Join the forum, it's quick and easy

Would you like to react to this message? Create an account in a few clicks or log in to continue.


+26
Potato-7
Grenade
SBSP
Ricardo
El Jefe
Lux
Carlos Jenkinson
Theo Filippo
luke.
Cadbury
Fanatic
Marvin
Royal
Jord
Zzonked
ayvee1
Dean
Kuled
Barton
ResurrectionRooney
Pippo
dena
Laurencio
JamieB
lesser21
Jamie
30 posters

    Yes or No.

    Poll

    Would you have stopped the ball with your hands?

    [ 33 ]
    Yes or No. - Page 6 Bar_left65%Yes or No. - Page 6 Bar_right [65%] 
    [ 18 ]
    Yes or No. - Page 6 Bar_left35%Yes or No. - Page 6 Bar_right [35%] 

    Total Votes: 51
    Anonymous
    Guest
    Guest


    Yes or No. - Page 6 Empty Re: Yes or No.

    Post by Guest Fri Apr 08, 2011 10:24 am

    ahlycotc wrote:
    polska. wrote:
    Cheating is intentionally getting an unfair challenge. Did Suarez intentionally handball it? Yes. Did he gain an unfair advantage? Yes. Because it was 100% going in, but now Ghana had to step 11 yards back with the possibility of missing the penalty.

    Fouls can be cheating or not, it depends on the type of punishment. If the punishment fits the crime and does not give the other team an unnecessary disadvantage, then it's not cheating.

    We aren't going by Websters definition of what cheating is. We are going by the FIFA rulebooks. Handball is a foul, and thus should be treated as such.

    Where in the FIFA rulebook does it list out cheating offenses or defines cheating?
    It doesn't.

    It however says that Handball = Foul.
    fluffy_kittens
    fluffy_kittens
     
     


    Posts : 3190
    Location : New Jersey, USA

    Yes or No. - Page 6 Empty Re: Yes or No.

    Post by fluffy_kittens Fri Apr 08, 2011 10:29 am

    polska. wrote:
    ahlycotc wrote:
    polska. wrote:
    Cheating is intentionally getting an unfair challenge. Did Suarez intentionally handball it? Yes. Did he gain an unfair advantage? Yes. Because it was 100% going in, but now Ghana had to step 11 yards back with the possibility of missing the penalty.

    Fouls can be cheating or not, it depends on the type of punishment. If the punishment fits the crime and does not give the other team an unnecessary disadvantage, then it's not cheating.

    We aren't going by Websters definition of what cheating is. We are going by the FIFA rulebooks. Handball is a foul, and thus should be treated as such.

    Where in the FIFA rulebook does it list out cheating offenses or defines cheating?
    It doesn't.

    It however says that Handball = Foul.

    exactly
    Anonymous
    Guest
    Guest


    Yes or No. - Page 6 Empty Re: Yes or No.

    Post by Guest Fri Apr 08, 2011 10:36 am

    polska. wrote:
    ahlycotc wrote:
    polska. wrote:
    Cheating is intentionally getting an unfair challenge. Did Suarez intentionally handball it? Yes. Did he gain an unfair advantage? Yes. Because it was 100% going in, but now Ghana had to step 11 yards back with the possibility of missing the penalty.

    Fouls can be cheating or not, it depends on the type of punishment. If the punishment fits the crime and does not give the other team an unnecessary disadvantage, then it's not cheating.

    We aren't going by Websters definition of what cheating is. We are going by the FIFA rulebooks. Handball is a foul, and thus should be treated as such.

    Where in the FIFA rulebook does it list out cheating offenses or defines cheating?
    It doesn't.

    It however says that Handball = Foul.

    So?

    It also says simulation (aka diving) is an unsporting behavior. Do you consider diving as not cheating?
    Anonymous
    Guest
    Guest


    Yes or No. - Page 6 Empty Re: Yes or No.

    Post by Guest Fri Apr 08, 2011 11:13 am

    I consider it unsportsmanlike and unprofessional as well as a tactical foul, but I don't consider it cheating.

    Sponsored content


    Yes or No. - Page 6 Empty Re: Yes or No.

    Post by Sponsored content


      Current date/time is Sat Nov 23, 2024 11:15 pm