So you think Hodgson is tactically a better manager than Dalglish then?
+10
luke.
Jordi
ResurrectionRooney
Mustangt125
Childish Logic
Jamie
dena
SBSP
Sean
Theo Filippo
14 posters
Hodgson or Dalglish
Poll
Hodgson or Dalglish?
- [ 11 ]
[61%]
- [ 7 ]
- [39%]
Total Votes: 18
Poll closed
Poll closed
Guest- Guest
Mal wrote:luke. wrote:How does Dalglish holding a trophy prove he's better tactically?
Very true.
This is about who is the better manager tactically not the most successful.
Not as if they are generally linked.
luke.-
- Posts : 32310
Age : 30
Location : Belfast
Scott wrote:So you think Hodgson is tactically a better manager than Dalglish then?
Did I say that?
A picture of Dalglish holding a premier league trophy proves very little about how good tactically he is.
Theo Filippo-
- Formerly known as : Filippo Inzaghi
Posts : 21636
Age : 30
Cant tell if your just failing at sarcasm againEternal Witcher wrote:Filippo Inzaghi wrote:Why would i trust you when i made itNZG wrote:Trust me it's notFilippo Inzaghi wrote:I can assure you all this is a serious thread
Either way it's not. Mainly because you have proved in the past that you are incapable of displaying a constructive opinion.
Anyway what is your opinion on the matter? I have yet to see you display anything constructive
Guest- Guest
luke. wrote:Scott wrote:So you think Hodgson is tactically a better manager than Dalglish then?
Did I say that?
A picture of Dalglish holding a premier league trophy proves very little about how good tactically he is.
So it takes no/little tactical knowledge at all to win the Premier League?
Guest- Guest
Scott wrote:luke. wrote:Scott wrote:So you think Hodgson is tactically a better manager than Dalglish then?
Did I say that?
A picture of Dalglish holding a premier league trophy proves very little about how good tactically he is.
So it takes no/little tactical knowledge at all to win the Premier League?
and a few million pounds
Guest- Guest
Dalglish is a genius tactically. That's why he could get a team of nobodies (Lucas, Spearing, Robinson, Flanagan, who are they?) to draw at the Emirates against a world class Arsenal midfield.
Guest- Guest
Filippo Inzaghi wrote:Cant tell if your just failing at sarcasm againEternal Witcher wrote:Filippo Inzaghi wrote:Why would i trust you when i made itNZG wrote:Trust me it's notFilippo Inzaghi wrote:I can assure you all this is a serious thread
Either way it's not. Mainly because you have proved in the past that you are incapable of displaying a constructive opinion.
Anyway what is your opinion on the matter? I have yet to see you display anything constructive
What has this got to do with sarcasm? And I don't fail, just some mugs say I do and you naturally join in.
This thread isn't worthy of constructive opinions now. Way to set the stage.
Theo Filippo-
- Formerly known as : Filippo Inzaghi
Posts : 21636
Age : 30
So you are trying to ruin a good thread? I see many other members have been on topic i suppose thats too hard for youEternal Witcher wrote:Filippo Inzaghi wrote:Cant tell if your just failing at sarcasm againEternal Witcher wrote:Filippo Inzaghi wrote:Why would i trust you when i made itNZG wrote:
Trust me it's not
Either way it's not. Mainly because you have proved in the past that you are incapable of displaying a constructive opinion.
Anyway what is your opinion on the matter? I have yet to see you display anything constructive
What has this got to do with sarcasm? And I don't fail, just some mugs say I do and you naturally join in.
This thread isn't worthy of constructive opinions now. Way to set the stage.
blackskar-
- Posts : 12479
If you are not going to contribute to the actual thread topic then don't post. I'm gonna start handing out warnings to people who don't now.
Guest- Guest
They are both tactically better than Wenger though.
Grenade-
- Formerly known as : grenade187
Posts : 9113
Age : 43
Hodgson got a draw against Arsenal aswell with an inferior side.
Theo Filippo-
- Formerly known as : Filippo Inzaghi
Posts : 21636
Age : 30
So could Di Matteo, Hughton and RedknappScott wrote:Dalglish is a genius tactically. That's why he could get a team of nobodies (Lucas, Spearing, Robinson, Flanagan, who are they?) to draw at the Emirates against a world class Arsenal midfield.
Guest- Guest
Filippo Inzaghi wrote:So could Di Matteo, Hughton and RedknappScott wrote:Dalglish is a genius tactically. That's why he could get a team of nobodies (Lucas, Spearing, Robinson, Flanagan, who are they?) to draw at the Emirates against a world class Arsenal midfield.
Must mean Wenger is pathetic tactically.
Theo Filippo-
- Formerly known as : Filippo Inzaghi
Posts : 21636
Age : 30
He doesn't do tactics so your rightScott wrote:Filippo Inzaghi wrote:So could Di Matteo, Hughton and RedknappScott wrote:Dalglish is a genius tactically. That's why he could get a team of nobodies (Lucas, Spearing, Robinson, Flanagan, who are they?) to draw at the Emirates against a world class Arsenal midfield.
Must mean Wenger is pathetic tactically.
Guest- Guest
i think dalglish also benefit from studying and learning under hodgson in his time in liverpool. hodgson would of gived some tips to dalglish and he would of learnt a few tactics in his time but dalglish still has long time to learn a few things but its only normal
luke.-
- Posts : 32310
Age : 30
Location : Belfast
Scott wrote:luke. wrote:Scott wrote:So you think Hodgson is tactically a better manager than Dalglish then?
Did I say that?
A picture of Dalglish holding a premier league trophy proves very little about how good tactically he is.
So it takes no/little tactical knowledge at all to win the Premier League?
Again, didn't say that. But it doesn't prove a manager is a better tactician then another. Grant almost won the UCL, is he a great tactician? No.
Scott wrote:Dalglish is a genius tactically. That's why he could get a team of nobodies (Lucas, Spearing, Robinson, Flanagan, who are they?) to draw at the Emirates against a world class Arsenal midfield.
Seriously, why do keep fucking banging out about drawing against Arsenal? It's making you look small time and it's getting boring. And I wouldn't put 'nobodies' playing well as tactical, it's more of a motivational thing.
Guest- Guest
Filippo Inzaghi wrote:He doesn't do tactics so your rightScott wrote:Filippo Inzaghi wrote:So could Di Matteo, Hughton and RedknappScott wrote:Dalglish is a genius tactically. That's why he could get a team of nobodies (Lucas, Spearing, Robinson, Flanagan, who are they?) to draw at the Emirates against a world class Arsenal midfield.
Must mean Wenger is pathetic tactically.
So what does he do then?
Sits on the bench and when things go wrong start kicking bottles?
Guest- Guest
blackskar wrote:If you are not going to contribute to the actual thread topic then don't post. I'm gonna start handing out warnings to people who don't now.
when it's clearly a baiting thread.
Fuck that, I'll leave this one.
Theo Filippo-
- Formerly known as : Filippo Inzaghi
Posts : 21636
Age : 30
He only plays to the teams strengths. He doesn't change his team to stop opposition players etcMr Leiva wrote:Filippo Inzaghi wrote:He doesn't do tactics so your rightScott wrote:Filippo Inzaghi wrote:So could Di Matteo, Hughton and RedknappScott wrote:Dalglish is a genius tactically. That's why he could get a team of nobodies (Lucas, Spearing, Robinson, Flanagan, who are they?) to draw at the Emirates against a world class Arsenal midfield.
Must mean Wenger is pathetic tactically.
So what does he do then?
Sits on the bench and when things go wrong start kicking bottles?
The Bat-Man-
- Posts : 4668
Age : 30
Location : Kuwait
Supports : The Voyeur
Scott wrote:They are both tactically better than Wenger though.
Wenger's better at uncovering potential world class players and fulfilling their potential.
What Wenger did at Arsenal, taking us from tenth to top in less than a year and turning us into an inconsistent side to a mainstay in European football is astonishing.
So Wenger>Dalglish&Hodgson.
Wenger was never a tactical manager, he just develops the players he gets into world beaters and unleashes them onto the league.
Plus financially Wenger>>>>>>>>>>>>>Dalglish&Hodgson
blackskar-
- Posts : 12479
Eternal Witcher wrote:blackskar wrote:If you are not going to contribute to the actual thread topic then don't post. I'm gonna start handing out warnings to people who don't now.
when it's clearly a baiting thread.
Fuck that, I'll leave this one.
In your opinion. Had you not come in crying about it being baiting and that then it could have been a good thread.
luke.-
- Posts : 32310
Age : 30
Location : Belfast
Scott wrote:Luke
You could at least reply and have a proper discussion and try prove me wrong...
Guest- Guest
The Bat-Man wrote:Scott wrote:They are both tactically better than Wenger though.
Wenger's better at uncovering potential world class players and fulfilling their potential.
What Wenger did at Arsenal, taking us from tenth to top in less than a year and turning us into an inconsistent side to a mainstay in European football is astonishing.
So Wenger>Dalglish&Hodgson.
Wenger was never a tactical manager, he just develops the players he gets into world beaters and unleashes them onto the league.
Plus financially Wenger>>>>>>>>>>>>>Dalglish&Hodgson
Guest- Guest
Filippo Inzaghi wrote:He only plays to the teams strengths. He doesn't change his team to stop opposition players etcMr Leiva wrote:Filippo Inzaghi wrote:He doesn't do tactics so your rightScott wrote:Filippo Inzaghi wrote:So could Di Matteo, Hughton and Redknapp
Must mean Wenger is pathetic tactically.
So what does he do then?
Sits on the bench and when things go wrong start kicking bottles?
Playing to your strengths is adjusting your team to have an advantage off your opposition.
blackskar-
- Posts : 12479
Scott wrote:The Bat-Man wrote:Scott wrote:They are both tactically better than Wenger though.
Wenger's better at uncovering potential world class players and fulfilling their potential.
What Wenger did at Arsenal, taking us from tenth to top in less than a year and turning us into an inconsistent side to a mainstay in European football is astonishing.
So Wenger>Dalglish&Hodgson.
Wenger was never a tactical manager, he just develops the players he gets into world beaters and unleashes them onto the league.
Plus financially Wenger>>>>>>>>>>>>>Dalglish&Hodgson
You do realise baiting is a warnable offence right?
Guest- Guest
luke. wrote:Scott wrote:
You could at least reply and have a proper discussion and try prove me wrong...
It wasn't worthy of a response because you clearly got the wrong idea. My post about Liverpool's nobodies and Arsenal world class midfield was not a serious post, it's a running joke amongst Liverpool fans. You freaked out about it as if I was being serious. Jesus. Keep your hair on.
No actually, shave it off. SHAVE IT ALL OFF. Or dye it.
Guest- Guest
blackskar wrote:Scott wrote:The Bat-Man wrote:Scott wrote:They are both tactically better than Wenger though.
Wenger's better at uncovering potential world class players and fulfilling their potential.
What Wenger did at Arsenal, taking us from tenth to top in less than a year and turning us into an inconsistent side to a mainstay in European football is astonishing.
So Wenger>Dalglish&Hodgson.
Wenger was never a tactical manager, he just develops the players he gets into world beaters and unleashes them onto the league.
Plus financially Wenger>>>>>>>>>>>>>Dalglish&Hodgson
You do realise baiting is a warnable offence right?
Tell that to the OP of this thread.
