I think Abidal had a great game today and was the best performing defender. But Maxwell usually starts for Barca this season. They are both pretty equal in quality, but who edges it in your opinion?
+3
mac
Torresxvilla
Lux
7 posters
Abidal or Maxwell?
Poll
Abidal or Maxwell?
- [ 10 ]
[63%]
- [ 4 ]
- [25%]
- [ 2 ]
- [12%]
Total Votes: 16
Lux-
- Posts : 9892
Age : 32
Location : North West London
Supports : Watford FC
Johnson :joke:
------------
But ya generally Abidal as he's a better defender. Barcelona have enough attackers and Abidal could still go forward and be decent.
------------
But ya generally Abidal as he's a better defender. Barcelona have enough attackers and Abidal could still go forward and be decent.
Last edited by Luxz0rz on Tue Nov 30, 2010 12:58 pm; edited 1 time in total
Torresxvilla-
- Posts : 893
Against normal La Liga teams, I would say Maxwell, who gives them the extra attacking edge normally.
Abidal was brought in today for defense against Madrid.
Though Abidal did look good today.
Abidal was brought in today for defense against Madrid.
Though Abidal did look good today.
mac-
- Posts : 1505
Age : 33
Supports : Liverpool
Abidal as he is the better defensive player. 
Torresxvilla-
- Posts : 893
BTW, what happened to Adriano from Sevilla?
Guest- Guest
Torresxvilla wrote:BTW, what happened to Adriano from Sevilla?
He has played a few matches this season.
On FM, I replace him for Pedro sometimes and he does pretty good in the right wing position.
Last edited by ahlycotc on Tue Nov 30, 2010 1:17 pm; edited 1 time in total
Torresxvilla-
- Posts : 893
ahlycotc wrote:Torresxvilla wrote:BTW, what happened to Adriano from Sevilla?
He has played a few matches this season.
Hm...thought he was brought in to be the 1st choice LB.
Guess he hasn't performed.
Guest- Guest
Torresxvilla wrote:ahlycotc wrote:Torresxvilla wrote:BTW, what happened to Adriano from Sevilla?
He has played a few matches this season.
Hm...thought he was brought in to be the 1st choice LB.
Guess he hasn't performed.
I haven't really seen much of him so I can't say. Maxwell and Abidal aren't bad.
SBSP-
- Posts : 50010
Abidal by a country mile.
Grenade-
- Formerly known as : grenade187
Posts : 9113
Age : 43
Personally I would say Abidal is the better player, but Maxwell is better at attacking I guess thats why he always starts against weaker teams.
Guest- Guest
Basically what's been said already, v harder teams Abidal works better, but Maxwell is better going forward and passing.
Walcott-
- Posts : 14547
Location : at the stewards with Lewis Hamilton.
Supports : Arsenal & Lewis Hamilton.
What she said.kyro7 wrote:Basically what's been said already, v harder teams Abidal works better, but Maxwell is better going forward and passing.
Guest- Guest
Abidal because when I've watched him he's never put a foot wrong.
Jamie-
- Posts : 24047
Age : 63
Location : Thiago
Supports : That Catalan club
Maxwell, I don't rate Abidal that highly. He's solid but nothing more really.