Who is better and who would you rather have ?
+10
ResurrectionRooney
The Zlatan
The Bat-Man
Thorri93
blackskar
fergiesrednose
Hitchy
dena
SBSP
Grenade
14 posters
Nicklas Bendtner or Andy Caroll ?
Poll
Who is better?
- [ 18 ]
[55%]
- [ 15 ]
- [45%]
Total Votes: 33
Grenade-
- Formerly known as : grenade187
Posts : 9113
Age : 43
SBSP-
- Posts : 50010
Bendtner.
dena-
- Posts : 18688
Age : 35
Location : only place to find base heads and hot women
I'd rather play with 10 men.
SBSP-
- Posts : 50010
dena wrote:I'd rather play with 10 men.
Guest- Guest
Carroll by a fucking mile. World Class potential.
dena-
- Posts : 18688
Age : 35
Location : only place to find base heads and hot women
This is one of those pot kettle black moments isnt it.
SBSP-
- Posts : 50010
Nope. I'm just a hater. You're a player hater.dena wrote:This is one of those pot kettle black moments isnt it.
SBSP-
- Posts : 50010
He's only a year younger.Jelavic18|RFC wrote:Carroll by a fucking mile. World Class potential.
Guest- Guest
SBSP wrote:He's only a year younger.Jelavic18|RFC wrote:Carroll by a fucking mile. World Class potential.
That is one of the stupidest quotes I have ever seen.
Because I am 15, I have more potential than lets say Thiago? Idiot.
SBSP-
- Posts : 50010
You're not exactly a professional footballer.Jelavic18|RFC wrote:SBSP wrote:He's only a year younger.Jelavic18|RFC wrote:Carroll by a fucking mile. World Class potential.
That is one of the stupidest quotes I have ever seen.
Because I am 15, I have more potential than lets say Thiago? Idiot.
Bendtner has a Champions League hat trick. Andy Carroll has never scored in Europe.
Guest- Guest
SBSP wrote:You're not exactly a professional footballer.Jelavic18|RFC wrote:SBSP wrote:He's only a year younger.Jelavic18|RFC wrote:Carroll by a fucking mile. World Class potential.
That is one of the stupidest quotes I have ever seen.
Because I am 15, I have more potential than lets say Thiago? Idiot.
Bendtner has a Champions League hat trick. Andy Carroll has never scored in Europe.
He has only played in 1 or 2 games.
Grenade-
- Formerly known as : grenade187
Posts : 9113
Age : 43
Jelavic18|RFC wrote:Carroll by a fucking mile. World Class potential.
Please elaborate.
SBSP-
- Posts : 50010
Cue the laugh and facepalm.grenade187 wrote:Jelavic18|RFC wrote:Carroll by a fucking mile. World Class potential.
Please elaborate.
Hitchy-
- Posts : 1556
Carroll at the moment is better, but I think people on here (and in general) heavily underrated Bendtner. Yes, he's a cocky cunt and hasn't achieved much, but he's big, strong, has good feet and is good in the air... the main thing that lets him down is that his finishing is erratic as fuck. I think if he lifted his work rate and sorted out his finishing then he'd be a top striker (better than Carroll)
fergiesrednose-
- Posts : 1332
Location : Republic of Manchester
carrol everyday of the week. Bendtner missed some sitters last season.
blackskar-
- Posts : 12479
Rather have Bendtner
Thorri93-
- Posts : 6
Age : 31
Location : Norway
Supports : Real Madrid
come on! carrol is better. he is superb in the air and and shoots better than bendtner. Bendtner has never been in any 1. XI. he is simply a back up.
The Bat-Man-
- Posts : 4668
Age : 30
Location : Kuwait
Supports : The Voyeur
Bendtner will come good, he'll be of similar stature of Dzeko when he gets older, amazing striker in a league like the Bundesliga bagging 20 goals a season.
Carroll's got a good left peg and he's good in the air, he'll be a good striker in the future in the Premier league, he'll get 15 goals a season with relative ease I would say.
As for who is better, let's see, Carroll is better in the air and is a better finisher, Bendtner is a better all-round football, he's better running with the ball and linking up and stuff, he's quite average in the air for someone his size and he is one determined fuck so he will keep improving.
Carroll's got a good left peg and he's good in the air, he'll be a good striker in the future in the Premier league, he'll get 15 goals a season with relative ease I would say.
As for who is better, let's see, Carroll is better in the air and is a better finisher, Bendtner is a better all-round football, he's better running with the ball and linking up and stuff, he's quite average in the air for someone his size and he is one determined fuck so he will keep improving.
blackskar-
- Posts : 12479
Thorri93 wrote:come on! carrol is better. he is superb in the air and and shoots better than bendtner. Bendtner has never been in any 1. XI. he is simply a back up.
Not his fault he has one of the best strikers in the world in RVP ahead of him.
The Bat-Man-
- Posts : 4668
Age : 30
Location : Kuwait
Supports : The Voyeur
blackskar wrote:Thorri93 wrote:come on! carrol is better. he is superb in the air and and shoots better than bendtner. Bendtner has never been in any 1. XI. he is simply a back up.
Not his fault he has one of the best strikers in the world in RVP ahead of him.
Stole the words right out of my mouth.
The Zlatan-
- Posts : 10347
I've said this before whilst trolling on a different forum 
But I would pick Bendtner. I think he has a lot more potential than Andy Carroll, but he still needs some work, he would have also cost about £25-20 million less.
But I would pick Bendtner. I think he has a lot more potential than Andy Carroll, but he still needs some work, he would have also cost about £25-20 million less.
ResurrectionRooney-
- Posts : 17681
Supports : United
They're about equal, Bendtner doesn't get a run in the side at Arsenal because he's behind van Persie, if Carroll was at Arsenal he'd be in the same situation though.
Kris-
- Posts : 842
Age : 32
Location : Surprisingly close to Lyngby stadium, Denmark
If Bendtner gets a manager, who'll give his cockiness a kick, and learn to finish, I think he has more potential. If that doesn't happen, I'd say Caroll
Guest- Guest
Carroll is a better finisher.
Bendtner is better technically.
Bendtner is better technically.
Sean-
- Posts : 33857
Age : 30
Tbf Bendtner would be brilliant at a team like Everton.
Drake-
- Posts : 16006
Age : 29
I would rather have Carroll yes Bendtner is good but his ego gets the better of him.
JonjoShelvey-
- Formerly known as : Snoopy
Posts : 2587
Supports : Liverpool Football Club.
At the moment i'd have Carroll as he is showing really good potential like scoring 17 goals in the BPL and netting for England but I think Bendtner has the potential to be a good striker but I think he should drop his ego.
Guest- Guest
Bendtner hasn't had the opportunity to show his talent.
Next season if he goes on loan to Everton, he will score 20 goals if not more.
Next season if he goes on loan to Everton, he will score 20 goals if not more.
Last edited by polska. on Tue Jul 19, 2011 2:39 am; edited 1 time in total
JonjoShelvey-
- Formerly known as : Snoopy
Posts : 2587
Supports : Liverpool Football Club.
polska. wrote:Bendtner hasn't had the opportunity to show his talent.
Next season if he goes on loan to Everton, he will score 20 goals.
Indeed.
Guest- Guest
this shold not even be a question
bentner is by far better then carroll, another player liverpool should of bought instead of carroll he would of been much cheap also
bentner is by far better then carroll, another player liverpool should of bought instead of carroll he would of been much cheap also
