My first compilation video, tell me what you think please

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kUZtpqj57dU

Why isn't it letting me use the tags or embed it?

I like it.

Way too much walking around at the start though. Excellent nonetheless.

Ronaldo painted black?

Thanks


I'm gonna edit it then, take out a bit of the start. Realised i've missed out his goal v Millwall too

Pick a better song

I like compilation videos that have at the start bad points of them missing a shot and commentator saying stuff like "He just can't find his form" then it gradually gets better.

This is good though, try to go for a song that is good for the occasion, not a song you like. Also, less walking around.

I liked it, I wanted to make one but I have a hard time finding clips without downloading every football league show.

You should render the video to fit Youtube, look up how to do it so it doesn't show up in a little box.

Well I'm overly critical about these sort of videos, so don't be too sensitive about what I'm about to rant out.

1. The music doesn't fit, it's not good, the singing is awful, the rythm doesn't fit the movements and there is nothing immersive about it.
2. The clips themselves are OK, but of a little poor quality, other than that I find them a little too sharply cut
3. You need to bring in the atmosphere of the goals every once in a while. Having music that lets you turn on the ambient sound is vital
4. Could do with some better transitions, they are too plain and takes away the action and rythm.
5. Some clips are too long, others are too short, you need to find a rythm and stick with it, usually what music is intended to do
6. The intro is basically a loop, if you want to present the player then use music, sounds and somewhat rapid-moving clips, it feels like it's the same thing being churned over too many times. Too long basically.
7. A handful of shots, particulary the one at the end, has the camera too far away for the "slow-motion great moment" to be realistic.


I could go into more detail, but that would just be... I'll shut up now.
As I said, I'm very critical. I've only seen about 3-4 compilations on youtube that I actually liked, and two of those were by professionals =/

Dreadful music.

Lmao Laurencio.

Laurencio wrote:Well I'm overly critical about these sort of videos, so don't be too sensitive about what I'm about to rant out.

1. The music doesn't fit, it's not good, the singing is awful, the rythm doesn't fit the movements and there is nothing immersive about it.
2. The clips themselves are OK, but of a little poor quality, other than that I find them a little too sharply cut
3. You need to bring in the atmosphere of the goals every once in a while. Having music that lets you turn on the ambient sound is vital
4. Could do with some better transitions, they are too plain and takes away the action and rythm.
5. Some clips are too long, others are too short, you need to find a rythm and stick with it, usually what music is intended to do
6. The intro is basically a loop, if you want to present the player then use music, sounds and somewhat rapid-moving clips, it feels like it's the same thing being churned over too many times. Too long basically.
7. A handful of shots, particulary the one at the end, has the camera too far away for the "slow-motion great moment" to be realistic.


I could go into more detail, but that would just be... I'll shut up now.
As I said, I'm very critical. I've only seen about 3-4 compilations on youtube that I actually liked, and two of those were by professionals =/

Whacha think about El Alonso's work?

That's one of the one's Laurencio liked, done by a professional.

kyro7 wrote:

That's one of the one's Laurencio liked, done by a professional.

lmao

Laurencio wrote:Well I'm overly critical about these sort of videos, so don't be too sensitive about what I'm about to rant out.

1. The music doesn't fit, it's not good, the singing is awful, the rythm doesn't fit the movements and there is nothing immersive about it.
2. The clips themselves are OK, but of a little poor quality, other than that I find them a little too sharply cut
3. You need to bring in the atmosphere of the goals every once in a while. Having music that lets you turn on the ambient sound is vital
4. Could do with some better transitions, they are too plain and takes away the action and rythm.
5. Some clips are too long, others are too short, you need to find a rythm and stick with it, usually what music is intended to do
6. The intro is basically a loop, if you want to present the player then use music, sounds and somewhat rapid-moving clips, it feels like it's the same thing being churned over too many times. Too long basically.
7. A handful of shots, particulary the one at the end, has the camera too far away for the "slow-motion great moment" to be realistic.


I could go into more detail, but that would just be... I'll shut up now.
As I said, I'm very critical. I've only seen about 3-4 compilations on youtube that I actually liked, and two of those were by professionals =/

It's hard to find top quality clips of Championship goals...

kyro7 wrote:

That's one of the one's Laurencio liked, done by a professional.

It was hard, but I managed to resist a wank. Nice work.