England V France - Wembley 8pm Kick-off

luke. wrote:

James wrote:

luke. wrote:

James wrote:

luke. wrote:

James wrote:Malouda world class?

Sorry but no. He had 1 good season.

He had a lot more then just 1 more good season, there is football outside of England you know

Tell me what league he played in before England. You cannot be world class playing in that league.

So if you play in a certain league you can't be world class? Fuck off.

If Messi played in the Irish league he'd still be world class.. good logic you have there.

You have to prove you are world class, it would be different Messi moving away from Barcelona as he has proved he can do it in a top league consistently. Malouda had 1 good season in a top league.

The-Reporter wrote:

James wrote:

luke. wrote:

James wrote:Malouda world class?

Sorry but no. He had 1 good season.

He had a lot more then just 1 more good season, there is football outside of England you know

Tell me what league he played in before England. You cannot be world class playing in that league.

Ligue 1.

What do you mean you can't be world class? So if Fabregas went and played one match in Ligue one for the match he's not world class? Are you a spastic?

I think you are the spastic for saying something like that. 1. How would he go and play 1 match in Ligue 1 without being injured or dropped. Like I said, it would be different seeing as he has already proved it in a top league that he is world class.

I suppose Ribery ain't world class then? Or Phillip Lahm?

What the fuck am I arguing for, you only watch English football so you wouldn't have a clue.

He's not tbh.

We should stick bloody Walcott up front and play that regular hoof ball we're used to with Carroll and Walcott

coolmarvin wrote:

luke. wrote:

James wrote:

luke. wrote:

James wrote:

luke. wrote:

James wrote:Malouda world class?

Sorry but no. He had 1 good season.

He had a lot more then just 1 more good season, there is football outside of England you know

Tell me what league he played in before England. You cannot be world class playing in that league.

So if you play in a certain league you can't be world class? Fuck off.

If Messi played in the Irish league he'd still be world class.. good logic you have there.

You have to prove you are world class, it would be different Messi moving away from Barcelona as he has proved he can do it in a top league consistently. Malouda had 1 good season in a top league.

The-Reporter wrote:

James wrote:

luke. wrote:

James wrote:Malouda world class?

Sorry but no. He had 1 good season.

He had a lot more then just 1 more good season, there is football outside of England you know

Tell me what league he played in before England. You cannot be world class playing in that league.

Ligue 1.

What do you mean you can't be world class? So if Fabregas went and played one match in Ligue one for the match he's not world class? Are you a spastic?

I think you are the spastic for saying something like that. 1. How would he go and play 1 match in Ligue 1 without being injured or dropped. Like I said, it would be different seeing as he has already proved it in a top league that he is world class.

I suppose Ribery ain't world class then? Or Phillip Lahm?

What the fuck am I arguing for, you only watch English football so you wouldn't have a clue.

He's not tbh.

Well If Nani is world class according to some Utd fans, Ribery is.

Luke.

1. You are wrong, i've started watching other leagues.
2. Malouda plays England so what leagues I watch other leagues I watch is irrelevant. It is easy to tell which are the weaker leagues.
3. Ribery isn't world class.

As for Lahm i'll admit he's world class, but he has proven that while playing with Germany which is an even bigger stage then the PL/La Liga/Serie A.

Malouda had 1 good season in a top league. Simple. He hasn't done much for France either.

It's so painful watching England trying to attack.

Nasri is playing absolute class.

Gibbs

Was hoping to see more off this M'Villa kid, but he's not really got a chance to do much seeing as they are camped in England's half.

James wrote:Luke.

1. You are wrong, i've started watching other leagues.
2. Malouda plays England so what leagues I watch other leagues I watch is irrelevant. It is easy to tell which are the weaker leagues.
3. Ribery isn't world class.

As for Lahm i'll admit he's world class, but he has proven that while playing with Germany which is an even bigger stage then the PL/La Liga/Serie A.

Malouda had 1 good season in a top league. Simple. He hasn't done much for France either.

Clearly not if you think world class players aren't world class if they play in Ligue 1

2 Makes no sense whatsoever, but it is relevant.. as you said he had 1 good season, and you've only watched him while hes in England.. he only took time to settle into the league, he's been performing for France since 2004 too. And has been a regular.

For your info, here is a list of wingers better than Malouda.

World Class - Ronaldo, Messi, Robben, Robinho(if you class him as a winger)

Not quite World Class but still better - Ribery, Navas, Arshavin, Silva(If you class him as a winger)

Then on par with Malouda - Bale, Valencia, Nani, Krasic, Mata(If you class him as a winger), Arda Turan

I probably missed some from that list too.

Henderson has given the ball away more times than Carroll.

That's quite some achievement.

luke. wrote:

James wrote:Luke.

1. You are wrong, i've started watching other leagues.
2. Malouda plays England so what leagues I watch other leagues I watch is irrelevant. It is easy to tell which are the weaker leagues.
3. Ribery isn't world class.

As for Lahm i'll admit he's world class, but he has proven that while playing with Germany which is an even bigger stage then the PL/La Liga/Serie A.

Malouda had 1 good season in a top league. Simple. He hasn't done much for France either.

Clearly not if you think world class players aren't world class if they play in Ligue 1

2 Makes no sense whatsoever, but it is relevant.. as you said he had 1 good season, and you've only watched him while hes in England.. he only took time to settle into the league, he's been performing for France since 2004 too. And has been a regular.

My 2nd point didn't make sense but you knew what I was getting at.

Basically you are saying that if a player plays well in Turkey constantly we can class him as world class? No.

James wrote:For your info, here is a list of wingers better than Malouda.

World Class - Ronaldo, Messi, Robben, Robinho(if you class him as a winger)

Not quite World Class but still better - Ribery, Navas, Arshavin, Silva(If you class him as a winger)

Then on par with Malouda - Bale, Valencia, Nani, Krasic, Mata(If you class him as a winger), Arda Turan

I probably missed some from that list too.

Malouda >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Bale.

James wrote:For your info, here is a list of wingers better than Malouda.

World Class - Ronaldo, Messi, Robben, Robinho(if you class him as a winger)

Not quite World Class but still better - Ribery, Navas, Arshavin, Silva(If you class him as a winger)

Then on par with Malouda - Bale, Valencia, Nani, Krasic, Mata(If you class him as a winger)

I probably missed some from that list too.

Ronaldo and Messi aren't wingers.. Robinho better then Malouda? Haha, fuck off mate, you stupid twat.

Malouda is easily better then Arshavin, and maybe Ribery. Silva isn't a winger.

Bale, Valencia, Nani, Krasic all equal? Fuck off.. you seriously know nothing if u think that.

Oh and yeah, Bale, Nani, Krasic and Robinho have only had pretty much 1 good season, some not even.. so how they're counted as world class ill never know.

The-Reporter wrote:

James wrote:For your info, here is a list of wingers better than Malouda.

World Class - Ronaldo, Messi, Robben, Robinho(if you class him as a winger)

Not quite World Class but still better - Ribery, Navas, Arshavin, Silva(If you class him as a winger)

Then on par with Malouda - Bale, Valencia, Nani, Krasic, Mata(If you class him as a winger), Arda Turan

I probably missed some from that list too.

Malouda >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Bale.

On Bales form towards the end of last season and this season i'd say they are equal.

Actually Malouda's been on top form ever since Gus hiddink was at Chelsea.

James wrote:

The-Reporter wrote:

James wrote:For your info, here is a list of wingers better than Malouda.

World Class - Ronaldo, Messi, Robben, Robinho(if you class him as a winger)

Not quite World Class but still better - Ribery, Navas, Arshavin, Silva(If you class him as a winger)

Then on par with Malouda - Bale, Valencia, Nani, Krasic, Mata(If you class him as a winger), Arda Turan

I probably missed some from that list too.

Malouda >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Bale.

On Bales form towards the end of last season and this season i'd say they are equal.

Didn't you accuse somebody of judging Malouda on one season, and now you are talking about Bale and he hasn't even gone a full season being good?

Sean CFC wrote:Actually Malouda's been on top form ever since Gus hiddink was at Chelsea.

Was gonna say this too, remember his ghost goal in the FA cup final? that was beaut.

The-Reporter wrote:

James wrote:

The-Reporter wrote:

James wrote:For your info, here is a list of wingers better than Malouda.

World Class - Ronaldo, Messi, Robben, Robinho(if you class him as a winger)

Not quite World Class but still better - Ribery, Navas, Arshavin, Silva(If you class him as a winger)

Then on par with Malouda - Bale, Valencia, Nani, Krasic, Mata(If you class him as a winger), Arda Turan

I probably missed some from that list too.

Malouda >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Bale.

On Bales form towards the end of last season and this season i'd say they are equal.

Didn't you accuse somebody of judging Malouda on one season, and now you are talking about Bale and he hasn't even gone a full season being good?

Calling someone world class after 1 good season isn't right. Calling them a good player after 1 good season is fair imo.

Also, Malouda is joint top scorer this season as well.. and his form hasn't really been as good as last season either..

James wrote:

The-Reporter wrote:

James wrote:

The-Reporter wrote:

James wrote:For your info, here is a list of wingers better than Malouda.

World Class - Ronaldo, Messi, Robben, Robinho(if you class him as a winger)

Not quite World Class but still better - Ribery, Navas, Arshavin, Silva(If you class him as a winger)

Then on par with Malouda - Bale, Valencia, Nani, Krasic, Mata(If you class him as a winger), Arda Turan

I probably missed some from that list too.

Malouda >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Bale.

On Bales form towards the end of last season and this season i'd say they are equal.

Didn't you accuse somebody of judging Malouda on one season, and now you are talking about Bale and he hasn't even gone a full season being good?

Calling someone world class after 1 good season isn't right. Calling them a good player after 1 good season is fair imo.

Malouda has been very good for a while and last season had slightly better stats than Arshavin who you put a level above him. Although people said Arshavin was poor, yet contributed to 20 goals with his goals/assists.

That list of players I posted then, put them in order for me. I want to see your opinions rather than just slating mine.


Also, what is Maloudas best position seeing as he played alot in a midfield 3 as well. Didn't some of his best form come in the centre?

Carroll just did Mexes

Messi, Ronaldo, Robben, Malouda, Ribery, Arshavin, Silva, Robinho, Bale/Navas/Nani/Mata, Krasic, Turan.

Biased.

James wrote:Biased.

It's an opinion, of course it's fucking biased.

Leave out Messi and Ronaldo because they are just another level. They are what i call elite.

Out of them players i'd put

Arshavin, Malouda, Robben on par then the rest.

Robben was single handedly winning games for Bayern... Malouda didn't do that for Chelsea.

"If we're going to play long ball let's do it properly with Cahill and Johnson as centre backs, Nolan, Cattermole and Muamba in midfield and Crouch, Davies and Carroll upfront!"