It was me
+39
ricky//habana
El_indian
Mason
Ben 10
Andy
dena
Mal
Paulinho
Scuba Steve
Childish Logic
Jordi
samiz
SBSP
Jeff
Drake
VivaRonaldoLAD
Keanoo
Mustangt125
drivescore
LiamB_14
Mouse
Uncle John from Jamaica
Dean
Carlos Jenkinson
Barton
Steadman
Van Wolfswinkel
Laurencio
Benitez
Gegilworld93
lvrpl4life
ResurrectionRooney
Zzonked
Cadbury
Danny
Kuled
Scouser_Dave
Theo Filippo
Jord
43 posters
Liverpool vs Man United | FA Cup
Poll
...
- [ 8 ]
[67%]
- [ 0 ]
- [0%]
- [ 4 ]
- [33%]
Total Votes: 12
Jord-
- Formerly known as : SUPAH BURNLEY!
Posts : 33665
Location : Equestria
Supports : Liverpool FC
ricky//habana-
- Posts : 630
Location : Wales.
Supports : DFA79
Loving some of the responses here.
Undeserved? How many chances did United have again?
Parking the bus? Nah, you're right, we'll just attack carelessly without a defensive midfielder.
Some of you need to engage your brain before posting.
Undeserved? How many chances did United have again?
Parking the bus? Nah, you're right, we'll just attack carelessly without a defensive midfielder.
Some of you need to engage your brain before posting.
ResurrectionRooney-
- Posts : 17681
Supports : United
Completely dominated the game, lost because of an unfair goal and a mistake from the goalkeeper. That's the sort of shit that happens in Cup games. That leukaemia referee should be banned, he's clearly only getting games because the PGMO feel sorry for him.
Guest- Guest
Laurencio wrote:God damnit. Taking off Scholes was the biggest mistake we did all match, well aside from playing two poachers instead of someone who could help us hold the ball up
Well done Liverpool though. I reckon they will win the FA Cup and the Carling cup now. Finally realised how to play Carroll too. Compeltely destroyed us in the latter part of the second half... Congrats.....
Well said
And i agree United were the better team and deserved at least a replay.
Guest- Guest
ResurrectionRooney wrote:Completely dominated the game, lost because of an unfair goal and a mistake from the goalkeeper. That's the sort of shit that happens in Cup games. That leukaemia referee should be banned, he's clearly only getting games because the PGMO feel sorry for him.
LiamB_14-
- Formerly known as : Mong.
Posts : 624
Can't believe everyone is ignoring the fact that Maxi should have been off 
Had a United player gotten away with it and went on to win you wouldn't hear the end of it 
Had a United player gotten away with it and went on to win you wouldn't hear the end of it 
Laurencio-
- Posts : 8730
Age : 36
Location : La Paz, Bolivia
Supports : Rosenborg, ManUtd
LiamB_14 wrote:Can't believe everyone is ignoring the fact that Maxi should have been off
Meh. It wasn't a dangerous foul and it kept the game running nicely. Ref did right there IMO. We only have ourseleves and our rubbishness without scholes and lack of quality in the final third to blame for not winning this.
Guest- Guest
You should never blame the referee to compensate for what your team lacks.LiamB_14 wrote:Can't believe everyone is ignoring the fact that Maxi should have been off
Barton-
- Formerly known as : JMB_94
Posts : 10066
Age : 30
Yeah i forgot about that challenge from Maxi, still a lot of uncertainty surrounding the two-footed tackle rule i think. 
Guest- Guest
I thought Maxi would have been sent off.
Relieved to see him subbed quickly after.
Relieved to see him subbed quickly after.
Guest- Guest
ResurrectionRooney wrote:Completely dominated the game, lost because of an unfair goal and a mistake from the goalkeeper. That's the sort of shit that happens in Cup games. That leukaemia referee should be banned, he's clearly only getting games because the PGMO feel sorry for him.
BBC Statistics ..
Possession: Liverpool 43% - 57% Man United
Shots on Target: Liverpool 9 - 3 Man United
Off Target: Liverpool 5 - 6 Man United
Corners: Liverpool 5 - 1 Man United
Yeah, erm .. I don't think so.
Guest- Guest
They are consistently inconsistent on the matter. This referee was probably the most lenient referee I have ever seen, and he was excellent.Barton wrote:Yeah i forgot about that challenge from Maxi, still a lot of uncertainty surrounding the two-footed tackle rule i think.
Kuled-
- Posts : 55235
Age : 28
We had the ball more in the second half and were the better team.
Possession: Liverpool 43% - 57% Man United
Guest- Guest
Disgusting.ResurrectionRooney wrote:That leukaemia referee should be banned, he's clearly only getting games because the PGMO feel sorry for him.
ResurrectionRooney-
- Posts : 17681
Supports : United
There is no two footed tackle rule, and Scott, I don't know about you but I actually watched the game, rather than manipulating statistics.
Guest- Guest
Manipulating statistics 
Guest- Guest
I demand that RR apologises for his outrageously horrendous comment about the referee's illness.
ResurrectionRooney-
- Posts : 17681
Supports : United
InGlennyWeTrust wrote:I demand that RR apologises for his outrageously horrendous comment about the referee's illness.
It's the truth, he was one of the strictest referees in the Premier League before his illness, since he returned a season and a half ago he's given a grand total of one red card. I'm not saying I wish he had died of it or anything, I don't really care about that, but he shouldn't be refereeing top level fixtures.
Last edited by ResurrectionRooney on Sun Jan 29, 2012 2:23 am; edited 1 time in total
Mouse-
- Posts : 17009
Age : 28
Location : Cymru
Supports : Sweden Women's National Handball Team
Liverpool won....Man United lost. It's done.
Benitez-
- Posts : 4952
Location : Antonella Roccuzzo <3
Supports : Antonella Roccuzzo <3
InGlennyWeTrust wrote:I demand that RR apologises for his outrageously horrendous comment about the referee's illness.
Typical behavior from a United fan
Guest- Guest
"That leukaemia referee."ResurrectionRooney wrote:InGlennyWeTrust wrote:I demand that RR apologises for his outrageously horrendous comment about the referee's illness.
It's the truth, he was one of the strictest referees in the Premier League before his illness, since he returned a season and a half ago he's given a grand total of one red card.
What a pointless, classless, and disgusting insult to throw about.
Guest- Guest
Karma's a bitch.
LiamB_14-
- Formerly known as : Mong.
Posts : 624
Liverpool's goals came from a hoofed goal kick and a hoofed corner kick. If that is what they class to prove they "dominated the game" then you have to pity them.
Clearly they must learn the findamentals of football, what requires a great deal of skill, and what doesn't. because you could cleary see a significant gulf in class between the quality of both teams. United's play was vastly superior.
Clearly they must learn the findamentals of football, what requires a great deal of skill, and what doesn't. because you could cleary see a significant gulf in class between the quality of both teams. United's play was vastly superior.
Guest- Guest
What are the findementals of football?LiamB_14 wrote:Liverpool's goals came from a hoofed goal kick and a hoofed corner kick. If that is what they class to prove they "dominated the game" then you have to pity them.
Clearly they must learn the findamentals of football, what requires a great deal of skill, and what doesn't. because you could cleary see a significant gulf in class between the quality of both teams. United's play was vastly superior.
Enlighten me.
Guest- Guest
LiamB_14 wrote:Liverpool's goals came from a hoofed goal kick and a hoofed corner kick. If that is what they class to prove they "dominated the game" then you have to pity them.
Clearly they must learn the findamentals of football, what requires a great deal of skill, and what doesn't. because you could cleary see a significant gulf in class between the quality of both teams. United's play was vastly superior.
Scoring more than your opponent results in victory?
Barton-
- Formerly known as : JMB_94
Posts : 10066
Age : 30
InGlennyWeTrust wrote:They are consistently inconsistent on the matter. This referee was probably the most lenient referee I have ever seen, and he was excellent.Barton wrote:Yeah i forgot about that challenge from Maxi, still a lot of uncertainty surrounding the two-footed tackle rule i think.
Maybe that's the way to go about things, but correct me if i'm wrong, the rules state that all two-footed tackles should warrant a red card? If that's the case then Maxi should've been sent off, end of story.
ResurrectionRooney-
- Posts : 17681
Supports : United
It's pertinent. How can the World Cup Final referee be stood on the sidelines while someone who has only been appointed because he had a disease referees the game? How?InGlennyWeTrust wrote:"That leukaemia referee."ResurrectionRooney wrote:
It's the truth, he was one of the strictest referees in the Premier League before his illness, since he returned a season and a half ago he's given a grand total of one red card.
What a pointless, classless, and disgusting insult to throw about.
drivescore-
- Posts : 1336
Age : 29
Location : Toronto
Supports : Arsenal FC, FC Bayern Munich, Liverpool FC
LiamB_14 wrote:Can't believe everyone is ignoring the fact that Maxi should have been off
It was the correct decision, you can't send off somebody for that.Kompany's sending off was wrong, Glen Johnson performed a similar challenge against Manchester City and was not sent off and now Maxi does it against Manchester United and is not sent off.Happy to see the referees get some sense in their decision making from time to time.
ResurrectionRooney-
- Posts : 17681
Supports : United
Barton wrote:InGlennyWeTrust wrote:They are consistently inconsistent on the matter. This referee was probably the most lenient referee I have ever seen, and he was excellent.
Maybe that's the way to go about things, but correct me if i'm wrong, the rules state that all two-footed tackles should warrant a red card? If that's the case then Maxi should've been sent off, end of story.
That's not the fucking rules, honestly they're not hard to come by, just Google for 'Laws of the Game', you can read them in less than an hour.
Laurencio-
- Posts : 8730
Age : 36
Location : La Paz, Bolivia
Supports : Rosenborg, ManUtd
Whut. The referee was good. One of the best these fixtures have had in recent years. Could have decided the game in our favour by sending off maxi for a bit of a reckless tackle, but not giving him a red is completely justified. Saved the game.
