Adam or Lucas

Lucas is shit.All he do is pass da ball sideways can't believe he near da brazil team when all he do is run around da pitch kicking people dis not the brazil way. Only look reasonable at Liverpool cos he playing wif even badder players.
Charlie Adams family is da heart and soul of his club and much better played dan da brazil imposter Lucas cos he can actually pass da ball forward.


In all seriousness, Lucas has improved alot over the last few seasons and is now a quality defensive midfielder who can pass a ball forward contrary to popular belief. Lucas was everywhere against us at the Emirates.

Scott wrote:Who is Lucas?

Should have put a world class midfielder in instead of Lucas (who?) .. Like Nasri or Fabregas.

Not really because Nasri and Fabregas are far better than both of these players put together.

kyro7 wrote:

Scott wrote:Who is Lucas?

Should have put a world class midfielder in instead of Lucas (who?) .. Like Nasri or Fabregas.

Not really because Nasri and Fabregas are far better than both of these players put together.

I'd rather have Lucas at DM than Nasri.

Scott wrote:Who is Lucas?

Should have put a world class midfielder in instead of Lucas (who?) .. Like Nasri or Fabregas.

lolololololololololololololololololol
Fail troll is fail.

Dan wrote:

kyro7 wrote:

Scott wrote:Who is Lucas?

Should have put a world class midfielder in instead of Lucas (who?) .. Like Nasri or Fabregas.

Not really because Nasri and Fabregas are far better than both of these players put together.

I'd rather have Lucas at DM than Nasri.

Correct, but I'd rather have Nasri than Lucas in a squad.

kyro7 wrote:

Dan wrote:

kyro7 wrote:

Scott wrote:Who is Lucas?

Should have put a world class midfielder in instead of Lucas (who?) .. Like Nasri or Fabregas.

Not really because Nasri and Fabregas are far better than both of these players put together.

I'd rather have Lucas at DM than Nasri.

Correct, but I'd rather have Nasri than Lucas in a squad.

Stupid statement. They play different positions, Lucas is as important to the squad than Nasri is.

Dan wrote:

kyro7 wrote:

Dan wrote:

kyro7 wrote:

Scott wrote:Who is Lucas?

Should have put a world class midfielder in instead of Lucas (who?) .. Like Nasri or Fabregas.

Not really because Nasri and Fabregas are far better than both of these players put together.

I'd rather have Lucas at DM than Nasri.

Correct, but I'd rather have Nasri than Lucas in a squad.

Stupid statement. They play different positions, Lucas is as important to the squad than Nasri is.

Stupid statement? What are you on about Dan?

If I had to choose one in a squad it'd be Nasri because he's better attacking midfielder than Lucas is a defensive midfielder.

Not a stupid statement if it's my choice that I'd pick Nasri in a squad ahead of Lucas.

Coatsy wrote:Lucas is shit.All he do is pass da ball sideways can't believe he near da brazil team when all he do is run around da pitch kicking people dis not the brazil way. Only look reasonable at Liverpool cos he playing wif even badder players.
Charlie Adams family is da heart and soul of his club and much better played dan da brazil imposter Lucas cos he can actually pass da ball forward.


In all seriousness, Lucas has improved alot over the last few seasons and is now a quality defensive midfielder who can pass a ball forward contrary to popular belief. Lucas was everywhere against us at the Emirates.

Fail

Fonseca wrote:

Coatsy wrote:Lucas is shit.All he do is pass da ball sideways can't believe he near da brazil team when all he do is run around da pitch kicking people dis not the brazil way. Only look reasonable at Liverpool cos he playing wif even badder players.
Charlie Adams family is da heart and soul of his club and much better played dan da brazil imposter Lucas cos he can actually pass da ball forward.


In all seriousness, Lucas has improved alot over the last few seasons and is now a quality defensive midfielder who can pass a ball forward contrary to popular belief. Lucas was everywhere against us at the Emirates.

Fail

Coatsy wrote:

Fonseca wrote:

Coatsy wrote:Lucas is shit.All he do is pass da ball sideways can't believe he near da brazil team when all he do is run around da pitch kicking people dis not the brazil way. Only look reasonable at Liverpool cos he playing wif even badder players.
Charlie Adams family is da heart and soul of his club and much better played dan da brazil imposter Lucas cos he can actually pass da ball forward.


In all seriousness, Lucas has improved alot over the last few seasons and is now a quality defensive midfielder who can pass a ball forward contrary to popular belief. Lucas was everywhere against us at the Emirates.

Fail

kyro7 wrote:

Dan wrote:

kyro7 wrote:

Dan wrote:

kyro7 wrote:Not really because Nasri and Fabregas are far better than both of these players put together.

I'd rather have Lucas at DM than Nasri.

Correct, but I'd rather have Nasri than Lucas in a squad.

Stupid statement. They play different positions, Lucas is as important to the squad than Nasri is.

Stupid statement? What are you on about Dan?

If I had to choose one in a squad it'd be Nasri because he's better attacking midfielder than Lucas is a defensive midfielder.

Not a stupid statement if it's my choice that I'd pick Nasri in a squad ahead of Lucas.

Of course it is. You're saying that you'd pick an attacking player over a defensive player in a squad. There's no reason to have to pick between them because they are different positions. Song and Lucas would be a better comparison.

Dan wrote:Of course it is. You're saying that you'd pick an attacking player over a defensive player in a squad. There's no reason to have to pick between them because they are different positions. Song and Lucas would be a better comparison.

Oh my god, I'm saying if I had to put one and only one into a squad it would be Nasri because he's better.

Like I think Gerrard is better than Aurelio, they might play different positions but I think Gerrard is a better central midfielder than Aurelio is a left back, it's not stupid what I'm saying at all.

kyro7 wrote:

Dan wrote:Of course it is. You're saying that you'd pick an attacking player over a defensive player in a squad. There's no reason to have to pick between them because they are different positions. Song and Lucas would be a better comparison.

Oh my god, I'm saying if I had to put one and only one into a squad it would be Nasri because he's better.

Like I think Gerrard is better than Aurelio, they might play different positions but I think Gerrard is a better central midfielder than Aurelio is a left back, it's not stupid what I'm saying at all.

I'm gonna stop here because you keep missing the point.

Dan wrote:

kyro7 wrote:

Dan wrote:Of course it is. You're saying that you'd pick an attacking player over a defensive player in a squad. There's no reason to have to pick between them because they are different positions. Song and Lucas would be a better comparison.

Oh my god, I'm saying if I had to put one and only one into a squad it would be Nasri because he's better.

Like I think Gerrard is better than Aurelio, they might play different positions but I think Gerrard is a better central midfielder than Aurelio is a left back, it's not stupid what I'm saying at all.

I'm gonna stop here because you keep missing the point.

No, you keep missing the point Dan, I'm saying if I had to choose one, and ONLY one of them, it'd be Nasri.

Then you start going on about their positions and it's totally irrelevant because I can only pick ONE of them, I'm not putting Lucas down.. I know having them BOTH would be good.. but if I could ONLY PICK ONE it'd be Samir Nasri.

kyro7 wrote:

Dan wrote:

kyro7 wrote:

Dan wrote:Of course it is. You're saying that you'd pick an attacking player over a defensive player in a squad. There's no reason to have to pick between them because they are different positions. Song and Lucas would be a better comparison.

Oh my god, I'm saying if I had to put one and only one into a squad it would be Nasri because he's better.

Like I think Gerrard is better than Aurelio, they might play different positions but I think Gerrard is a better central midfielder than Aurelio is a left back, it's not stupid what I'm saying at all.

I'm gonna stop here because you keep missing the point.

No, you keep missing the point Dan, I'm saying if I had to choose one, and ONLY one of them, it'd be Nasri.

Then you start going on about their positions and it's totally irrelevant because I can only pick ONE of them, I'm not putting Lucas down.. I know having them BOTH would be good.. but if I could ONLY PICK ONE it'd be Samir Nasri.

No, I completely understand you think ONE is better than the other. But the point is, they are different players. That whole comparison makes no sense. Like the 'I'd pick Gerrard in a squad over Aurelio'. What squad? A completely random squad or an actual team that exists?

I could say 'I'd pick Bramble in a squad over Messi'. It doesn't add anything. and it makes no sense.

Bad comparison is bad.
Should be a CM vs CM or DM vs DM etc.
Not ST vs CB etc.

Dan wrote:

kyro7 wrote:

Dan wrote:

kyro7 wrote:

Dan wrote:Of course it is. You're saying that you'd pick an attacking player over a defensive player in a squad. There's no reason to have to pick between them because they are different positions. Song and Lucas would be a better comparison.

Oh my god, I'm saying if I had to put one and only one into a squad it would be Nasri because he's better.

Like I think Gerrard is better than Aurelio, they might play different positions but I think Gerrard is a better central midfielder than Aurelio is a left back, it's not stupid what I'm saying at all.

I'm gonna stop here because you keep missing the point.

No, you keep missing the point Dan, I'm saying if I had to choose one, and ONLY one of them, it'd be Nasri.

Then you start going on about their positions and it's totally irrelevant because I can only pick ONE of them, I'm not putting Lucas down.. I know having them BOTH would be good.. but if I could ONLY PICK ONE it'd be Samir Nasri.

No, I completely understand you think ONE is better than the other. But the point is, they are different players. That whole comparison makes no sense. Like the 'I'd pick Gerrard in a squad over Aurelio'. What squad? A completely random squad or an actual team that exists?

I could say 'I'd pick Bramble in a squad over Messi'. It doesn't add anything. and it makes no sense.

End of then, because that's all I'm getting at.

Coatsy wrote:Bad comparison is bad.
Should be a CM vs CM or DM vs DM etc.
Not ST vs CB etc.

That was my point. Thank you.

You can still say you'd rather have one player to another, no matter what position they play in.

If I think Messi is a better attacker than Bramble is a defender, then I can say so.

kyro7 wrote:You can still say you'd rather have one player to another, no matter what position they play in.

If I think Messi is a better attacker than Bramble is a defender, then I can say so.

You can, I didn't say you couldn't. But it's a pointless comparison.

It's really not that stupid. Yes, comparing completely different positions is stupid, but if it's generally a Defender vs Defender, Midfielder vs Midfielder or Forward vs Forward, then it's fair enough, you can say which one you'd prefer in your squad.

arsenalap11 wrote:It's really not that stupid. Yes, comparing completely different positions is stupid, but if it's generally a Defender vs Defender, Midfielder vs Midfielder or Forward vs Forward, then it's fair enough, you can say which one you'd prefer in your squad.

Mascherano or Nasri

Nasri.

kyro7 wrote:Nasri.

Which midfield will be better.

4 Nasri's, or 4 Mascherano's.

arsenalap11 wrote:It's really not that stupid. Yes, comparing completely different positions is stupid, but if it's generally a Defender vs Defender, Midfielder vs Midfielder or Forward vs Forward, then it's fair enough, you can say which one you'd prefer in your squad.

No it isn't. Because for a start, Lucas is a defensive midfielder and Nasri is an attacking midfielder. That's two completely different roles.

david vaughans better than both

Blackpool Rule wrote:david vaughans better than both

Always said Vaughan is better than Adam, but not better than Lucas.

Mr Leiva wrote:

Blackpool Rule wrote:david vaughans better than both

Always said Vaughan is better than Adam, but not better than Lucas.

yeah lucas is better than both.charlie hit his peak at the start of the season and isnt playing anywhere near as good

I see some of the Liverpool fans are at it again..

Filippo Inzaghi wrote:I see some of the Liverpool fans are at it again..

I see you are attempting to WUM again ..