Join the forum, it's quick and easy

Would you like to react to this message? Create an account in a few clicks or log in to continue.


+21
SBSP
Grenade
Torresxvilla
ayvee1
moscowmadeit3
Danny
H-T-W14i
blackskar
El Jefe
Barton
Theo Filippo
Jamie
dena
Pippo
Kuled
menalawyerguy
The Zlatan
Dink
Trig
Mal
Kris
25 posters

    Red card for RVP - correct or mistake?

    Poll

    Should RVP have had the red card

    [ 11 ]
    Red card for RVP - correct or mistake? Bar_left23%Red card for RVP - correct or mistake? Bar_right [23%] 
    [ 37 ]
    Red card for RVP - correct or mistake? Bar_left77%Red card for RVP - correct or mistake? Bar_right [77%] 

    Total Votes: 48
    Kris
    Kris
    Kris
     
     


    Posts : 842
    Age : 32
    Location : Surprisingly close to Lyngby stadium, Denmark
    • Post n°1

    Red card for RVP - correct or mistake? Empty Red card for RVP - correct or mistake?

    Post by Kris Thu Mar 10, 2011 12:05 am

    So, Roben van Persie got a rather contorversial red card.

    The rules are clear - kick the ball away intentionally, to stall the play after the ref blows his whistle = yellow card.

    However, could he hear the ref and or see the linesman? If he could either, the red card is justified, if he couldn't, he really shouldn't have been sent off. Do you think he could hear the whistle or was looking at the ref?

    vid here: http://onside.dk/fodbold-video/champions-league/barca-arsenal-3-1-se-rodt-kort-og-straffespark
    • Back to top
    Mal
    Mal
    Mal
     
     


    Posts : 31043
    Age : 34
    • Post n°2

    Red card for RVP - correct or mistake? Empty Re: Red card for RVP - correct or mistake?

    Post by Mal Thu Mar 10, 2011 12:06 am

    One second between whistle and shot. Neutral
    • Back to top
    Guest
    Anonymous
    Guest
    Guest


    • Post n°3

    Red card for RVP - correct or mistake? Empty Re: Red card for RVP - correct or mistake?

    Post by Guest Thu Mar 10, 2011 12:06 am

    It wasn't a sending off..
    • Back to top
    Guest
    Anonymous
    Guest
    Guest


    • Post n°4

    Red card for RVP - correct or mistake? Empty Re: Red card for RVP - correct or mistake?

    Post by Guest Thu Mar 10, 2011 12:14 am

    In theory, celebrating a goal is wasting time also seeing as the clock keeps ticking. How about players stop wasting time and run straight back to their side to restart the game?


    Oh wait, there is stoppage time for this... So why didn't he just add 10 seconds on to account for him kicking the ball away.

    Obvious time wasting should be punished with a yellow card, this is usually if it is done more than once.
    • Back to top
    Kris
    Kris
    Kris
     
     


    Posts : 842
    Age : 32
    Location : Surprisingly close to Lyngby stadium, Denmark
    • Post n°5

    Red card for RVP - correct or mistake? Empty Re: Red card for RVP - correct or mistake?

    Post by Kris Thu Mar 10, 2011 12:15 am

    I voted no too.

    I doubt he could hear it, and why the fuck would he want to look at the linesman in this case, he's a striker, his job is to score goals.
    • Back to top
    Trig
    Trig
    Trig
     
     


    Formerly known as : And0TheGr8
    Posts : 2806
    Age : 35
    Location : Charleston, SC
    • Post n°6

    Red card for RVP - correct or mistake? Empty Re: Red card for RVP - correct or mistake?

    Post by Trig Thu Mar 10, 2011 12:39 am

    Probably one of the worst red cards i've seen
    • Back to top
    Dink
    Dink
    Dink
     
     


    Posts : 558
    Age : 31
    • Post n°7

    Red card for RVP - correct or mistake? Empty Re: Red card for RVP - correct or mistake?

    Post by Dink Thu Mar 10, 2011 12:49 am

    Definitely not. Thought they should of have a few red cards though, Koncielny and RVP on Alves for instance.
    • Back to top
    Mal
    Mal
    Mal
     
     


    Posts : 31043
    Age : 34
    • Post n°8

    Red card for RVP - correct or mistake? Empty Re: Red card for RVP - correct or mistake?

    Post by Mal Thu Mar 10, 2011 1:28 am

    Dink wrote:Definitely not. Thought they should of have a few red cards though, Koncielny and RVP on Alves for instance.

    Red card for RVP - correct or mistake? X610

    Red card for RVP - correct or mistake? 82710884
    • Back to top
    The Zlatan
    The Zlatan
    The Zlatan
     
     


    Posts : 10347
    • Post n°9

    Red card for RVP - correct or mistake? Empty Re: Red card for RVP - correct or mistake?

    Post by The Zlatan Thu Mar 10, 2011 1:34 am

    Wow, I haven't seen the one with Adriano grabbing Nasri's neck. So there was a neck grab by Abidal on van Persie, a slap on the face by Busquets on van Persie, and a neck grab on Nasri by Adriano. So three unrightfully called red cards there then Coffee


    Last edited by ZlatanFabregas on Thu Mar 10, 2011 1:47 am; edited 1 time in total
    • Back to top
    Dink
    Dink
    Dink
     
     


    Posts : 558
    Age : 31
    • Post n°10

    Red card for RVP - correct or mistake? Empty Re: Red card for RVP - correct or mistake?

    Post by Dink Thu Mar 10, 2011 1:35 am

    Mal wrote:
    Dink wrote:Definitely not. Thought they should of have a few red cards though, Koncielny and RVP on Alves for instance.

    Red card for RVP - correct or mistake? X610

    Red card for RVP - correct or mistake? 82710884
    I wasn't saying they shouldn't of got any reds either; I wanted Arsenal to go through. Dani Alves should of got a yellow for diving.
    • Back to top
    menalawyerguy
    menalawyerguy
    menalawyerguy
     
     


    Posts : 6547
    Age : 111
    • Post n°11

    Red card for RVP - correct or mistake? Empty Re: Red card for RVP - correct or mistake?

    Post by menalawyerguy Thu Mar 10, 2011 1:37 am

    And a perfectly good goal disallowed as well as a penalty in the box that wasn't given. So what are you bitching about? You didn't get screwed anymore than Barca did.
    • Back to top
    Mal
    Mal
    Mal
     
     


    Posts : 31043
    Age : 34
    • Post n°12

    Red card for RVP - correct or mistake? Empty Re: Red card for RVP - correct or mistake?

    Post by Mal Thu Mar 10, 2011 1:38 am

    ZlatanFabregas wrote:Wow, I haven't seen the one with Alves grabbing Nasri's neck. So there was a neck grab by Abidal on van Persie, a slap on the face by Busquets on van Persie, and a neck grab on Nasri by Alves. So three unrightfully called red cards there then Coffee

    I think that's Adriano on Nasri.
    • Back to top
    The Zlatan
    The Zlatan
    The Zlatan
     
     


    Posts : 10347
    • Post n°13

    Red card for RVP - correct or mistake? Empty Re: Red card for RVP - correct or mistake?

    Post by The Zlatan Thu Mar 10, 2011 1:47 am

    Mal wrote:
    ZlatanFabregas wrote:Wow, I haven't seen the one with Alves grabbing Nasri's neck. So there was a neck grab by Abidal on van Persie, a slap on the face by Busquets on van Persie, and a neck grab on Nasri by Alves. So three unrightfully called red cards there then Coffee

    I think that's Adriano on Nasri.

    Oops, just noticed that, better do some editing.
    • Back to top
    The Zlatan
    The Zlatan
    The Zlatan
     
     


    Posts : 10347
    • Post n°14

    Red card for RVP - correct or mistake? Empty Re: Red card for RVP - correct or mistake?

    Post by The Zlatan Thu Mar 10, 2011 1:49 am

    menalawyerguy wrote:And a perfectly good goal disallowed as well as a penalty in the box that wasn't given. So what are you bitching about? You didn't get screwed anymore than Barca did.

    I'm not saying anyone got screwed, I am just pointing out the fact that Barcelona could have ended up with 8 men.
    • Back to top
    Kuled
    avatar
    Kuled
     
     


    Posts : 55235
    Age : 28
    • Post n°15

    Red card for RVP - correct or mistake? Empty Re: Red card for RVP - correct or mistake?

    Post by Kuled Thu Mar 10, 2011 2:02 am

    Why don't the guys that voted yes say they think it was a red?
    • Back to top
    Mal
    Mal
    Mal
     
     


    Posts : 31043
    Age : 34
    • Post n°16

    Red card for RVP - correct or mistake? Empty Re: Red card for RVP - correct or mistake?

    Post by Mal Thu Mar 10, 2011 2:04 am

    Kuled wrote:Why don't the guys that voted yes say they think it was a red?

    Because they're wrong and they know they are. They just want to even up the voting. Neutral
    • Back to top
    Pippo
    Pippo
    Pippo
     
     


    Formerly known as : Pippo Inzaghi
    Posts : 30777
    • Post n°17

    Red card for RVP - correct or mistake? Empty Re: Red card for RVP - correct or mistake?

    Post by Pippo Thu Mar 10, 2011 2:11 am

    No, it was not a red card.
    • Back to top
    dena
    dena
    dena
     
     


    Posts : 18688
    Age : 35
    Location : only place to find base heads and hot women
    • Post n°18

    Red card for RVP - correct or mistake? Empty Re: Red card for RVP - correct or mistake?

    Post by dena Thu Mar 10, 2011 2:28 am

    The Van Persie incident was obviously a bad call.
    • Back to top
    Jamie
    Jamie
    Jamie
     
     


    Posts : 24047
    Age : 63
    Location : Thiago
    Supports : That Catalan club
    • Post n°19

    Red card for RVP - correct or mistake? Empty Re: Red card for RVP - correct or mistake?

    Post by Jamie Thu Mar 10, 2011 2:33 am

    He knew he was offside but still a poor decision.
    • Back to top
    Mal
    Mal
    Mal
     
     


    Posts : 31043
    Age : 34
    • Post n°20

    Red card for RVP - correct or mistake? Empty Re: Red card for RVP - correct or mistake?

    Post by Mal Thu Mar 10, 2011 2:34 am

    Fine Shagger wrote:He knew he was offside but still a poor decision.

    Did he? We have a psychic. Run
    • Back to top
    Jamie
    Jamie
    Jamie
     
     


    Posts : 24047
    Age : 63
    Location : Thiago
    Supports : That Catalan club
    • Post n°21

    Red card for RVP - correct or mistake? Empty Re: Red card for RVP - correct or mistake?

    Post by Jamie Thu Mar 10, 2011 2:38 am

    Mal wrote:
    Fine Shagger wrote:He knew he was offside but still a poor decision.

    Did he? We have a psychic. Run

    Or, someone who can see Van Persie was looking at the linesman when he flagged, and that a left footed striker shot quickly with his weak foot when he had plenty of time.
    • Back to top
    Mal
    Mal
    Mal
     
     


    Posts : 31043
    Age : 34
    • Post n°22

    Red card for RVP - correct or mistake? Empty Re: Red card for RVP - correct or mistake?

    Post by Mal Thu Mar 10, 2011 2:39 am

    Fine Shagger wrote:
    Mal wrote:
    Fine Shagger wrote:He knew he was offside but still a poor decision.

    Did he? We have a psychic. Run

    Or, someone who can see Van Persie was looking at the linesman when he flagged, and that a left footed striker shot quickly with his weak foot when he had plenty of time.

    He looked like he didn't have a clue to me but you're a body language expert so I won't argue. Neutral
    • Back to top
    Guest
    Anonymous
    Guest
    Guest


    • Post n°23

    Red card for RVP - correct or mistake? Empty Re: Red card for RVP - correct or mistake?

    Post by Guest Thu Mar 10, 2011 2:41 am

    UFEA hate english clubs....
    • Back to top
    Jamie
    Jamie
    Jamie
     
     


    Posts : 24047
    Age : 63
    Location : Thiago
    Supports : That Catalan club
    • Post n°24

    Red card for RVP - correct or mistake? Empty Re: Red card for RVP - correct or mistake?

    Post by Jamie Thu Mar 10, 2011 2:43 am

    DamianMartinez wrote:UFEA hate english clubs....

    What I mean right here Mal about your fans being embarrassing.
    • Back to top
    Guest
    Anonymous
    Guest
    Guest


    • Post n°25

    Red card for RVP - correct or mistake? Empty Re: Red card for RVP - correct or mistake?

    Post by Guest Thu Mar 10, 2011 2:46 am

    In theory, right decison.

    In realility, wrong decision. Ref should have shown some common sense.
    • Back to top
    Guest
    Anonymous
    Guest
    Guest


    • Post n°26

    Red card for RVP - correct or mistake? Empty Re: Red card for RVP - correct or mistake?

    Post by Guest Thu Mar 10, 2011 2:58 am

    Fine Shagger wrote:
    DamianMartinez wrote:UFEA hate english clubs....

    What I mean right here Mal about your fans being embarrassing.

    but is soo true, and it aint embarrassing. whats embarrasing is how barca have to get the ref on there side remember the chelsea v barca game? < that was a "fucking disgrace" in the words of drogba
    • Back to top
    Theo Filippo
    Theo Filippo
    Theo Filippo
     
     


    Formerly known as : Filippo Inzaghi
    Posts : 21636
    Age : 30
    • Post n°27

    Red card for RVP - correct or mistake? Empty Re: Red card for RVP - correct or mistake?

    Post by Theo Filippo Thu Mar 10, 2011 3:00 am

    No. The game should of been abandoned because barca should of been down to 6 men
    • Back to top
    Jamie
    Jamie
    Jamie
     
     


    Posts : 24047
    Age : 63
    Location : Thiago
    Supports : That Catalan club
    • Post n°28

    Red card for RVP - correct or mistake? Empty Re: Red card for RVP - correct or mistake?

    Post by Jamie Thu Mar 10, 2011 3:03 am

    DamianMartinez wrote:
    Fine Shagger wrote:
    DamianMartinez wrote:UFEA hate english clubs....

    What I mean right here Mal about your fans being embarrassing.

    but is soo true, and it aint embarrassing. whats embarrasing is how barca have to get the ref on there side remember the chelsea v barca game? < that was a "fucking disgrace" in the words of drogba

    Was it a fucking disgrace Barca weren't awarded a penalty in the first leg which would've changed the 2nd leg dynamic?

    Was it a disgrace Messi wasn't given a goal in the first leg, or Pedro a penalty in the first leg, or Messi a penalty in the 2nd leg?
    • Back to top
    Theo Filippo
    Theo Filippo
    Theo Filippo
     
     


    Formerly known as : Filippo Inzaghi
    Posts : 21636
    Age : 30
    • Post n°29

    Red card for RVP - correct or mistake? Empty Re: Red card for RVP - correct or mistake?

    Post by Theo Filippo Thu Mar 10, 2011 3:05 am

    Fine Shagger wrote:
    DamianMartinez wrote:
    Fine Shagger wrote:
    DamianMartinez wrote:UFEA hate english clubs....

    What I mean right here Mal about your fans being embarrassing.

    but is soo true, and it aint embarrassing. whats embarrasing is how barca have to get the ref on there side remember the chelsea v barca game? < that was a "fucking disgrace" in the words of drogba

    Was it a fucking disgrace Barca weren't awarded a penalty in the first leg which would've changed the 2nd leg dynamic?

    Was it a disgrace Messi wasn't given a goal in the first leg, or Pedro a penalty in the first leg, or Messi a penalty in the 2nd leg?
    Koscielny clearly got the ball therefore your argument goes out the window.
    Anyone with football knowledge will know that the game should of been abandoned before the van persie incident. There should of been 5 red cards for barcelona
    • Back to top
    Jamie
    Jamie
    Jamie
     
     


    Posts : 24047
    Age : 63
    Location : Thiago
    Supports : That Catalan club
    • Post n°30

    Red card for RVP - correct or mistake? Empty Re: Red card for RVP - correct or mistake?

    Post by Jamie Thu Mar 10, 2011 3:06 am

    What do you actually add to this forum?
    • Back to top
    Sponsored content

    Sponsored content


    • Post n°31

    Red card for RVP - correct or mistake? Empty Re: Red card for RVP - correct or mistake?

    Post by Sponsored content

    • Back to top
      Current date/time is Fri Nov 15, 2024 11:42 am