Valencia vs Nani

Who would you rather have in your team?

Man United fans have to pick as if they could only have one. No smartarse comments like "but we have both lolololol"

But they have both

I'd rather have Valencia. Strong, fast, cross is amazing.

Valencia. Unsung hero.

Dunno. Nani is just class tbh, Valencia probably isn't as good with what Fine Shagger would call flair ( ), but he's probably just as affective- in terms of assists as well. And he's been brilliant since he came back, and he works so much harder than Nani.

In big games, I'd go with Valencia.

They're both stronger on the right, Nani can cover the left as well.

In my opinion Nani is the better player but Valencia is not far off, his wing play is amazing.

Nani has actually lost a bit of form since being taken out by Carragher (not saying it's linked), and Valencia coming back who moved out to the right, and Nani isn't as good on the left.

Plus Valencia does a better defensive job.

I think Nani is the better individual player, but if I had to choose one I might pick Valencia. Better defensively, more consistent (in terms of wing play to me), he's just effective and will get the job done. Nani will give you the the brilliant moments though, and this year his play has been out of control, ugh but I dunno.

Yeah, since Carragher tried to end Nani's career he's been nowhere near as good. Valencia on the other hand has been superb since returning from his injury. Really difficult to say either way, it depends on the opponent I suppose.

I would pick Valencia for our team, his crosses for Carroll would be ideal.

Me personally? Valencia.

Who's the better player? Nani.

ResurrectionRooney wrote:Yeah, since Carragher tried to end Nani's career he's been nowhere near as good. Valencia on the other hand has been superb since returning from his injury. Really difficult to say either way, it depends on the opponent I suppose.

Give it a rest.

_________________________

I prefer Valencia. Plus he seems the non cunt type.

Hard one.

Nani has more flair and he is more of an attacking threat in front of goal. Although, Valencia is strong and has a brilliant cross on him. Also he defends better which, unlike Nani.

Depends on the opponents and formation.

..This one's tough.
I'm going for Valencia because he isn't selfish...I don't know. Really tough. I love them both, Valencia just edges it for me

Do I get a gold star for making a really good player comparison thread? Most people find it difficult to pick one.

Valencia, Since he has been fully fit United have been firing and Rooney has been at his best.

Scott wrote:Do I get a gold star for making a really good player comparison thread? Most people find it difficult to pick one.

Blue peter badge.

Nani.

Jelavic18|RFC wrote:Nani.

Any particular reason?

If only one could stay at United I would pick Valencia. He is an absolute beast