Liverpool vs Manchester City | Match Thread | Sunday 4pm |

TRS-T_AVFC wrote:

I Andy I wrote:

I'm not saying De Gea better either, Hart is better than Given and Reina.

James wrote:Given is Overrated. He is a great shot stopper, that's all.

cheesy wrote:Reina is easily better than Hart, while I'd still take Given ahead of him as well.

cheesy wrote:

James wrote:Given is Overrated. He is a great shot stopper, that's all.

Still, if you want a goalkeeper to be great at anything, then it would be shot stopping, a department that he's brilliant in.

cheesy wrote:

James wrote:Given is Overrated. He is a great shot stopper, that's all.

Still, if you want a goalkeeper to be great at anything, then it would be shot stopping, a department that he's brilliant in.

Mal wrote:

cheesy wrote:Reina is easily better than Hart, while I'd still take Given ahead of him as well.

I think Hart is better.

Sammys_Tekkers wrote:Hart is extremely over-rated. Very good, but not near the level people think.

So, has Nasri done anything for Man City yet since he signed?

Sammys_Tekkers wrote:Hart is extremely over-rated. Very good, but not near the level people think.

So, has Nasri done anything for Man City yet since he signed?

cheesy wrote:

Mal wrote:

I think Hart is better.

I'm sure he will be better soon, but I'd still take Given at the moment, purely for his fantastic shot stopping. I'll give you the fact that Hart is better at other things, such as commanding the defence better. I think that's something that Given does lack. He never really seems to organise his defence as often as he should.

Mal wrote:

Bogdan wrote:Derrr it's not even half the season yet.

There's not many games that City could lose. Liverpool away is one of the toughest fixtures.

James wrote:

cheesy wrote:
Still, if you want a goalkeeper to be great at anything, then it would be shot stopping, a department that he's brilliant in.

I'd rather have someone that is good in every department rather than great in just 1 department.

Scott wrote:City dominating. 2 fluke goals, although Kompany's one looked like a fantastic goal on first viewing.

Fully expect us to lose still. 2-1 or 3-1.

Have to say, I've enjoyed watching Adam these last 2 weeks. His bursts forwards are quite good.

James wrote:

cheesy wrote:
Still, if you want a goalkeeper to be great at anything, then it would be shot stopping, a department that he's brilliant in.

I'd rather have someone that is good in every department rather than great in just 1 department.

68% - Shay Given has saved 68% of shots on target faced in the last five seasons - below the Premier League average of 70%. Resurrection.

Jord wrote:

James wrote:

I'd rather have someone that is good in every department rather than great in just 1 department.

Meaning you rate Reina higher than Hart?

Zzonked wrote:

Sammys_Tekkers wrote:Hart is extremely over-rated. Very good, but not near the level people think.

So, has Nasri done anything for Man City yet since he signed?

6 assists in 6 games and a goal.

Zzonked wrote:

68% - Shay Given has saved 68% of shots on target faced in the last five seasons - below the Premier League average of 70%. Resurrection.

Great shot stopper, Given.

kyro7 wrote:

Scott wrote:City dominating. 2 fluke goals, although Kompany's one looked like a fantastic goal on first viewing.

Fully expect us to lose still. 2-1 or 3-1.

Have to say, I've enjoyed watching Adam these last 2 weeks. His bursts forwards are quite good.

About time you got a bit of luck in front of goal though.

Zzonked wrote:

Sammys_Tekkers wrote:Hart is extremely over-rated. Very good, but not near the level people think.

So, has Nasri done anything for Man City yet since he signed?

6 assists in 6 games and a goal.

kyro7 wrote:Fuck me man, just seeing Silva, Nasri and Aguero in the same team makes me cream and cry at the same time.

Zzonked wrote:

68% - Shay Given has saved 68% of shots on target faced in the last five seasons - below the Premier League average of 70%. Resurrection.

Great shot stopper, Given.