Pepe Reina v Petr Cech

Interesting debate. I have always believed that Reina was the best keeper in the league, but I read something last week, where it proved by stats, that Cech has been the Premier League's best ever keeper, with Reina in 2nd.


What do the people of the Playmaker think?

Cech

Reina is just a shit keeper hyped up by idiotic deluded scousers imo.

Cech.

Cech

People will obviously point to Cech's injury etc. but Cech has been brilliant this season, without him we'd not be in the top 4.

Mate, we've had this debate so many times.


I believe I made a thread actually.


http://www.the-playmaker.com/t3020-reina-vs-cech-vs-van-der-sar

I voted Reina.

Cech, Reina just looks better with his dives!

Reina.

Seriously though: Reina and it's not even a hard choice.

Picked Reina.

Used to think Cech was the best in the world and was really jealous Chelsea had him, but ever since his injury, he just doesn't seem to be the same.

Reina has more to his game and is one of the best, if not the best goalkeeper at starting off counter-attacking movements.

Kaspar's Dad shouldn't have been in our PL Team ahead of these 2 imo

Hmmm, one plays for one of the best teams in England and is a first choice international while the other is playing for a mid table team, third choice for his country and a Barcelona reject on top of that.

Clearly Cech.

Reina is the best goalkeeper in the PL.

Easily Reina. Cech was good last season but he's gotten a tad bit inconsistant after his head injury, before that i think he was arguably the best GK in the world.

No i'm not a deluded scouser btw.

Ché Guayaba wrote:Hmmm, one plays for one of the best teams in England and is a first choice international while the other is playing for a mid table team, third choice for his country and a Barcelona reject on top of that.

Clearly Cech.

You're not a very good troll.

Reina, in my view he's the best goalkeeper in the Premier League since van der Sar's retirement. Cech's not as far behind as people make out though.

Cam wrote:

Ché Guayaba wrote:Hmmm, one plays for one of the best teams in England and is a first choice international while the other is playing for a mid table team, third choice for his country and a Barcelona reject on top of that.

Clearly Cech.

You're not a very good troll.

That's because he's not

Fonseca wrote:

Cam wrote:

Ché Guayaba wrote:Hmmm, one plays for one of the best teams in England and is a first choice international while the other is playing for a mid table team, third choice for his country and a Barcelona reject on top of that.

Clearly Cech.

You're not a very good troll.

That's because he's not

Don't talk to me please.

Cam wrote:

Fonseca wrote:

Cam wrote:

Ché Guayaba wrote:Hmmm, one plays for one of the best teams in England and is a first choice international while the other is playing for a mid table team, third choice for his country and a Barcelona reject on top of that.

Clearly Cech.

You're not a very good troll.

That's because he's not

Don't talk to me please.

Hi cam how are you?

I think Reina.

Ché Guayaba wrote:Hmmm, one plays for one of the best teams in England and is a first choice international while the other is playing for a mid table team, third choice for his country and a Barcelona reject on top of that.

Clearly Cech.

Retard comment.

By your logic, Jeffren is a better player than Aguero, because Aguero's playing for a mid-table team and Jeffren is playing for the best team in the world. I don't see why people go by this shitty logic.
Your other point also makes you look like a cunt. Reina's second choice for Spain behind the best keeper in the world and faces competition from Valdes, Lopez and soon, Guatia and De Gea. Cech faces competition from Grigar.

Thought you were smarter than that Che. Utterly stupid.

Cadbury wrote:

Ché Guayaba wrote:Hmmm, one plays for one of the best teams in England and is a first choice international while the other is playing for a mid table team, third choice for his country and a Barcelona reject on top of that.

Clearly Cech.

Retard comment.

By your logic, Jeffren is a better player than Aguero, because Aguero's playing for a mid-table team and Jeffren is playing for the best team in the world. I don't see why people go by this shitty logic.
Your other point also makes you look like a cunt. Reina's second choice for Spain behind the best keeper in the world and faces competition from Valdes, Lopez and soon, Guatia and De Gea. Cech faces competition from Grigar.

Thought you were smarter than that Che. Utterly stupid.

Jeffren isn't a regular starter though, is he? So it's hardly the same.

Che 1 - 0 Cadbury

Cech for me personally.

Scott wrote:Picked Reina.

Used to think Cech was the best in the world and was really jealous Chelsea had him, but ever since his injury, he just doesn't seem to be the same.

Reina has more to his game and is one of the best, if not the best goalkeeper at starting off counter-attacking movements.

Not really

grenade187 wrote:

Scott wrote:Picked Reina.

Used to think Cech was the best in the world and was really jealous Chelsea had him, but ever since his injury, he just doesn't seem to be the same.

Reina has more to his game and is one of the best, if not the best goalkeeper at starting off counter-attacking movements.

Not really

Who then? Provide me with some video evidence.

luke. wrote:

Cadbury wrote:

Ché Guayaba wrote:Hmmm, one plays for one of the best teams in England and is a first choice international while the other is playing for a mid table team, third choice for his country and a Barcelona reject on top of that.

Clearly Cech.

Retard comment.

By your logic, Jeffren is a better player than Aguero, because Aguero's playing for a mid-table team and Jeffren is playing for the best team in the world. I don't see why people go by this shitty logic.
Your other point also makes you look like a cunt. Reina's second choice for Spain behind the best keeper in the world and faces competition from Valdes, Lopez and soon, Guatia and De Gea. Cech faces competition from Grigar.

Thought you were smarter than that Che. Utterly stupid.

Jeffren isn't a regular starter though, is he? So it's hardly the same.

Alright, here's a better one;
Nesta's a better player than Chiellini because he plays for the best team in Italy while Chiellini plays for a mid-table Itallian team.

CollieBuddz wrote:Che 1 - 0 Cadbury

He's not replied, so it's still level. Though I'm entitled to points because he used some shitty over-used logic that "He's better than him because he plays for a better team."

Cadbury wrote:

luke. wrote:

Cadbury wrote:

Ché Guayaba wrote:Hmmm, one plays for one of the best teams in England and is a first choice international while the other is playing for a mid table team, third choice for his country and a Barcelona reject on top of that.

Clearly Cech.

Retard comment.

By your logic, Jeffren is a better player than Aguero, because Aguero's playing for a mid-table team and Jeffren is playing for the best team in the world. I don't see why people go by this shitty logic.
Your other point also makes you look like a cunt. Reina's second choice for Spain behind the best keeper in the world and faces competition from Valdes, Lopez and soon, Guatia and De Gea. Cech faces competition from Grigar.

Thought you were smarter than that Che. Utterly stupid.

Jeffren isn't a regular starter though, is he? So it's hardly the same.

Alright, here's a better one;
Nesta's a better player than Chiellini because he plays for the best team in Italy while Chiellini plays for a mid-table Itallian team.

When Nesta isn't injured he is arguably as good as, or better than Chiellini.