Utd fans didn't rate Carrick, or did he just have a poor last season?
Scouser_Dave wrote:El_indian wrote:I haven't seen enough of either to vote TBH, but I always thought Utd fans didn't rate Carrick, or did he just have a poor last season?
Shame on us for slating Carrick? He has been useless all season. he did alot last season? u mean he got us knocked out of the champions leauge and seems to go invisible in any big matches we have played. Yesterday his performance was disgraceful see him trying to tackle suarez? He doesnt seem to care lacks heart,passion and the fight that the likes of keano had. All our problems our coming from midfield people say carrick was good i never rem him being good. . He was carried by ronaldo tevez rooney giggs and scholes. Only for rooney last year our season would have been more average than it was. It hurts me to watch him play for this club that i love how has he not been dropped for being poor? BE HONEST WITH YOURSELVES WOULD HE GET ON ANY OTHER TOP TEAM? I Know some die hard fans should say we shouldn criticise our own players i find that stupid we can voice our opinions we need to revamp our squad and if we dont i can even see us making the top four next season. Look at the difference in Liverpool since they spend some money they destroyed us yesterday. I am worried for our future we are in serious trouble if we dont spend money on midfielders this summer. i am sorry for criticizing the player he is a model professional and always gives a 100% but he is just not good enough. I love manchester united but now i find myself worrying about big away games and having no confidence in the team which never happened me before, I am really worried with the direction our club is going.
we need to revamp our squad and if we dont i can even see us making the top four next season.
ResurrectionRooney wrote:Scouser_Dave wrote:Carrick winning the poll
It's a mystery to you because you're pretty thick and don't really understand football. Nearly all midfielders in the Premier League are worse than Carrick, and he would walk into your team. Ferguson keeps picking him, I think he knows a bit more about football than you do.
Scouser_Dave wrote:ResurrectionRooney wrote:Scouser_Dave wrote:Carrick winning the poll
It's a mystery to you because you're pretty thick and don't really understand football. Nearly all midfielders in the Premier League are worse than Carrick, and he would walk into your team. Ferguson keeps picking him, I think he knows a bit more about football than you do.
Would he fuck
Ferguson keeps picking him because your midfield is a fucking shambles. Probably think's he will spring into this world class midfielder under his guidance. You would have thought the penny would have dropped for the old fart by now.
We do yeah, look at our thread, RR can't stop going on about Carrick, Sneidjer and Nasri, but saying shit like Carrick can't pass...El_indian wrote:so you don't feel the need to improve that midfield?
ResurrectionRooney wrote:Scouser_Dave wrote:ResurrectionRooney wrote:Scouser_Dave wrote:Carrick winning the poll
It's a mystery to you because you're pretty thick and don't really understand football. Nearly all midfielders in the Premier League are worse than Carrick, and he would walk into your team. Ferguson keeps picking him, I think he knows a bit more about football than you do.
Would he fuck
Ferguson keeps picking him because your midfield is a fucking shambles. Probably think's he will spring into this world class midfielder under his guidance. You would have thought the penny would have dropped for the old fart by now.
That explains why we've been so unsuccessful over the past 5 years, we've been carrying a passenger in Carrick. God, I hope the penny drops soon.
