One Club Players XI

Rei Andros wrote:So putting in the players you guys added.

Rogerio Ceni; Neville,Carragher,Terry,Maldini; Giggs; Scholes,Xavi; Le Tissier; Totti, Del Piero

Scholes will have the tackling responsibility in midfield.

Sir Tom Finney should be in it.

That's what I said on the first page. You have to put a limit on it, or else it will be easy to make the team full of players from history. I tried to be as current at possible Pilkz.

This might help. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_one-club_men

As I said before Rei, Terry played while on loan at another club so he doesn't count.

ResurrectionRooney wrote:

arsenalap11 wrote:

ResurrectionRooney wrote:Alright dick heads, I made a mistake, I've admitted to it. I know it's an incredibly rare occurrence, a bit like a new millennium coming around, but you don't need to keep pointing it out.

Maybe look at the post times and you'll see it was all posted at the same time dick head

Do you guys not get that thing where it says 'A New post has been made, please review your post' or whatever if someone posts in between you writing your reply and clicking submit?

No, I didn't get that. Normally I do but not in this case.

Rei Andros wrote:That's what I said on the first page. You have to put a limit on it, or else it will be easy to make the team full of players from history. I tried to be as current at possible Pilkz.

Ok

"Tom Finney would have been great in any team, in any match and in any age ... even if he had been wearing an overcoat." (Bill Shankly)
Shankly was also once asked about how a top star of the day compared to Finney: "Aye, he's as good as Tommy – but then Tommy's nearly 60 now."[11]
"Tom Finney should claim income tax relief ... for his 10 dependents." (Satirical observation on the weakness of the Preston team in his absence)
"If all the brains in the game sat in committee to design the perfect player, they would come up with a reincarnation of Tom Finney." (Anonymous newspaper feature)

Rei Andros wrote:So putting in the players you guys added.

Rogerio Ceni; Neville,Carragher,Terry,Maldini; Giggs; Scholes,Xavi; Le Tissier; Totti, Del Piero

Scholes will have the tackling responsibility in midfield.

Sounds like a plan.

coolhead33 wrote:This might help. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_one-club_men

As I said before Rei, Terry played while on loan at another club so he doesn't count.

Oh, I didn't see that post.

Rei Andros wrote:So putting in the players you guys added.

Rogerio Ceni; Neville,Carragher,Terry,Maldini; Giggs; Scholes,Xavi; Le Tissier; Totti, Del Piero

Scholes will have the tackling responsibility in midfield.

Carragher over Tony Adams?

Franco Baresi

Rei Andros wrote:So putting in the players you guys added.

Rogerio Ceni; Neville,Carragher,Terry,Maldini; Giggs; Scholes,Xavi; Le Tissier; Totti, Del Piero

Scholes will have the tackling responsibility in midfield.

Del Piero is a Juve legend, but he played for Padova before he went to Juve.

How many of them players are Sirs i rest my case

Pilkz wrote:How many of them players are Sirs i rest my case

But being a sir, does not always mean they were great at Football.

Mal wrote:Carragher over Tony Adams?

Gegilworld93 wrote:Del Piero is a Juve legend, but he played for Padova before he went to Juve.

Wasn't it only as a youth player?

Pilkz wrote:How many of them players are Sirs i rest my case

Alex Ferguson is a Sir, but he's still in Bob Paisley's shadow.

Liverpool fc 4 ever wrote:

Pilkz wrote:How many of them players are Sirs i rest my case

But being a sir, does not always mean they were great at Football.

Sir Tom Finney is one of the best players England has had.

Ledley King should be involved somewhere.

Pilkz wrote:

Liverpool fc 4 ever wrote:

Pilkz wrote:How many of them players are Sirs i rest my case

But being a sir, does not always mean they were great at Football.

Sir Tom Finney is one of the best players England has had.

Defenders were shit back then.

If only Vítor Baía didn't spend those two years at Barça , would be a dead cert.

Dan wrote:

Pilkz wrote:How many of them players are Sirs i rest my case

Alex Ferguson is a Sir, but he's still in Bob Paisley's shadow.

Paisley is one of the ultimate one club men.

From 1939-1954 as a player, 1954 to 1974 he worked for Liverpool. 1974-83 as manager and then worked at Liverpool from 85 to 92.

Dan wrote:

Pilkz wrote:

Liverpool fc 4 ever wrote:

Pilkz wrote:How many of them players are Sirs i rest my case

But being a sir, does not always mean they were great at Football.

Sir Tom Finney is one of the best players England has had.

Defenders were shit back then.

Right..

Pilkz wrote:

Dan wrote:

Pilkz wrote:

Liverpool fc 4 ever wrote:

Pilkz wrote:How many of them players are Sirs i rest my case

But being a sir, does not always mean they were great at Football.

Sir Tom Finney is one of the best players England has had.

Defenders were shit back then.

Right..

left and centre.

If we're including youth academy's and such didn't Giggs play for Man City?

easley91 wrote:Ledley King should be involved somewhere.

He can't play he is injured.

Liverpool fc 4 ever wrote:

easley91 wrote:Ledley King should be involved somewhere.

He can't play he is injured.

I thought the rule was one club players, that's why Ledley should be in. And King isn't injured now, he played the last two full games of the season and with pre-season he'll be ready for next year.

GK01 wrote:If we're including youth academy's and such didn't Giggs play for Man City?

Yes he did 83-85.

San Iker of course

easley91 wrote:

Liverpool fc 4 ever wrote:

easley91 wrote:Ledley King should be involved somewhere.

He can't play he is injured.

I thought the rule was one club players, that's why Ledley should be in. And King isn't injured now, he played the last two full games of the season and with pre-season he'll be ready for next year.

Sorry i was only joking. Great player King, just a shame injuries and not being able to train properly have stopped him playing as often.

Liverpool fc 4 ever wrote:

easley91 wrote:Ledley King should be involved somewhere.

He can't play he is injured.

Józef Kałuża and Gerard Cieślik should be included in the all-timers.

Fucking amazing both of them were apparently. Remember back then pre-WWII and right after it Polish League/club football was no worse than Spanish/Italian/English.