Official Newcastle United Thread

Big_Lad_Taylor wrote:

Gegilworld93 wrote:I know he is composed, was just kidding but Vermaelen and Agger are better ball-playing wise. Luiz probably too but he's just shit at defending.

I dont think you realize how good he is on the ball..

Seen you on the EA forum. Out of interest, are you overrating Newcastle on purpose, or do you actually mean what you say? It's a genuine question because i'm not sure at all.

arsenalap11 wrote:

Big_Lad_Taylor wrote:
I dont think you realize how good he is on the ball..

Seen you on the EA forum. Out of interest, are you overrating Newcastle on purpose, or do you actually mean what you say? It's a genuine question because i'm not sure at all.

Give me an example of who i overrate? Who are you on ea pal?

Big_Lad_Taylor wrote:

arsenalap11 wrote:

Seen you on the EA forum. Out of interest, are you overrating Newcastle on purpose, or do you actually mean what you say? It's a genuine question because i'm not sure at all.

Give me an example of who i overrate? Who are you on ea pal?

To be fair it might not be you, but most Newcastle fans on there act like the Liverpool fans on here and I can't tell if it's serious or not.

And same as here, but not logged on for a while, just roam really.

arsenalap11 wrote:

Big_Lad_Taylor wrote:
Give me an example of who i overrate? Who are you on ea pal?

To be fair it might not be you, but most Newcastle fans on there act like the Liverpool fans on here and I can't tell if it's serious or not.

And same as here, but not logged on for a while, just roam really.

What do i say when you wonder if im serious??
Like coloccini being one of the best CB in the league?

Yea to be fair that's one of them although it depends what you mean by best.

arsenalap11 wrote:Yea to be fair that's one of them although it depends what you mean by best.

i mean best as in best

arsenalap11 wrote:

Big_Lad_Taylor wrote:
Give me an example of who i overrate? Who are you on ea pal?

To be fair it might not be you, but most Newcastle fans on there act like the Liverpool fans on here and I can't tell if it's serious or not.

And same as here, but not logged on for a while, just roam really.

I'm usually joking 80% of the time on there, only person I would say that people would think I'm joking but 100% serious is with Guthrie.

Big_Lad_Taylor wrote:

arsenalap11 wrote:Yea to be fair that's one of them although it depends what you mean by best.

i mean best as in best

Well thanks for that.

By best do you mean top 5, top 10?

arsenalap11 wrote:

Big_Lad_Taylor wrote:
i mean best as in best

Well thanks for that.

By best do you mean top 5, top 10?

Top 5

Right, well then I think you're overrating them, but fair enough if that's your opinion. Was just wondering if you were being serious or not.

arsenalap11 wrote:Right, well then I think you're overrating them, but fair enough if that's your opinion. Was just wondering if you were being serious or not.

Yeh im being serious pal. Really really rate him, not many better.

Coloccini is brilliant from what I watch, who do you think the top 5 are then? (doesn't have to be in order)

Don't get me wrong, I think he's a good CB, but I wouldn't say top 5. Top 10 yeah maybe.

kyro7 wrote:Coloccini is brilliant from what I watch, who do you think the top 5 are then? (doesn't have to be in order)

Not sure, in truth i would be going off reputation too much. Same could be said to those who dont rate colo.
I see most 3/4 times a season, maybe twice in the flesh, which is required to properly rate.

arsenalap11 wrote:Don't get me wrong, I think he's a good CB, but I wouldn't say top 5. Top 10 yeah maybe.

So who are you thinking is better?

Are you one of the people that think Koscielny is awful btw? Again out of interest.

arsenalap11 wrote:Are you one of the people that think Koscielny is awful btw? Again out of interest.

I think he has improved drastically. Seems to have been significantly better this term. As you would expect, CB's always need a year to settle. I am the type of person who will refrain from commenting if he doesn't know...

Big_Lad_Taylor wrote:

arsenalap11 wrote:Are you one of the people that think Koscielny is awful btw? Again out of interest.

I think he has improved drastically. Seems to have been significantly better this term. As you would expect, CB's always need a year to settle. I am the type of person who will refrain from commenting if he doesn't know...

Fair dues!

Naturally i am used to fighting off the tag of overrating delusional. After all i did say how enrique was the best in the league and carroll would fail as he isnt very good...

Big_Lad_Taylor wrote:

arsenalap11 wrote:Don't get me wrong, I think he's a good CB, but I wouldn't say top 5. Top 10 yeah maybe.

So who are you thinking is better?

Vermaelen
Koscielny
Vidic
Ferdinand when fit
Terry even though he's gone downhill
Ivanovic
Possibly Alex but atm probably not
Agger
Kompany
King when fit

Not in any order.

Big_Lad_Taylor wrote:Naturally i am used to fighting off the tag of overrating delusional. After all i did say how enrique was the best in the league and carroll would fail as he isnt very good...

Personally don't agree with that.

arsenalap11 wrote:

Big_Lad_Taylor wrote:
So who are you thinking is better?

Vermaelen
Koscielny
Vidic
Ferdinand when fit
Terry even though he's gone downhill
Ivanovic
Possibly Alex but atm probably not
Agger
Kompany
King when fit

Not in any order.

I think he is better than Koscielny, ferdinand, agger, king, ivanovic and alex. I find the last two offensive. He is really good pal...

I dont see who can claim to be better than jose..

Big_Lad_Taylor wrote:

arsenalap11 wrote:

Vermaelen
Koscielny
Vidic
Ferdinand when fit
Terry even though he's gone downhill
Ivanovic
Possibly Alex but atm probably not
Agger
Kompany
King when fit

Not in any order.

I think he is better than Koscielny, ferdinand, agger, king, ivanovic and alex. I find the last two offensive. He is really good pal...

Well then we'll have to differ. I think all of those are better, the last one is debatable but it's close.

Big_Lad_Taylor wrote:I dont see who can claim to be better than jose..

Baines, Cole still just. Think Evras lost it though.

arsenalap11 wrote:

Big_Lad_Taylor wrote:
I think he is better than Koscielny, ferdinand, agger, king, ivanovic and alex. I find the last two offensive. He is really good pal...

Well then we'll have to differ. I think all of those are better, the last one is debatable but it's close.

Big_Lad_Taylor wrote:I dont see who can claim to be better than jose..

Baines, Cole still just. Think Evras lost it though.

I couldnt disagree more with you over either. But best we left it there..

Big_Lad_Taylor wrote:

arsenalap11 wrote:

Well then we'll have to differ. I think all of those are better, the last one is debatable but it's close.



Baines, Cole still just. Think Evras lost it though.

I couldnt disagree more with you over either. But best we left it there..

He's an Arsenal fan, those clowns think everyone is shit if they don't play for ''by far the greatest team, the world has ever seen'' Arsenal FC.

Whats happening with Maiga?

We might wait until the summer to bring in a new ST... AHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH!!!! DEKKKKAAA YOU CONNIVING CUNT!

RollnRock wrote:

Big_Lad_Taylor wrote:
I couldnt disagree more with you over either. But best we left it there..

He's an Arsenal fan, those clowns think everyone is shit if they don't play for ''by far the greatest team, the world has ever seen'' Arsenal FC.

Whats happening with Maiga?

Guessing you're one of the twats from EA though. This isn't EA anyway, we don't all think we're by far the greatest team blah blah..

2 points in the last 15.

Jordo wrote:2 points in the last 15.

Aye... you seen who we played? Then take a peak at our back line kiddo... take a peak.

Big_Lad_Taylor wrote:We might wait until the summer to bring in a new ST... AHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH!!!! DEKKKKAAA YOU CONNIVING CUNT!

Bit of a kick in the arse as they've had 12 months to find someone, but think a CB is a priority atm.