Cadbury wrote:Chris wrote:
Since RVP has been playing lone striker he has the most prolific strike rate in EPL.
Before these "2 season's" he was playing as a second striker or winger. I guess you only watch Liverpool.
So did Kuyt... interesting.
+41
The Zlatan
menalawyerguy
Glen Miller
PrideOfTheMidlands
JamieB
FishnChips
Laurencio
crump
George
jeb4eva
drivescore
Muhkoo
Barton
Keanoo
Mason
Danny
Kuled
GK01
fluffy_kittens
Mal
ResurrectionRooney
Cadbury
LFC_Grunners
samiz
Jord
The Bat-Man
Grenade
Mustangt125
El_indian
Steadman
Jeff
El Jefe
Phadunkin Donuts
VivaRonaldoLAD
Sean
Childish Logic
Hitchy
Dr. Ján Ĩtor
Clark
Mouse
Carlos Jenkinson
45 posters
Van Persie or Suarez? Who's better?
Poll
.
- [ 67 ]
[72%]
- [ 26 ]
- [28%]
Total Votes: 93
Guest- Guest
Guest- Guest
Fucking hell, shut up
Steadman-
- Posts : 6134
Age : 32
Location : London
Supports : I have humor, yes.
He wasn't one of our main forwards during that time, plus he has had to deal with injuries stopping him gaining any momentum and form. Since his transition as our leading man he has proven what he was always capable of.Cadbury wrote:Van Persie has had two decent seasons. Take them out of the picture and his goals/assists record isn't much better than Kuyt's
Guest- Guest
Eternal Witcher wrote:Suppose this is just going to keep going until RVP breaks a leg or two.
Keanoo-
- Posts : 11774
Age : 31
Supports : Manchester United
Van Persie has scored 28 goals in 27 Premier League games in 2011. BEAST.
Cadbury-
- Posts : 23487
Age : 31
Location : Blackpool
Supports : Not Kenny.
06/07
Kuyt - 14
RvP - 13
07/08
Kuyt - 11
RvP - 9
08/09
Kuyt - 15
RvP - 20
09/10
Kuyt - 11
RvP - 10
10/11
Kuyt - 15
RvP - 22
.
Kuyt - 14
RvP - 13
07/08
Kuyt - 11
RvP - 9
08/09
Kuyt - 15
RvP - 20
09/10
Kuyt - 11
RvP - 10
10/11
Kuyt - 15
RvP - 22
.
Guest- Guest
How many apps?Cadbury wrote:06/07
Kuyt - 14
RvP - 13
07/08
Kuyt - 11
RvP - 9
08/09
Kuyt - 15
RvP - 20
09/10
Kuyt - 11
RvP - 10
10/11
Kuyt - 15
RvP - 22
Guest- Guest
Cadbury wrote:06/07
Kuyt - 14
RvP - 13
07/08
Kuyt - 11
RvP - 9
08/09
Kuyt - 15
RvP - 20
09/10
Kuyt - 11
RvP - 10
10/11
Kuyt - 15
RvP - 22
Cadbury-
- Posts : 23487
Age : 31
Location : Blackpool
Supports : Not Kenny.
Kuyt has more apps, which shows he's more reliable. Maybe God is a Dutchmankyro7 wrote:How many apps?Cadbury wrote:06/07
Kuyt - 14
RvP - 13
07/08
Kuyt - 11
RvP - 9
08/09
Kuyt - 15
RvP - 20
09/10
Kuyt - 11
RvP - 10
10/11
Kuyt - 15
RvP - 22.
.
Danny-
- Posts : 55218
Age : 30
Location : Burscough
Only Cristiano Ronaldo has scored more goals in the top 5 European leagues than Robin van Persie in 2011.
Guest- Guest
Another thing. Van Persie is aging. 28 already.
Suarez is only 24.
Suarez now is better than 24 year old Van Persie.
Suarez is only 24.
Suarez now is better than 24 year old Van Persie.
El Jefe-
- Formerly known as : Jay
Posts : 10657
Location : In the hall, already, on the wall, already
Supports : Pixie Lott's Legs
Suarez of today is head and shoulders above RvP of 4 years ago.
Also, in Holland, Suarez often played off a main striker, usually Huntelaar or Pantelic, so his role wasn't too much different from van Persie's, and his scoring record was much better.
Also, in Holland, Suarez often played off a main striker, usually Huntelaar or Pantelic, so his role wasn't too much different from van Persie's, and his scoring record was much better.
Danny-
- Posts : 55218
Age : 30
Location : Burscough
That's because it's in fucking Holland.Jay wrote:Suarez of today is head and shoulders above RvP of 4 years ago.
Also, in Holland, Suarez often played off a main striker, usually Huntelaar or Pantelic, so his role wasn't too much different from van Persie's, and his scoring record was much better.
Unless you meant it was better than RVP's record in Holland.
Even so, RVP's better.
Steadman-
- Posts : 6134
Age : 32
Location : London
Supports : I have humor, yes.
People using ages as comparisons. 
Do you not realise people peak at different ages?
Do you not realise people peak at different ages?
Cadbury-
- Posts : 23487
Age : 31
Location : Blackpool
Supports : Not Kenny.
Danny wrote:That's because it's in fucking Holland.Jay wrote:Suarez of today is head and shoulders above RvP of 4 years ago.
Also, in Holland, Suarez often played off a main striker, usually Huntelaar or Pantelic, so his role wasn't too much different from van Persie's, and his scoring record was much better.
Unless you meant it was better than RVP's record in Holland.
Even so, RVP's better.
Guest- Guest
Steadman wrote:People using ages as comparisons.
Do you not realise people peak at different ages?
I believe Suarez will be even better at 28.
Guest- Guest
RVP is 100 times the player Kuyt has ever been.Cadbury wrote:06/07
Kuyt - 14
RvP - 13
07/08
Kuyt - 11
RvP - 9
08/09
Kuyt - 15
RvP - 20
09/10
Kuyt - 11
RvP - 10
10/11
Kuyt - 15
RvP - 22
Suarez will be at a decent club when he's 28 aswell.. maybe Arsenal.Scott wrote:Another thing. Van Persie is aging. 28 already.
Suarez is only 24.
Suarez now is better than 24 year old Van Persie.
Barton-
- Formerly known as : JMB_94
Posts : 10066
Age : 30
Isn't it ironic that Liverpool fans are the only ones who think Suarez is better?
Seriously, you guys are blinded by delusion sometimes.
Seriously, you guys are blinded by delusion sometimes.
Steadman-
- Posts : 6134
Age : 32
Location : London
Supports : I have humor, yes.
That is impossible to predict. He could get a serious injury (hopefully not) and could never be the same player again. He could also stop progressing as a player in a few years, you just never know.Scott wrote:Steadman wrote:People using ages as comparisons.
Do you not realise people peak at different ages?
I believe Suarez will be even better at 28.
Guest- Guest
He didn't do anything against us though did he. Missed a sitter too.
Suarez scored against you and shat your defences into scoring an own goal.
He had less time on the pitch too.
Suarez
Suarez scored against you and shat your defences into scoring an own goal.
He had less time on the pitch too.Suarez
Cadbury-
- Posts : 23487
Age : 31
Location : Blackpool
Supports : Not Kenny.
JMB_94 wrote:Isn't it ironic that Liverpool fans are the only ones who think Suarez is better?
Seriously, you guys are blinded by delusion sometimes.
You're a massive twat btw.
ResurrectionRooney-
- Posts : 17681
Supports : United
Scott wrote:He didn't do anything against us though did he. Missed a sitter too.
Suarez scored against you and shat your defences into scoring an own goal.
Suarez
Neither of those goals should have counted.
Guest- Guest
Cadbury wrote:JMB_94 wrote:Isn't it ironic that Liverpool fans are the only ones who think Suarez is better?
Seriously, you guys are blinded by delusion sometimes.
You're a massive twat btw.
I Agree with this.
Guest- Guest
ResurrectionRooney wrote:Scott wrote:He didn't do anything against us though did he. Missed a sitter too.
Suarez scored against you and shat your defences into scoring an own goal.
Suarez
Neither of those goals should have counted.
False.
What about 2 of your goals against Chelsea?
Last edited by Scott on Sun Oct 30, 2011 1:45 am; edited 1 time in total
Guest- Guest
Ha, people thinking only the liverpool fans really rate Suarez when this forum has always been strangely but evidently against us. Not that their's a conspiracy, just plenty of cretins.
Barton-
- Formerly known as : JMB_94
Posts : 10066
Age : 30
Cadbury wrote:JMB_94 wrote:Isn't it ironic that Liverpool fans are the only ones who think Suarez is better?
Seriously, you guys are blinded by delusion sometimes.
You're a massive twat btw.
I am not a twat, i just think some of staticstics and reasons you've come up with are ridiuclous. Like 'Yeah well can RVP score against Stoke? Suarez can so he's obviously better'.
Cadbury-
- Posts : 23487
Age : 31
Location : Blackpool
Supports : Not Kenny.
Eternal Witcher wrote:Ha, people thinking only the liverpool fans really rate Suarez when this forum has always been strangely but evidently against us. Not that their's a conspiracy, just plenty of cretins.
That JMB guy makes out he's a neutral but in reality, he's an Ipswich/United fan who hates Liverpool
.
Guest- Guest
I think JMB is not very good at picking up on sarcasm.
Cadbury-
- Posts : 23487
Age : 31
Location : Blackpool
Supports : Not Kenny.
JMB_94 wrote:Cadbury wrote:
You're a massive twat btw.
I am not a twat, i just think some of staticstics and reasons you've come up with are ridiuclous. Like 'Yeah well can RVP score against Stoke? Suarez can so he's obviously better'.
Can you not see that this is a joke? You know, that old "Messi can't do it on a Wednesday night against Stoke."
Guest- Guest
Suarez is a quality player nobody is doubting that.
Van Persie has better finishing, positioning, passing, vision, touch and is not half as much of a diver or cheater.
If Suarez had scored that hattrick today Liverpool fans would say he's better than Messi no doubt.
Van Persie has better finishing, positioning, passing, vision, touch and is not half as much of a diver or cheater.
If Suarez had scored that hattrick today Liverpool fans would say he's better than Messi no doubt.
