Luis Suárez vs Sergio Agüero vs Carlos Tévez

Will be interesting to see who people think is the best out of these 3, all have similarities in their build and playing style.

Say who you voted for and why, will make it a better thread than if everyone just votes and gives a one word answer.

Aguero, easily.

El Jefe wrote:Will be interesting to see who people think is the best out of these 3, all have similarities in their build and playing style.

Say who you voted for and why, will make it a better thread than if everyone just votes and gives a one word answer.

Andy wrote:Aguero, easily.

That went well.

Uh oh. I dunno.. I'd like to say that different players are better in different ways, if that makes sense..

I'd like to vote for Suarez, as I think him and Tevez are better all round players than Aguero (although his finishing is the best of the three players), but obviously I can't cos people will go crazy.

I'd say that Suarez is a better Dribbler than Aguero (although he is a really good dribbler) and a bit better at dribbling or the same as Tevez, but Aguero is the best finisher out of them.

I really like Tevez, think he's amazing, I don't really rate Aguero as much as the other two as an all round player, he's really good, but his finishing is his best quality (obviously), but his all round play isn't as good as Suarez (who is basically carrying Liverpool at the moment) and Tevez.

I'm gonna vote for Suarez because I think he's about the same as Tevez and because I want to

I see them as surprisingly different but similar players, this is going to sound odd but I see Suarez as a mixture of Tevez and Aguero, Tevez's famous bulldog like approach with Aguero's dribbling and speed to take men on whilst scoring goals, I personally prefer Suarez to the other 2, but it's close between all 3 really.

I don't know.

I would like to think if Suarez was part of the Manchester City team then he would play better than both Tevez and Aguero.

Jord wrote:I would like to think if Suarez was part of the Manchester City team then he would play better than both Tevez and Aguero.

Not necessarily true, a lot of players perform a lot better when they are the centre of attention even if there are lesser players around them (as Suarez is at Liverpool right now). Tevez and Aguero are both class players, but they have equally as good players all around them so the team doesn't depend on them as much. When City came 3rd a couple years ago Tevez was absolutely outstanding, most likely because their play was more focused more on him rather than spread out through several good attacking players (though City still were pretty good, not quite as good as they are now).

More or less what I'm trying to say, if you're the only player who can finish on your team you're going to have the play focused more on you, thus having more chances and playing better.

Luis Suarez is the best player in the Barclays Premier League, so it has to be him.

Suarez at the moment Tevez before he left city and then came back he was outstanding.

Nice to see 6 liverpool supporters voting.

Feels like youtube again.

All three are far too reliant on their teamates. I would much prefer a player such as Dimitar Berbatov, a player that can do absolutely everything for his team.

Every Fulham game he is all over the pitch with so many touches. He is a joy to watch, everything is skill based with Berbatov, unlike the three you mention who persist in doing scruffy looking dribbles with the ball, occassionally getting lucky deflections off defenders legs with the ball going straight back to them, but the majority of the time losing the ball.

Dimitar Berbatov simply never loses the ball. the only time he does do so is when his teamates fail to be on the same wavelength as he is.

Mr. Agüero.

edit: ^^^Are you still fanboying him after all these years?

1. Aguero
2. Suarez
3. Tevez