If your club could sign one player, who would it be and why?

The old Eduardo

Erection rooney, trust you to start an argument against liverpool out of it. I know you have a 'haters gonna hate' mentality but you truly are rather pathetic. I just hope and pray that it's all just an act.


Jokes lolololololol. I don't particularly care.

19Jones19v wrote:The old Eduardo

As fantasy signings go, a player from the past is pretty unrealistic.

19Jones19v wrote:The old Eduardo

He was immense back then for you.

He was far from immense, another one of these players overhyped by his absence. Even at his best he wouldn't get into the Arsenal team at the moment. If you want a former Arsenal player at his best you should be looking at people like Toure or Gallas.

ResurrectionRooney wrote:He was far from immense, another one of these players overhyped by his absence. Even at his best he wouldn't get into the Arsenal team at the moment. If you want a former Arsenal player at his best you should be looking at people like Toure or Gallas.

Trust me, when he just joined Arsenal and was playing at his best he was a top striker and if he was still the same now he would easily be able to walk into this Arsenal team and play alongside Van Persie.

Without checking, how many League goals do you think he scored for Arsenal in his 3 full seasons there?

Messi

cheesy wrote:

Pip wrote:Probably Alick Maemae.

What team are your team from?

Solomon Islands.

NZG wrote:Messi

Aim a little higher.

Diego Maradona. Because we need a number 10.

Thierry Henry because he could still score 20+ goals and 10+ assists in the PL.

ResurrectionRooney wrote:He was far from immense, another one of these players overhyped by his absence. Even at his best he wouldn't get into the Arsenal team at the moment. If you want a former Arsenal player at his best you should be looking at people like Toure or Gallas.

Have to agree to many people overrated Eduardo.

Unrealistic: Messi
Realistic: Zidan

Yaya Toure.

Chiellini.

It wont' be too unrealistic because I'm sure he wants to play in Europe.

AriseForLife wrote:Thierry Henry because he could still score 20+ goals and 10+ assists in the PL.

If he found his best form again then he could.

The Bat-Man wrote:Chiellini.

It wont' be too unrealistic because I'm sure he wants to play in Europe.

Italy is in Europe

I don't think he'll leave. Juventus have a massive project going on at the minute.

luke. wrote:

The Bat-Man wrote:Chiellini.

It wont' be too unrealistic because I'm sure he wants to play in Europe.

Italy is in Europe

I don't think he'll leave. Juventus have a massive project going on at the minute.

If he got a big money offer, I'm sure that he would decide to leave.

The answer for every single club in the world should be Messi. The reason is because he's Messi.

menalawyerguy wrote:The answer for every single club in the world should be Messi. The reason is because he's Messi.

But I said in my OP that it was meant to be a realistic choice who your club could actually get.

How do we decide if it's realistic or not? And surely, my answer is more realistic than "Old Eduardo," right? Until somebody invents a time machine, that one is literally impossible.

dena wrote:Xavi cause he's Xavi.

I need to get my own material.

AriseForLife wrote:Thierry Henry because he could still score 20+ goals and 10+ assists in the PL.

He barely goes at that pace in the MLS. What makes you think he could do it in the PL?

menalawyerguy wrote:How do we decide if it's realistic or not? And surely, my answer is more realistic than "Old Eduardo," right? Until somebody invents a time machine, that one is literally impossible.

I guess that you cannot really decide whether it is realistic or not: you just have to use common sense.

cheesy wrote:

menalawyerguy wrote:How do we decide if it's realistic or not? And surely, my answer is more realistic than "Old Eduardo," right? Until somebody invents a time machine, that one is literally impossible.

I guess that you cannot really decide whether it is realistic or not: you just have to use common sense.

Ahh see, there ya go. I don't have this so-called "common sense" thing you reference. I just go on mindless gibberish and impulse. It's worked well for me to date

menalawyerguy wrote:

cheesy wrote:

menalawyerguy wrote:How do we decide if it's realistic or not? And surely, my answer is more realistic than "Old Eduardo," right? Until somebody invents a time machine, that one is literally impossible.

I guess that you cannot really decide whether it is realistic or not: you just have to use common sense.

Ahh see, there ya go. I don't have this so-called "common sense" thing you reference. I just go on mindless gibberish and impulse. It's worked well for me to date

Neither do I, but I deserve a meerkat for trying.

menalawyerguy wrote:

Thank you. I will give you two meerkats in return.

Lucas