Gibson, Mceachran or Shelvey?

Mr Leiva wrote:

ZlatanFabregas wrote:Wilshere

What?

ZlatanFabregas wrote:

Mr Leiva wrote:

ZlatanFabregas wrote:Wilshere

What?

Get out.

1. Gibson - Proven talent, won the Premier League, dominated European Cup Quarter Final and Semi Final 2nd Legs. Better striker of the ball than any other midfielder in the Premier League, and his final ball is excellent
2. Wilshere - Had a good game against Barcelona, been a reasonable player for Arsenal this season
3. McEachran - Never achieved anything except a stupid pose with a ball where it looks like he is controlling it magically. Chelsea have been crying out for a creative player and he hasn't been able to get into the team, says it all really.
4. Shelvey - Shit

None of these are fit to clean wilshere's boots.

Eternal Witcher wrote:

ZlatanFabregas wrote:

Mr Leiva wrote:

ZlatanFabregas wrote:Wilshere

What?

Get out.

Remember, no-one takes the bait.

Eternal Witcher wrote:Remember, no-one takes the bait.

Is it baiting if it's true?

ZlatanFabregas wrote:

Eternal Witcher wrote:

ZlatanFabregas wrote:

Mr Leiva wrote:

ZlatanFabregas wrote:Wilshere

What?

Get out.

It's bait if you disagree.

Mr Leiva wrote:

To be fair, that is a pretty appealing worm.

ZlatanFabregas wrote:

Eternal Witcher wrote:Remember, no-one takes the bait.

Is it baiting if it's true?

Well if such a rare occurrence comes along, I'll answer that question.

Gibson young lol.

@ this thread.

Cameron. wrote: @ this thread.

Filippo Inzaghi wrote:

Cameron. wrote: @ this thread.

Generally means the thread is shite.

Eternal Witcher wrote:

Filippo Inzaghi wrote:

Cameron. wrote: @ this thread.

Generally means the thread is shite.

Shite because certain deluded posters were posting? Or because my OP contains a fair comparison

Filippo Inzaghi wrote:

Eternal Witcher wrote:

Filippo Inzaghi wrote:

Cameron. wrote: @ this thread.

Generally means the thread is shite.

Shite because certain deluded posters were posting? Or because my OP contains a fair comparison

I'm sure you will draw a fair conclusion.

ResurrectionRooney wrote:1. Gibson - Proven talent, won the Premier League, dominated European Cup Quarter Final and Semi Final 2nd Legs. Better striker of the ball than any other midfielder in the Premier League, and his final ball is excellent
2. Wilshere - Had a good game against Barcelona, been a reasonable player for Arsenal this season
3. Shelvey - Shit

Wilshere isn't even in the poll..

Coatsy wrote:Shelvey is clearly the best. He's already better than Wilshere.

Shelvey.

Eternal Witcher wrote:Remember, no-one takes the bait.

Good thing you warned me. I was about to respond.

Gegilworld93 wrote:

Coatsy wrote:Shelvey is clearly the best. He's already better than Wilshere.

That's so ridiculous it isn't even funny anymore.

Well, Wilshere is obviously the best, but he's not in the poll.

Gibson, dude has a shot and a big ass head, that's about it.

Shelvey and Mceachran, eh... tough. Did see Josh play very well in that game vs. Newcastle in the LC, Shelvey has shown some flashes but only as a sub, I'm leaning toward the Chelsea kid but would love to see both get more playing time.

Gibson is very underrated, he is a decent enough midfielder, scores some long shots here and there, has experience on a winning team and in big games. Always liked him tbh think Man U fans give him too much shit.

Lucas

SBSP wrote:

Eternal Witcher wrote:Remember, no-one takes the bait.

Good thing you warned me. I was about to respond.

Nice sarcasm but I wasn't referring to you lot, just the liverpool fans. There's an ignore RR policy in place.

gibson is a scrub, on top of the fact hes like 4 or 5 years older than the other 2

shelvey is pretty good, but hes not in the same class as mceachran whos even younger than him. cant compare them easily enough because both only play bit parts at their clubs here and there but you can tell just from watching mceachran on the ball that hes simply better, his technique, vision and just downright skill is higher than shelveys which doesnt mean jonjo is bad, just not as good as mceachran. easier way to determine whos better i guess is looking at the fact that mceachran and shelvey were teammates for a while in the england u19 side, but then mceachran became way to good for that level and moved up to the u21s where hes already one of the best players there and probably wont be there for long. whereas shelvey is still with the u19

Is GCU Mauro? .......

Eww no

Have any of the Liverpool supporters actually voted against one of their players in any of these polls?