Reina vs Cech vs Van Der Sar

No, i won it last year, i just gave it to Cech

luke. wrote:Cech hasn't been good for 2 years? That's why he won the golden glove last year then

Cech's a shit out now, his performance on Sunday was piss poor

Practically turned his back on the ball for Raul's goal, and he had a right fuck up with Ivanovic. He's too scared to come for crosses, and command his area now, no where near what he was.

Danny wrote:

luke. wrote:Cech hasn't been good for 2 years? That's why he won the golden glove last year then

Cech's a shit out now, his performance on Sunday was piss poor

Practically turned his back on the ball for Raul's goal, and he had a right fuck up with Ivanovic. He's too scared to come for crosses, and command his area now, no where near what he was.

What a poor reason, Vds dropped the ball v West Brom and cost us a win.

kyro7 wrote:

Danny wrote:

luke. wrote:Cech hasn't been good for 2 years? That's why he won the golden glove last year then

Cech's a shit out now, his performance on Sunday was piss poor

Practically turned his back on the ball for Raul's goal, and he had a right fuck up with Ivanovic. He's too scared to come for crosses, and command his area now, no where near what he was.

What a poor reason, Vds dropped the ball v West Brom and cost us a win.

Only mistake he's made in a United shirt.

I know but you only come up with one game.. Cech is still class.

Yeah I agree Cech is still good. Not as good as he was, but still top 5 in the prem easily.

kyro7 wrote:I know but you only come up with one game.. Cech is still class.

There's plenty of other examples of where he's done similar things, mistakes that he wouldn't have made before his head injury.

He's still class yeah, he's no where near what he was 3-4 years ago though.

But you said "Cech's a shit now".

When really he's not shit, he's just not as good as he was.

Reina has made at least 3 calamitous errors this season. Van Der Sar ha smade one.

kyro7 wrote:But you said "Cech's a shit now".

When really he's not shit, he's just not as good as he was.

I called him a shit out.

LiamB_30 wrote:Reina has made at least 3 calamitous errors this season. Van Der Sar ha smade one.

Can only remember Reina's one against Arsenal for Liverpool. Obviously his one for Spain v Argentina as well..

I remember one in the Europa League, aswell as another coupld of dodgy league moments with him fumbling the ball.

Yep, a dodgy moment = "calamitous error"?

Liverpool fans have deluded you

You're next Liam

His one in the Europa League where he totally fucked up and it cost a goal, went through his legs I think.

LiamB_30 wrote:Liverpool fans have deluded you

You're just an idiot, sorry.

Brilliant, a keeper comparison thread.

First of all, on his day, Lee Camp matches all of these 3. Reina not so much, but he is a different class.

Sometimes though, Camp is better than VDS and Cech. Cech is very unfortunate imo. Had he not received that head injury, he'd still be up there with the likes of Casillas and Buffon. But now, he is a completely different player. Lee Camp can pull off saves Cech can only dream of at times. Therefore, I declare Camp and Cech as equal.

Onto VDS. Back in his day, he was quality, but now he's about 45 isn't he? He's catching up with Moscow in years. Therefore, I declare Camp as being better as he has better reflexes, reactions and agility.


Reina > Camp = Cech > Van der Sar

Van Der Sar is 40 and the years haven't caught up with him at all, I honestly don't know what the fuck you're going on about.

Shut the fuck up about Lee Camp, he's shit, can't even play for Northern Ireland.

Cech is still a great keeper, doesn't have the confidence to come for crosses etc. anymore though

kyro7 wrote:Van Der Sar is 40 and the years haven't caught up with him at all, I honestly don't know what the fuck you're going on about.

Exactly, fuck his retirement, could donanother season at least, still world class.

That's like saying Giggs is shite because he's 37

He needs to take his hat off tbh, its a sign of weakness.

forestfcfan wrote:
Reina > Camp = Cech > Van der Sar

That's a joke, surely?

forestfcfan wrote:Brilliant, a keeper comparison thread.

First of all, on his day, Lee Camp matches all of these 3. Reina not so much, but he is a different class.

Sometimes though, Camp is better than VDS and Cech. Cech is very unfortunate imo. Had he not received that head injury, he'd still be up there with the likes of Casillas and Buffon. But now, he is a completely different player. Lee Camp can pull off saves Cech can only dream of at times. Therefore, I declare Camp and Cech as equal.

Onto VDS. Back in his day, he was quality, but now he's about 45 isn't he? He's catching up with Moscow in years. Therefore, I declare Camp as being better as he has better reflexes, reactions and agility.


Reina > Camp = Cech > Van der Sar

You can't really compare Lee Camp to the likes of Reina, Cech and Van Der Sar can you? He dosen't even make any top flight exp.

Cam wrote:You're next Liam

Unfortunately I am invulnerable as I have seen the techniques scosuers use to delude people, themselves included.

I will not buy it. Unfortunately some have. I am sure Danny never watches Reina but he takes Liverpool fans' words for it.

Liam = Rolo when hes high.

Say what you wish, but Lee Camp is class. He is better than McGugan and more consistent, so would you please have a bit of love for Lee Camp. Thankyou

LiamB_30 wrote:

Cam wrote:You're next Liam

Unfortunately I am invulnerable as I have seen the techniques scosuers use to delude people, themselves included.

I will not buy it. Unfortunately some have. I am sure Danny never watches Reina but he takes Liverpool fans' words for it.

I watch most Liverpool games- at least on MOTD.

Watched the game yesterday with 3 mates, all Liverpool fans, so I think you should shut the fuck up tbh

Deary me, forest decides to be mature for once and everyone tells him to shut up

Tom wrote:Deary me, forest decides to be mature for once and everyone tells him to shut up

Probably because what he said was absolute shite.