Player of the season?

We've done team of the season so we'll now do player of the season.

These are the favourites to be nominees...



Twelve options. I do not agree with Adam being there at all.

Vidic.

My top 3 would be Vidic Nani and Nasri.

Where is Andy Carroll?

Scott wrote:Where is Andy Carroll?

Biased. He's a favourite to be shortlisted for young player of the year which I'm doing after.

Mal wrote:

Scott wrote:Where is Andy Carroll?

Biased. He's a favourite to be shortlisted for young player of the year which I'm doing after.

I think he has been immense for Newcastle. Wilshere is obviously going to win that one though, surely?

What about the likes of David Silva?

Scott wrote:

Mal wrote:

Scott wrote:Where is Andy Carroll?

Biased. He's a favourite to be shortlisted for young player of the year which I'm doing after.

I think he has been immense for Newcastle. Wilhsere is obviously going to win that one though, surely?

What about the likes of David Silva and Van Der Vaart?

Van Der Vaart is there. I said these are the favourites to be shortlisted for player of the year. They're not my choice. Stop being so fucking difficult. Kevin Nolan was better for Newcastle than Carroll anyway.

Nani, unfortunately.

Kevin Nolan should be on there.

He is.

I've been sitting here now thinking, and I can't really choose between Vidic and Nani even though I said Vidic.

Nasri has been good but it feels like he's died down a lot, and he has hardly got any assists in the league.

Mal wrote:He is.

I know, as he should be.

kyro7 wrote:I've been sitting here now thinking, and I can't really choose between Vidic and Nani even though I said Vidic.

Nasri has been good but it feels like he's died down a lot, and he has hardly got any assists in the league.

Nasri > Nani

Scott wrote:

kyro7 wrote:I've been sitting here now thinking, and I can't really choose between Vidic and Nani even though I said Vidic.

Nasri has been good but it feels like he's died down a lot, and he has hardly got any assists in the league.

Nasri > Nani

Yeah but I think you're a total and utter shitecunt that will say anything to make a United player look worse than he is, so I don't give a flying fuck what you say about any of our players.

kyro7 wrote:

Scott wrote:

kyro7 wrote:I've been sitting here now thinking, and I can't really choose between Vidic and Nani even though I said Vidic.

Nasri has been good but it feels like he's died down a lot, and he has hardly got any assists in the league.

Nasri > Nani

Yeah but I think you're a total and utter shitecunt that will say anything to make a United player look worse than he is, so I don't give a flying fuck what you say about any of our players.

So how come I think Vidic > Skrtel?

Scott wrote:

kyro7 wrote:

Scott wrote:

kyro7 wrote:I've been sitting here now thinking, and I can't really choose between Vidic and Nani even though I said Vidic.

Nasri has been good but it feels like he's died down a lot, and he has hardly got any assists in the league.

Nasri > Nani

Yeah but I think you're a total and utter shitecunt that will say anything to make a United player look worse than he is, so I don't give a flying fuck what you say about any of our players.

So how come I think Vidic > Skrtel?

Because Vidic is SOOOO FARRRR better than Skrtel that it would be quite ridiculous to say Skrtel > Vidic, Nasri and Nani are both top players who have both had good seasons, but even if Nani had a slightly better season you'd say Nasri because you hate Nani.

Okay, I think Park > Kuyt.

Well?

Scott wrote:Okay, I think Park > Kuyt.

Well?

Kuyt is shit.

Yeah I know, 3-1. ohh ahh woo.

Alright, I see you're playing hardball.

I think Berbatov > Suarez and Carroll put together.

Your move.

Nasri

Scott wrote:Alright, I see you're playing hardball.

I think Berbatov > Suarez and Carroll put together.

Your move.

No, no you do not.

Scott wrote:Okay, I think Park > Kuyt.

Well?

Really? Or taking the piss?

If Vidic is included then Cahill should be too.

Not even being bias either. Stupid really, but yeah whatever. From that list it's either Tevez or Nasri.

Evra > Johnson

Scotty, you full of shiiiiit..

Marvin wrote:If Vidic is included then Cahill should be too.

Not even being bias either. Stupid really, but yeah whatever. From that list it's either Tevez or Nasri.

I was thinking of the last player who's favourite to be shortlisted and you reminded me. Not Cahill though.

Nasri and Nani both have 9 goals in the league this season, Nasri has 2 or 3 penalties right?

Assists, Nani has 16 in the league, and Nasri has 1 assist in the league.

Kuyt > Park

No discussion necessary, this is a fact.

Marvin wrote:If Vidic is included then Cahill should be too.

Not even being bias either. Stupid really, but yeah whatever. From that list it's either Tevez or Nasri.

Not really, considering Vidic has been the best CB in the league.

kyro7 wrote:Nasri and Nani both have 9 goals in the league this season, Nasri has 2 or 3 penalties right?

Assists, Nani has 16 in the league, and Nasri hss 1 assist in the league.

Nani is a cheat and a cry baby though, so Nasri automatically > Nani.

@ Dan. My girl > your girl.

Scott wrote:

kyro7 wrote:Nasri and Nani both have 9 goals in the league this season, Nasri has 2 or 3 penalties right?

Assists, Nani has 16 in the league, and Nasri hss 1 assist in the league.

Nani is a cheat and a cry baby though, so Nasri automatically > Nani.

That's really the point I've been making..