Playmaker's Best Premier League Team - RM - Voting

But they didn't get nominated in the other thread.

Thread obviously wasn't open for long enough then. Not everyone comes on here 24/7.

My nomination wasn't put on the poll.

ResurrectionRooney wrote:Ah be fair man, I wouldn't say it when someone was saying something reasonable, something that can be backed up with evidence, like Seaman is better than van der Sar or something, it's only in extraordinary cases. I've never said anything as absurd as what's been going on in the few days when I've been away.

End of the day, they are all opinions. You can't say any one is more valid than the other, because there is no right and wrong opinion. I know you haven't said things like what has been going on, but I do think some of the motives behind some of your posts do deserve to be questioned in the ways that you listed in the disagreement thread. You're not immune to that.

Yeah but he shouldn't be on this poll either, nor should Beckham, the RM spot should just go to Ronaldo.

Ronaldo > Every human being ever.

ResurrectionRooney wrote:Yeah but he shouldn't be on this poll either, nor should Beckham, the RM spot should just go to Ronaldo.

Might seem a bit redundant.

ResurrectionRooney wrote:Yeah but he shouldn't be on this poll either, nor should Beckham, the RM spot should just go to Ronaldo.

I suppose. He was too good for Man United.

Zzonked wrote:

ResurrectionRooney wrote:Ah be fair man, I wouldn't say it when someone was saying something reasonable, something that can be backed up with evidence, like Seaman is better than van der Sar or something, it's only in extraordinary cases. I've never said anything as absurd as what's been going on in the few days when I've been away.

End of the day, they are all opinions. You can't say any one is more valid than the other, because there is no right and wrong opinion. I know you haven't said things like what has been going on, but I do think some of the motives behind some of your posts do deserve to be questioned in the ways that you listed in the disagreement thread. You're not immune to that.

'Joe Cole is better than Lionel Messi'

You're telling me that's as valid an opinion as 'Messi is better than Cole' ? You're telling me that's not wrong?

Like someone said earlier, Henry and Ronaldo should just have automatic positions.

Scott wrote:

ResurrectionRooney wrote:Yeah but he shouldn't be on this poll either, nor should Beckham, the RM spot should just go to Ronaldo.

I suppose. He was too good for Man United.

That's a pretty strange way of looking at it, the fact he left United isn't much of a measure of his quality. Can we say the same about Torres and Atletico/Liverpool? What about Ibrahimovic and Inter? It's almost like you're trying to get in some petty dig at Man United.

ResurrectionRooney wrote:

Zzonked wrote:

ResurrectionRooney wrote:Ah be fair man, I wouldn't say it when someone was saying something reasonable, something that can be backed up with evidence, like Seaman is better than van der Sar or something, it's only in extraordinary cases. I've never said anything as absurd as what's been going on in the few days when I've been away.

End of the day, they are all opinions. You can't say any one is more valid than the other, because there is no right and wrong opinion. I know you haven't said things like what has been going on, but I do think some of the motives behind some of your posts do deserve to be questioned in the ways that you listed in the disagreement thread. You're not immune to that.

'Joe Cole is better than Lionel Messi'

You're telling me that's as valid an opinion as 'Messi is better than Cole' ? You're telling me that's not wrong?

That's the nature of opinion. All it means is the persons perspective, if that's how they see it then that's how they see it.

ResurrectionRooney wrote:

Zzonked wrote:

ResurrectionRooney wrote:Ah be fair man, I wouldn't say it when someone was saying something reasonable, something that can be backed up with evidence, like Seaman is better than van der Sar or something, it's only in extraordinary cases. I've never said anything as absurd as what's been going on in the few days when I've been away.

End of the day, they are all opinions. You can't say any one is more valid than the other, because there is no right and wrong opinion. I know you haven't said things like what has been going on, but I do think some of the motives behind some of your posts do deserve to be questioned in the ways that you listed in the disagreement thread. You're not immune to that.

'Joe Cole is better than Lionel Messi'

You're telling me that's as valid an opinion as 'Messi is better than Cole' ? You're telling me that's not wrong?

Beauty is in the eye of the beholder.

The assumption that all opinions are equally valid is a very faulty one though.

ResurrectionRooney wrote:The assumption that all opinions are equally valid is a very faulty one though.

Validity and logic doesn't really factor in opinion, people only think they do.

Btw I also notice you framed the last one as fact, I do think saying 'Joe Cole is better than Messi' may be wrong unless the 'I think that' was implied.

"I think Joe Cole is better than Messi" is also a fact or a lie, you either think it or you don't. 'Joe Cole is better than Messi' would be the opinion.

I love Beckham he is an absolute legend but Ronaldo is far more dynamic. Ronaldo gets my vote.

GCU wrote:I would say Adam's inclusion is far more controversial than Vidic's, Vidic has been consistently the best central defender in England for 3 straight seasons. In Adam's time, there was a dude by the name of Marcel Desailly who was a far superior individual, pity that his club team wasn't as flash even though Chelsea were decent, but not in Arsenals tier though.

Rio Ferdinand shits on Adams and Vidic, but he's not as much of a thud and blunder defender so he doesn't get as much credit. 2007/2008 he was absolutely amazing.

ResurrectionRooney wrote:Rio Ferdinand shits on Adams and Vidic, but he's not as much of a thud and blunder defender so he doesn't get as much credit. 2007/2008 he was absolutely amazing.

Agreed.

Common sense prevails as always.

Messi's alright, but Joe Cole can do things with a ball that Messi can only dream of.

CLOSE THIS MOD

inb4andafterlock