Most underrated/overrated footballer

dena wrote:

(polskaGOLA) wrote:Soldado as well. Nearly as consistent of a goalscorer as David Villa.

Also Huge one, Darijo Srna.

Srna is probably among the world's top 3 RB's, but since he plays for Shaktar, he get's little attention.

The pass two years he's been alright, but let's not go overboard with comparing to Villa.

But then again, you are Polska.

I said that Soldado had a goal ratio rivaling that of Villa (before Soldado moved to Valencia that is)

Not saying Soldado is as good as Villa, no.

He is kind of like the La Liga version of Darren Bent. Not in particularly amazing player, but a very consistent goalscorer in the league.

Underrated - Backary Sagna, although people are finally starting to see how good he is.
Overrated - Glen Johnson, although people are finally starting to see how shit he actually is.

Underrated: Marouane Fellaini

Underrated: Mata/Eto'o
Overrated: Glen Johnson (can't play defense for his life)

overated:rooney

underated:busquets

ZlatanFabregas wrote:Underrated - Backary Sagna, although people are finally starting to see how good he is.

At squaring up to people?

Busquets is underrated. Can you believe he's never won an Oscar? What a crime. Not even his performance in "The Shining: Champions League Version" hauled in any hardware. Utter disgrace.

"HEEEEEERRRREEEEE"S SERGIO!"

Forlan isn't underrated in the media in spain, Aguero get's all the attention but Forlan's usually the guy who saves the day so he gets a lot praise also... just not as much as kun

Luxz0rz wrote:

ZlatanFabregas wrote:Underrated - Backary Sagna, although people are finally starting to see how good he is.

At squaring up to people?

Sagna is one of calmest players at Arsenal. And if you had seen any of the games and not just highlights, you would notice that he's been treated like shit by several players. There's nothing wrong with showing a bit of passion anyway.

Torresxvilla wrote:Underrated: Mata/Eto'o
Overrated: Glen Johnson (can't play defense for his life)

SMT

Underrated: Cristiano Ronaldo

Overrated: Messi

Over rated: Wes Morgan - Very good player, but I don't think he's as amazing as some of our fans make out

Under rated: Dele Adebola - Used as a scapegoat by most fans, but in our last 3 games, he's came on and completely changed the game and we've won
Joel Lynch - Cos he doesn't play much our 'fans' assume he's shit, but he's actually played really well since we've lost Bertrand

Overrated: Casillas
Underrated: Arboleda

Underrated: Michael Bradley. Still doesn't get all the praise that he should, especially at home amongst USA supporters. I think he gets due praise in Germany, but there are large portions of fans here that still doubt him, or claim all his success is only due to the fact that his father is the manager of the national team.

Overrated: Gael Clichy. Dude is worth at least two or three mistakes a game that leads to a goal scoring chance for the opposition. Somehow, this is usually passed off as a one off, even though it happens almost every game. And in the past, Arsenal supporters have claimed that he is just as good as the likes of Cole and Evra...

To be fair in the past he was pretty good. Not recently though ><

People might think im being bias but Paul Robinson , Ryan Nelsen and Michel Salgado are all underated

The yanks are underated.

He started having those mental lapses in 07/08. I thought the one in the Birmingham game (the Eduardo game) where he conceded the penalty late on was the one off. But I don't think he has ever really recovered from that.

Underrated: Lucas, future of the brazilian midfield


Overrated: Peinaar

Tom wrote:Forlan isn't underrated in the media in spain, Aguero get's all the attention but Forlan's usually the guy who saves the day so he gets a lot praise also... just not as much as kun

I remember Andres going on about how Aguero is overrated.

Pip wrote:Overrated: Casillas
Underrated: Arboleda

Arboleda is far from underrated in Poland.

Scuba Steve wrote:Overrated: Gael Clichy. Dude is worth at least two or three mistakes a game that leads to a goal scoring chance for the opposition. Somehow, this is usually passed off as a one off, even though it happens almost every game. And in the past, Arsenal supporters have claimed that he is just as good as the likes of Cole and Evra...

Only non-Arsenal fans actually rate Clichy. Anyone who follows Arsenal would know he is complete shit.

Although in the past, Clichy was class, but that was in the distant past.

Underrated - Bogdan Stancu, Lee Barnard, Yaya Toure, Emile Heskey.

Overrated - Rooney, Ibrahimovic (even though he has been excellent recently) Jordan Rhodes, Alex Smithies.

Overrated: Romelu Lukaku

Although Luxorz will disagree, I find Scott Loach overrated.

Underrated : Kyle Lafferty.

underrated
-Anderson
-Nani
-Rafael
-Welbeck
-Onuoha
-Lee Chung yong
Overrated
-Wilshere
- Adam Johnson
-Clichy
-Arshavin(Not that much now)
-Chamack
-Hart
-Parker

off the top of my head.

Underrated - Van Der Sar

moscowmadeit3 wrote:Underrated - Van Der Sar

Good point

He does the little things so well he doesn't have to make amazing saves and so you never notice him.

Underrated - Glen Johnson. Only retards think he can't defend.

Overrated - Barcelona. Boring football.