What should your teams ratings be on Fifa 12?

Just post what you think they should be (or rather, what you reckon they will be), used to be called the database discussion on EA. Do starting XI, whole team or a random selection.

Hart 83
Clichy 78
Kompany 85
Lescott 82
Richards 80
Johnson 79
Silva 84
Yaya Toure 84
De Jong 83
Tevez 85
Dzeko 82

Zabaleta 79
Milner 80
Kolarov 78
Barry 80
Kolo Toure 82
Balotelli 81

Reina - 85
Doni - 75? Not sure how good he is

Johnson - 81/82
Carra - 79/80
Agger - 82
Skrtel - 80/81
Soto - 76/77
Kelly - 78
Wilson - 76
Ayala - 74
Aurelio - 77

Poulsen - 13
Gerrard - 85
Henderson - 78
Adam - 79/80
Meireles - 80
Lucas - 81/82
Aquilani - 79/80
Shelvey - 76
Spearing - 75
Downing - 81
Coady - 73
Cole - 77
Maxi - 78

Suarez - 84
Carroll - 82
Ngog - 76
Kuyt - 80
Pacheco - 75


Not sure which of our youth players will be in the game but possible players are Flanagan, Robinson, Wisdom, Suso, Sterling, Morgan etc.

Jussi - 78/79
Bogdan - 75
Steinsson - 76
Marcos Alonso - 68-70
Robinson - 70
Cahill - 80
Knight - 76
Ricketts - 71
Wheater - 75
Muamba - 76
Holden - 80
Petrov - 74
Gardner - 70
Mark Davies - 78
Pratley - 70-73
Lee - 80
Kevin Davies - 74/75
Jeffren - 76
Reo-Coker - 78

Lee Camp - 76
Paul Smith - 69
Karl Darlow - 61

Chris Gunter - 72
Brendan Moloney - 66
Wes Morgan - 71
Luke Chambers - 74
Jamaal Lascelles - 58
Joel Lynch - 63

Paul Anderson - 68
Jonathan Greening - 73
Andy Reid - 74
George Boateng - 68
Chris Cohen - 75
Lewis McGugan - 76
Radoslaw Majewski - 70
Guy Moussi - 71
Garath McLeary - 67

Dexter Blackstock - 70
Marcus Tudgay - 67
Robbie Findley - 67
David McGoldrick - 66
Joe Garner - 68


Overall Team Rating: 3 Stars




Dont think i've missed anyone

Shay Given: 81

Luke Young: 78
James Collins: 78
Richard Dunne: 79
Stephen Warnock: 76/77

Stillian Petrov: 78
Jean Makoun: 80
Stephen Ireland: 79

Marc Albrighton: 80
Darren Bent: 84
Gabriel Agbonlahor: 80 /////////////// Charles N'Zogbia: 80


Edit:Subs Bench

Brad Guzan: 75
Andy Marshall: 68

Ciaran Clark: 77
Habib Beye: 74/75
Carlos Cuellar: 77
Eric Lichaj: 69/70
Nathan Baker: 69/70

Fabian Delph: 77
Barry Bannan: 75
Chris Herd: 69

Nathan Delfouneso: 74/75
Emile Heskey: 99 74/75
Andreas Weimann: 68/69

Scott Brown: 53

Sido Jombati: 56
Kyle Haynes: 48
Steve Elliot: 52
Alan Bennett: 60
Danny Andrew: 57
Keith Lowe: 61
Andy Gallinagh: 54

Michael Pook: 51
David Bird: 53
Russell Penn: 54
Marlon Pack: 62
Kaid Mohammed: 57
Josh Lowe: 60
Brian Smikle: 54
Theo Lewis: 53

Daryl Duffy: 60
Jeff Goulding: 58
Ethan Moore: 53
James Spencer: 56

Johnson - 81
Carra - 80
Agger - 81
Skrtel - 80
Soto - 76
Kelly - 78
Wilson - 74
Ayala - 73
Aurelio - 77

Poulsen - 10
Gerrard - 85
Henderson - 78
Adam - 79
Meireles - 80
Lucas - 82
Aquilani - 80
Shelvey - 77
Spearing - 75
Downing - 82
Coady - 73
Cole - 77
Maxi - 78

Suarez - 86
Carroll - 82
Ngog - 76
Kuyt - 80
Pacheco - 75

If I was to do it as a Fiorentina fan

Frey - 79
Per Krøldrup - 80
Gamberini - 83
Juan Manuel Vargas - 82
Jovetic - 81
Gilardino - 80
Montolivo - 84
Cerci - 79
De Silvestri - 77
Boruc - 80
Behrami - 78
Babacar - 76

Lucasz Fabianski - 81
Vito Mannone -73
Wojciech Szczesny - 80
James Shea - 68

Carl Jenkinson - 70
Bacary Sagna - 84
Laurent Koscielny - 79
Johan Djourou - 79
Thomas Vermealen - 83
Sebastien Squillaci - 71
Miguel - 71
Kyle Bartley - 73
Kieran Gibbs - 78
Armand Traore - 74

Emmanuel Eboue -75
Alex Song - 83
Craig Eastmond - 70
Emmanuel Frimpong -74
Francesc Fabregas -86
Aaron Ramsey -80
Henri Lansbury -76
Abou Diaby - 77
Denilson - 71
Conor Henderson -64
Oguzhan Ozyakup -63
Jack Wilshere -84
Tomas Rosicky - 79
Samir Nasri -86

Theo Walcott - 83
Marouane Chamakh -79
Robin Van Persie - 86
Jay Emmanuel Thomas - 74
Nicklas Bendtner - 79
Benik Afobe - 72
Sanchez Watt -75
Carlos Vela - 78
Andrey Arshavin - 81
Gervinho - 83

Reina - 84
Doni - 73

Johnson - 80
Carra - 81
Agger - 82
Skrtel - 80
Soto - 74
Kelly - 77
Wilson - 72
Ayala - 72
Aurelio - 77
Insua - 75

Poulsen - 65
Gerrard - 84
Henderson - 79
Adam - 77
Meireles - 80
Lucas - 80
Aquilani - 80
Shelvey - 74
Spearing - 73
Downing - 80
Cole - 76
Maxi - 79

Suarez - 84
Carroll - 80
Ngog - 74
Kuyt - 80
Pacheco - 74

Lucasz Fabianski - 79
Vito Mannone -75
Wojciech Szczesny - 81
James Shea - 65

Carl Jenkinson - 72
Bacary Sagna - 84
Laurent Koscielny - 80
Johan Djourou - 79
Thomas Vermealen - 83
Sebastien Squillaci - 78
Miguel - 70
Kyle Bartley - 72
Kieran Gibbs - 78
Armand Traore - 75

Emmanuel Eboue -77
Alex Song - 83
Craig Eastmond - 70
Emmanuel Frimpong -75
Francesc Fabregas -86
Aaron Ramsey -80
Henri Lansbury -75
Abou Diaby - 79
Denilson - 73
Conor Henderson -65
Oguzhan Ozyakup -60
Jack Wilshere -82
Tomas Rosicky - 79
Samir Nasri -85

Theo Walcott - 83
Marouane Chamakh -80
Robin Van Persie - 86
Jay Emmanuel Thomas - 75
Nicklas Bendtner - 80
Benik Afobe - 74
Sanchez Watt -75
Carlos Vela - 78
Andrey Arshavin - 82
Gervinho - 83

Lucasz Fabianski - 78
Vito Mannone -75
Wojciech Szczesny - 82
James Shea - 68

Carl Jenkinson - 73
Bacary Sagna - 84
Laurent Koscielny - 81
Johan Djourou - 80
Thomas Vermealen - 84
Sebastien Squillaci - 77
Miguel - 71
Kyle Bartley - 73
Kieran Gibbs - 79
Armand Traore - 76

Emmanuel Eboue -77
Alex Song - 84
Craig Eastmond - 71
Emmanuel Frimpong -74
Francesc Fabregas - 86
Aaron Ramsey - 81
Henri Lansbury -76
Abou Diaby - 79
Denilson - 74
Conor Henderson -67
Oguzhan Ozyakup -61
Jack Wilshere -83
Tomas Rosicky - 78
Samir Nasri - 85

Theo Walcott - 83
Marouane Chamakh -81
Robin Van Persie - 87
Jay Emmanuel Thomas - 74
Nicklas Bendtner - 79
Benik Afobe - 74
Sanchez Watt -75
Carlos Vela - 78
Andrey Arshavin - 83
Gervinho - 84

Kelvin Davis - 70
Bart Bialkowski - 69

Danny Butterfield - 65
Frazer Richardson - 66
José Fonte - 74
Radhi Jaidi - 64
Aaron Martin - 65
Danny Seaborne - 64
Dan Harding - 67
Ryan Dickson - 64
Joseph Mills - 60
Danny Fox - 70

Steve De Ridder - 68
Jack Cork - 70
Morgan Schneiderlin - 70
Dean Hammond - 67
Adam Lallana - 77
Jason Puncheon - 68
Richard Chaplow - 66

Jonathon Forte - 63
Guly Do Prado - 69
David Connolly - 66
Lee Barnard - 69
Rickie Lambert - 72

That's just the first team.

De Gea - 80
Evra - 81
Vidic - 87
Rio - 85
Rafael - 82
Nani - 87
Carrick - 80
Anderson - 80
Valencia - 82
Berbatov - 81
Rooney - 87

Lindegaard - ?
Evans - 78
Jones - ?
Fabio - 80
Hernandez - 80
Giggs - 81
Park - 82
Fletcher - 79
Young - 80
Fletcher - 80
Gibson - 0
Cleverley - High 70's
Pogba- low 70's
Norwood, low 70s
Morrison - 99
Owen - 80
Welbeck - 79/80
Macheda - 78
Diouf - 76

Casillas - 87
Adán - 76
Mejías - 70

Ramos - 83
Arbeloa - 81
Pepe - 85
Carvalho - 85
Varane - 78
Albiol - 80
Marcelo - 83
Coentrão - 83

Alonso - 86
Khedira - 81
Sahin - 83
Granero - 79
Özil - 85
Kaká - 83
Callejón - 79
Di María - 84
Altintop - 75

Cristiano - 90
Higuaín - 83
Benzema - 85

Peter Brezovan - 66
Michael Poke - 62
Casper Ankergren - 69

Gordon Greer - 69
Tommy Elphick - 68
Lewis Dunk - 66
Adam El-Abd - 69
Inigo Calderon - 70
Romain Vincelot - 68
Marcos Painter - 71
Mauricio Taricco - 64

Alan Navarro - 66
Matthew Sparrow - 68
Craig Noone - 70
Gary Dicker - 68
Kazenga LuaLua -76
Liam Bridcutt - 69
Will Buckley - 71

Will Hoskins - 70
Ashley Barnes - 67
Craig Mackail-Smith - 77

Kenneth Vermeer 76
Jeroen Verhoeven 72


Gregory Van Der Wiel 80
Jan Vertonghen 81
Toby Alderweireld 77
Daley Blind 74
Nicolai Boilesen 75
Andre Ooijer 76
Bruno Silva ? 68 (I haven't seen him play at all)

Vurnon Anita 75
Eyong Enoh 77
Siem De Jong 76
Theo Janssen 81
Rodney Sneijder 72
Christian Eriksen 80

Thulani Serero 74
Lorenzo Ebecilio 77
Kolbeinn Sigthorsson 76
Miralem Sulejmani 78
Derk Boerrigter 74

I may have shot a bit high. Should be 4 stars, 3½ with the players i haven't rated, they could be anywhere from 60 to 75.

Scott Bevan - 62



Michael Smith - 59

Byron Anthony - 61

Gary Sawyer - 60

Adam Virgo - 63



Chris Lines - 63

Mustapha Carayol - 61

Matthew Gill - 62

Joe Anyinsah - 61



Chris Zebroski - 64

Joe Kuffour - 62

Mutant123 wrote:Scott Bevan - 62



Michael Smith - 59

Byron Anthony - 61

Gary Sawyer - 60

Adam Virgo - 63



Chris Lines - 63

Mustapha Carayol - 61

Matthew Gill - 62

Joe Anyinsah - 61



Chris Zebroski - 64

Joe Kuffour - 62

Forgot Southway

I didn't do the full team. Couldn't be fucked.

Mutant123 wrote:I didn't do the full team. Couldn't be fucked.

I know, it is just I am good friends with him so felt like saying it

Reina 86

Doni 75

Johnson 81

Agger 82

Carragher 81

Skrtel 80

Aurelio 76

Kelly 79

Flanagan 72

Robinson 73

Kyrgiakos 75

Wilson 74

Gerrard 85

Poulsen 76

Cole 77

Adam 80

Aquilani 82

Henderson 78

Meireles 80

Lucas 83

Maxi 79

Spearing 73

Shelvey 75

Downing 82

Coady 72

N'Gog 76

Carroll 81

Suarez 85

Kuyt 82

Pacheco 73

I will just do Greek players, if that is cool.

Alexandros Tzorvas - 75

Vangelis Moras - 70

Avraam Papadopoulos - 78

Loukas Vyntra - 73

Sotirios Kyrgiakos - 77

Kyriakos Papadopoulos - 74

Sokratis Papastathopoulos - 80

Vasilis Torosidis - 81

Nikos Spyropoulos - 74

Pantelis Kafes - 76

Georgios Karagounis - 82

Kostas Katsouranis - 79/80

Alexandros Tziolis - 77

Georgios Samaras - 81

Ioannis Fetfatzidis - 75

Angelos Charisteas - 75

Theofanis Gekas - 79

Sotiris Ninis - 80 (I think he will do well, an update later could push him to 82)

Samaras will never be 81, FIFA put SPL players lower than they should be.

De Gea - 82
Lindegaard - 78

Evra - 83
Fabio - 78
Vidic - 87
Rio - 84
Smalling - 79
Jones - 78
Evans - 77
Rafael - 79

Nani - 85
Young - 83
Giggs - 81
Fletcher - 80
Cleverley - 78
Park - 80
Carrick - 81
Anderson 80
Valencia - 82

Rooney - 87
Berba - 84
Hernandez - 82
Welbeck - 78
Diouf - 76
Owen - 77
Macheda - 76

Was reading through from the start of this thread, trust crump to be the one to overrate the players first. Song 84, Wilshere 83, Sagna 84, Van Persie 87

I also wonder what Vermaelen desreves an 84 for. 2 seasons ago? Should be 80 max till he proves what he can do till January.

Same for Gerrard.

Samaras 81.

SBSP wrote:Samaras 81.

I know, 85.

Valdes - 82
Alves - 84
Pique - 85
Puyol - 85
Abidal - 83
Busquets - 82
Xavi - 89
Iniesta - 87
Messi - 92
Pedro - 84
Villa - 86

What about Al Ahly?