*Playmakers Best Premier League Team* - *RB* - ****Voting***

Gary Neville

Glen Johnson

If Johnson wins this

Melchiot.

I cannot believe two people have voted for Johnson.

Why didn't you put Rob Jones in the poll?

Rob Jones?

I shouldn't of put Finnan in the poll fuck sake forgot he played for Liverpool, and Lauren, fucking hell. Only one player can represent their team in voting, to make it equally fair.

Gary Neville.

Look at most of the Liverpool fans voting for Johnson.

Does everybody think my new two rules make it fair?

Only one player can be represented in voting from their team who are in the voting poll.
A player must have made at least 100 premier league appearences to be nominated.

crump wrote:Does everybody think my new two rules make it fair?

Only one player can be represented in voting from their team who are in the voting poll.
A player must have made at least 100 premier league appearences to be nominated.

The second one is, I don't understand the point of the first one to be honest.

Hmm, I think it makes it as fair as possible. I'll see how nominations go for centre-back, may scrap it. Probably will scrap it, the second one is brang in because I'm pissed off of joke voters.

I'd prefer it to be the best players get put in the poll. If anything, this could make votes more bias as the fan of a club will only have one player to vote for.

Rob Jones should have been in the poll.

I know mate, sorry completley forgot, but I couldn't see him winning anyway tbf.

crump wrote:I know mate, sorry completley forgot, but I couldn't see him winning anyway tbf.

He would of probably got Johnsons' votes + mine and Cadburys

CoVkId01 wrote:I'd prefer it to be the best players get put in the poll. If anything, this could make votes more bias as the fan of a club will only have one player to vote for.

Those were my thoughts exactly.

"WHERE IS SAGNA!"

All the players who have been in the polls have had over 100 appearances, not sure about Niemi though.

crump wrote:Does everybody think my new two rules make it fair?

Only one player can be represented in voting from their team who are in the voting poll.
A player must have made at least 100 premier league appearences to be nominated.

Make it two. Some positions will have a few players who were very good in that position but played for the same team. Just don't add strange options like Lauren or Finnan. Judge yourself whether they should be added or not.

Glen Johnson

Oh no it is level. We have to save the vote before the team becomes a farce.

Just include Johnson's votes on to Melchiot's . Then Melchiot will win.

TheMooseHunter wrote:not sure about Niemi though.

yeah, 106 for Saints and 62 for Fulham, I think there all in the PL.

cheesy wrote:Just don't add strange options like Lauren or Finnan. Judge yourself whether they should be added or not.

I don't think Finnan is a strange choice, a consistently good right back, making over 200 appearances for Liverpool and 145 league appearences for Fulham (alot being in the PL)

Did you seriously just put Glen Johnson in this list ?

cheesy wrote:

crump wrote:Does everybody think my new two rules make it fair?

Only one player can be represented in voting from their team who are in the voting poll.
A player must have made at least 100 premier league appearences to be nominated.

Make it two. Some positions will have a few players who were very good in that position but played for the same team. Just don't add strange options like Lauren or Finnan. Judge yourself whether they should be added or not.

Why even make it 2? Might as well just not have that rule at all, I don't see how it helps.

Johnson is winning

Zzonked wrote:

cheesy wrote:

crump wrote:Does everybody think my new two rules make it fair?

Only one player can be represented in voting from their team who are in the voting poll.
A player must have made at least 100 premier league appearences to be nominated.

Make it two. Some positions will have a few players who were very good in that position but played for the same team. Just don't add strange options like Lauren or Finnan. Judge yourself whether they should be added or not.

Why even make it 2? Might as well just not have that rule at all, I don't see how it helps.

I can understand where he is coming from though. In the nomination thread, some fans just nominate lots of their own players. Even if it were up to 3 it could maybe be okay.

It's easy to work out for yourself who deserves to be in the poll and when people are taking the piss. You should be able to nominate as many players as you want then the most commmon out of what people say should get put in the poll, like I did on EA

Lee Dixon